By this I mean any wedding that cuts BIG corners to save money, like holding it on a Friday night/Sunday evening (or, even worse, any of the weekday nights), a cash-only bar, hors d'oeuvres instead of a meal, asking for money instead of gifts, etc.
This has been on my mind as one of my BFF's just sent our group of friends an email saying she's scrapping her original wedding plans and going with something "simpler" to "save money." This includes some of the above-listed sins. I'm not sure if it makes a difference, but the money-saving thing is all about principle rather than necessity.
What say you? Are "money saving" weddings tacky, or are you cool with them?
Re: What's your opinion on "saving money" weddings?
Married 7/15
BFP #2 2/18/16
Me: 32 & DH: 37
BFP #2: 2/8/16 - EDD 10/20/16
IT'S A BOY!!!!
DS Born 10/16/16
Me: 32 & DH: 37
BFP #2: 2/8/16 - EDD 10/20/16
IT'S A BOY!!!!
DS Born 10/16/16
If your friends want to celebrate with you, they'll understand. Anyone who's going to be a stink about how you celebrate your own wedding and what you can afford doesn't need to be there.
Also, I don't get the big deal about a cash bar. I had no bar, and my friends didn't understand why. They begged me to have a cash bar cause they knew I couldn't afford an open bar. But in the end it was too expensive and we had a dry wedding. We all went out for drinks afterwards.
All that being said, I would never ask for cash. That's always tacky. I also hate that dance where you have to pay to dance with the bride. I skipped that one.
Every wedding I've ever been to had to cut a corner somewhere to afford everything. And even if it was a bummer, I didn't care because it wasn't my wedding.
ETA: typed cash when I meant to type open. Sense: what is that?
Me: 32 & DH: 37
BFP #2: 2/8/16 - EDD 10/20/16
IT'S A BOY!!!!
DS Born 10/16/16
A friend is a wedding planner, and was telling me about her Soup Bride. They served salad, breadsticks, and 7 kinds of soup. Apparently it was a disaster-people got smashed because they weren't eating real food, there were bathroom issues because so many people had to pee. Ugh.
I do think that a cash bar should be avoided at all costs, and that guests should never be made to contribute financially to their evening (through suggested cash gifts, paying for a meal at a shower, or a cash bar). I don't think a guest should have to pull out a wallet.
Now, if it's inconvenient for someone who's been asked to be IN the wedding, that's different. I think if you had one plan and asked someone to be a part of it, you shouldn't make any changes without speaking to your party first. That would definitely be rude.
I agree, I wasn't really talking about the little things. I guess I went off on my own little tangent because of the whole open/cash/no bar thing. Lol.
Me: 32 & DH: 37
BFP #2: 2/8/16 - EDD 10/20/16
IT'S A BOY!!!!
DS Born 10/16/16
A full meal for me is a must, I know I get super cranky when hungry so. Feed people.
A lot of couples live together for years before getting hitched, so I get not wanting to register for stuff they already have. It's tough to be tactful about asking for cash, so my hubby and I made a honeyfund website and it was great. Guests felt like they were contributing and buying something and we have cash to spend on the honeymoon.
At the end of the day, if you really want to save money, elope or keep it small.
Edited cause TB posted before I was finished: I do think cheap weddings are tacky. If I couldn't afford to treat my guests appropriately, I would simply cut the guest list until I could.
My SIL is about to have her second wedding. She's doing it on the cheap and it's already getting on my nerves. She asked me to make her cake (for free), which I don't mind, but she picked out something HUGE and elaborate. Rude. She also asked a few ladies from the church to make "bring a dish." The wedding is not even at the church. So essentially, she just asked some of her guests to bring a dish. Also, they're having a cash bar, which personally, I don't have a problem with, but it just adds to their cheapness.... And the most egregious offense of all: they've started a Go Fund Me account for their "wedding fund." No. Just NO.
