Baby Showers

People really just plan their own?

24

Re: People really just plan their own?

  • didi808 said:
    I've never known anyone who expected for other people to throw them a baby shower. Ha! Must be a Miami thing. ETA: honestly, here everyone plans their own shower. In fact, many people invite you to their shower and ask you to pay $20 (for example) to cover the cost in addition to a gift. This is usually because most people host their showers at a venue that cost money per plate. I just think it's interesting that to all of you it is so offensive to throw your own shower when in all seriousness that's just the norm in my area.
    image
    DS1: BFP 04/03/11 | EDD 12/02/11 | born 11/21/11 
    DS2: BFP 02/09/13 | EDD 10/26/13 | said goodbye 06/02/13
  • Loading the player...
  • I've always thought charging your guests was tacky, but apparently the whole thing is! Lol
  • didi808 said:

    I've never known anyone who expected for other people to throw them a baby shower. Ha! Must be a Miami thing.

    ETA: honestly, here everyone plans their own shower. In fact, many people invite you to their shower and ask you to pay $20 (for example) to cover the cost in addition to a gift. This is usually because most people host their showers at a venue that cost money per plate.

    I just think it's interesting that to all of you it is so offensive to throw your own shower when in all seriousness that's just the norm in my area.

    Please stop saying its a Miami thing. It's not. Just because there are some people who have poor etiquette, please don't disgrace everyone in the whole city with it.
  • Sorry you don't like it but I've lived here my whole life and have never heard of someone else throwing you a shower.
  • @Peony1982 Why didn't I know you were a Miami girl?  My mom is from the Shores and I have some cousins on my dads side that grew up there and went to St. Rose and Curly.  Small world.
  • Phew, that is good to know.  I was about to start calling Miami, Tacky Town.  
  • @Peony1982 Why didn't I know you were a Miami girl?  My mom is from the Shores and I have some cousins on my dads side that grew up there and went to St. Rose and Curly.  Small world.

    Well, I was born there but left before high school.. Still lots of family, though! I went to Country Day, dad to Shores Elementary/MCDS, Mom went to Notre Dame (Now part of Curley). Lots of friends did St. Rose. Super small world!

    At least we know the Shores does etiquette! ;)
  • Peony1982 said:



    @Peony1982 Why didn't I know you were a Miami girl?  My mom is from the Shores and I have some cousins on my dads side that grew up there and went to St. Rose and Curly.  Small world.




    Well, I was born there but left before high school.. Still lots of family, though! I went to Country Day, dad to Shores Elementary/MCDS, Mom went to Notre Dame (Now part of Curley). Lots of friends did St. Rose. Super small world!

    At least we know the Shores does etiquette! ;)


    My mom went to Notre Dame!!! Lol.
  • My husband wants a "baby-q". Is it bad etiquette for him to throw us one in honor of our baby? He loves to grill. It's just fun for him.
  • Latina211508Latina211508 member
    edited July 2015
    I've thrown my own shower, not a big deal. Has nothing to do with being gift grabby etc. Sometimes people don't have someone offering to give them a shower, so it's understandable that some still want to have a shower for their baby. Honestly I love just having the family together. Playing games, welcoming the baby. I never put on the invitation (must bring gift). That's all up to the person. I have never asked or demanded. My mil was going to throw me a shower. She set a date and I invited family etc. But then she didn't really do anything. So I just took over. I just had fun planning games, hanging decorations, making food etc. I even bought game prizes. Showers are all fun to me whether someone planned it the self or not. It's really not that big of a thing.
  • @latina211508 If no one offers, you don't get one.  A shower is a gift, not an entitlement.  Further, while you would hopefully never stoop that low to require gifts on an invitation (probably the only thing tackier than planning your own shower), showers are gift giving events.  It's basic common knowledge.  This is the reason that it's gift grabby to throw it for yourself. 

    Can your family only get together because of a pregnancy?  Of course not.  If that was all you wanted then you would just throw a family get together, not centered around your pregnancy.


  • @MyCousinVinny I love you. That is all.
  • @MyCousinVinny I love you. That is all.

