Need honest opinions...

deikenbe

My husband and I are going to try and keep our pregnancy a secret until I start showing, but I'm getting antsy for name opinions. We have an 18 month old named Everett and we like older sounding names.

Let me know what you think...
Girl options
Oakley
or
Emrey

Boy options
Oliver
or
Bennett

bbiutmcph

Both boy names are nice. I'm gonna be honest both those for girls are really really bad.

deikenbe

Yea I'm not too sure on the girl names either...any girl name suggestions?

deikenbe

We were also thinking about Barrett for a boy

lm45678

I like Emery/Emory for a girl.

I like both boy names, but think Oliver is a little less matchy.

Other Girl Options: (it seems like no frills not super girly is your style?)
Avery
Quinn
Emerson
Ainsley
Eloise
Elodie
Brynn
Blair
Sloane
Paige
Leighton
Lauren
Peyton
Hadley
Piper
Poppy
Riley
Mairen
Maeve

bbiutmcph

I like something with more name history yet spunk. With Everett which I love

Audra
Dahlia
Cara
Tallulah
Corrine
Miranda
Linnea
Rosa
Wren
Phoebe
Bianca
Ingrid
Serafina
Audrianna
Clara
Flora
Kendra

deikenbe

Emerson is cute maybe call her Emmy for short

mb0112

Oliver for the boy, and the suggestions from other posters for the girl. I really don't like your girl names and don't find them "older sounding". Not trying to be rude just honest as you asked for. Of the girl suggestions above, my favorites are:
Audra
Corinne
Phoebe
Clara

Adding suggestions:
Audrey
Rosalind
Amelia
Florence

deikenbe

I like the girl suggestions! I'm just having a hard time picking one or two that I absolutely love

magsugar13

oliver

and another girl name

Mamabeagle

Oliver is good. Everything else not so much.

Bennett can be a girls name as well and I prefer it as one personally.

parenthood4

Love Oliver. Bennett is okay but it's a bit matchy with Everett.

Agree about the girl names, a lot of people gave nice suggestions!

LNic5

For boy I love Oliver. Everett and Bennett are very similar to me. The girls names are honestly not very good.

Everett and Adelaide
Everett and Willa
Everett and Rosalie
Everett and Calista
Everett and Mila
Everett and Laila
Everett and Gemma
Everett and Natalia
Everett and Michaela
Everett and Alena

agerstner

I like the boys names but would choose Oliver as it's less matchy.

No human, especially a girl should be named Oakley. Sorry. Emery or Emry is ok. Emrey is spelled wrong..

KaLikeAWind

There have been some very good girl name suggestions. I'm behind a lot of them except for Emerson, because I don't think girls should have names that basically mean 'son of...'. I like @bbiutmcph list, its got a lot of good choices on it (the other lists do too, that is just my favorite list). Of your boy names, Oliver is my choice.

neverblushed

Oakley is a sunglasses brand.  It just sounds weird to use as a first name.  It's like naming your child Cheerio or Mazda.

Emrey seems like it's misspelled or made up.  You could use Emory like the university or Emery like the nail file, but both of those are kind of weird as well.

Both boy names are fine.  I say keep thinking of girl names.

That1didntcount

I think Emery definitely over Emrey. Emrey looks like it is misspelled, agree with PP's.

ClaireBear90

Oliver is one of my favorites that DH has permanently vetoed, so that gets my vote! I think it goes great with Everett too. I'd avoid another boy name ending in t.

Oakley . . . might as well use Annie Oakley, because that's all I can think of. Emery is a man's name and the only Emery I've known is a very grumpy old man. I would hate to see that name stuck on a sweet baby girl!

Parker16772

I like both boy names but not a fan of either girl name. What about Everly or Evelyn?