    :\">
  • @OliveOyl2014 - I'm just saying it could be seen the way by some not that it should be seen that way always. For some women who maybe are in financial need, it might be about the gifts - and of course they should be gracious and not annoying. But for some it might be more to bring people together and celebrate- the registry being an if you want to bring something( because let's get real, people will know you are pregnant and might want to bring something) but the gifting not being the goal and expectation.

    The goal of rant was just to say there can't be one set of applied rules for everyone. It's unfair to attack so repeatedly and unnecessarily harshly just because it isn't what one would do for themselves. That being said of course there are people that get completely out of hand, those exist in every situation.
  • @MyCousinVinny not necessarily. For example I have a large extended family who just found out I was pregnant at another family event earlier this month. At parting they were all "let us know when the baby shower is!". They couldn't care less who threw the baby shower, they just figure it's coming,let me know. If for some reason I had no1 to throw me shower and abided by what many of you were saying ( ie throwing myself a bbq and noting no gifts required) they would be confused and possibly offended. If I didn't have one at all, they would also feel left out. What I'm stressing is different situations call for different plans of actions. For 3 of my cousins baby showers I could not tell you who put up the money or how the work was divided up. And I'm close to all 3 of them and clearly I was not all up in their planning committee. There was no boo hoo thank you speech for someone else's efforts so I assume preggo was all up in he planning and prepping. Nobody cared and the showers were great. For many people when a close person to them is pregnant they expect to be invited to a shower to celebrate. All I'm saying is pushing some weird "come celebrate but don't do what you expect to do at any other baby is coming celebration" can also be off putting. I don't think most guests give a crap who put the money an effort down for the shower. They go as an expectation and I don't think it's "considerate" to make things weird for them bc of some behind the scenes issues of etiquette, my sister/mom won't throw me one, will they think I'm gift grabby...blah blah blah. Let me final note- yes there are crazy preggos out there who push their registries at people, demand someone plan their shower to an extravagant extent, or have whatever these stupid silent showers are (I saw that on some post somewhere). Those are outliers, weirdos- I'm not speaking for or considering those people.
    I think you're placing way too much importance on a baby shower.  While people may say, "Oh, can't wait for the shower!", they probably aren't waiting with baited breath for that invitation.  

    Furthermore, if there is no shower, how could they feel left out?  From what?  Can people really not just get together without the expectation of gifts?  Also, you mention running the risk of offending them.  Unless you know that every.single.person that would be in attendance is accepting of this party being thrown by the MTB, you can't possibly know that you won't be offending anyone.

    Personally, I'd rather a few people be butthurt that there is no shower than a lot of people being offended that I threw my own gift giving party.  

    Plainly put, while you may not care about what goes on behind the scenes, there are some people that do.  And unless you know for sure they are okay with it, you run the risk of appearing rude to them.

    But hey, you do you.
  • JenJohn228JenJohn228 member
    edited September 2015
  • JenJohn228JenJohn228 member
    edited September 2015
  • SUPER ZOMBIES!

    I lurk. I snark. I offer sound advice if you're not BSC. You may not like me. I'm okay with it.





  • SUPER ZOMBIES!

    SUPER RELEVANT AND NOT AT ALL BEAT TO DEATH ZOMBIE HORSES.
  • This content has been removed.
  • edited October 2015



    Some people are not fortunate enough to have family or friends that are willing and able to step up and host a shower for them.  I had plenty of people who expressed interest in attending a baby shower for me, but no one would offer to host it and I wasn't going to ask anyone to do it for me.  A good friend of mine asked what my plans were and when I told her that I did not have one planned at all, she graciously offered to do it.  In hindsight though, I really feel as if my family on both sides just expected me to throw my own because I know that neither my mother or my in laws were in a position to throw one for me.

    It may not be proper etiquette for people to throw their own shower, but unless I was willing to step up and pony up the time and expenses to throw a party for them, then I have no room to sit back and pass judgment on others. You should just be thankful and consider yourself blessed to have friends and family who are generous enough and have the means to throw a party in your honor. 


    I just asked a question about this.  Sounds like it's pretty taboo.  I have no one to throw one and have never had one before.  It's not about gifts.  It's just to not feel so alone.  


    -----------------

    @EstrogenFest Make friends with other moms in your area.

    Showers are gift giving events. So you hosting your own is you asking people to bring you gifts.

    I don't understand how a couple hours long party is going to keep you from feeling alone?

    Edited for quoting fail.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"