ETA: I believe that cash bars are pretty tacky. There are plenty of ways to save on alcohol costs, or just forgo it altogether if it's a huge deal. And I firmly believe guests should get at least a meal. If I could do it (twice!) on my budget, anyone can make something work. All the other stuff doesn't bother me. If I can't get to your weird wedding time/date I just won't come. No biggie.
Oct 16 March Siggy Challenge
Oct 16 Feb Siggy Challenge
I have a close-ish friend who has to pay for her entire wedding, so she is only inviting a very small number of people to her wedding, and having a big backyard party a few weeks later.
I completely understand her need to save money and at least she is not trying to invite everyone and then not having enough food/space/etc for them, but I am sad that I won't get to physically see her say I do.
But you know, my opinion is it's THEIR day and as long as they are happy, it's cool. I am actually going to be on vacation for my friend's wedding and couldn't go even if I was invited.
There are ways to cut cost in way guests will barely notice as long as the details are executed in a creative way.
In 2010 we had a wonderful Saturday 11am church wedding ceremony with a 12:30 luncheon afterwards at a nice restaurant with a banquet room. We had a champagne toast and open Bar from 12:30-2:30. Salad and bread served at 1:00 and a plated lunch each guest chose on their invitation was served at 1:30. We also hired a 3 piece band to entertain our guests while they ate. Most people left by 3:30 aside from family and friends who chose to take the party downstairs from the banquet room to the bar. Our guests knew that we had a flight that night to our honeymoon destination and a luncheon reception seemed both practical and financially beneficial. Our reception had a touch of all the traditional elements like cake cutting, first dance and guest table gifts but we left out the "party" details like a DJ, Garter/Bouquet toss that seemed more appropriate for an evening reception. We still hear what a great time our guests had even 5 years later.
My family and friends came to our Friday night wedding and had a great time eating from a small town caterer and dancing. We had 2 kegs and some bottles of wine. We spent a total of less than $4000 on the whole thing. Why can't people just be happy for the bride and groom and go to celebrate instead of judging and criticizing? I seriously don't get it. I've never once thought badly of a cash bar at a wedding. If someone is seriously that offended about something happening at a wedding, don't go.
You and and I differ on whether a cash bar is ok, but who cares? That's what opinions are all about.
Also, easy on the judgement that people who spend more are going to be divorced 6 months later. You're mad at a perceived slight about money, but you have no problem going the other way and making a harsh judgement yourself?
anyone else, or inconvienincing anyone else.
DH and I were planning a big wedding, paying for t 100% and listening and worrying about everyone's options. We said screw it. Eloped at a local, gorgeous brewery, for free, without telling anyone. We had our photographer there. DH zipped up my dress, help me put on my shoes, bustled my dress and it was amazing. Our photographer was crying. We didn't have to worrying about anyone else, but us.
We had a backyard BBQ later that summer to celebrate and everyone kept telling us how much they wish they eloped and did what we did.
Just my thoughts.
Fell in love: Dec 2005 // Married: Feb 9, 2013
Little Miss Rosalie Harper--Born Jan 9th, 2014
I always hate excuses for poor behavior and poor hosting.If you don't have the money, have a simple park/court house/etc wedding instead. A guest shouldn't have to open their wallets at your wedding. A guest also shouldn't leave after a meal time to go somewhere else and eat. If you can only afford for your guests to have beer and wine, only offer beer and wine.
Dating: 10/3/08 | Married: 12/27/14
TTC #1: August 2015 | BFP: 2/3/16 | EDD: 10/7/16
DD: 10/5/16
TTC #2: September 2017 | BFP: 4/28/18 | EDD: 1/7/19
DS: 1/9/19
LFAF Summer 2016 Awards:
Me: 28 DH: 27
I wasn't feeling defensive of my own wedding; we had a blast. I just think that it's too bad people would rather not go to a wedding of someone they love than go to one with a cash bar. If a close friend had to cut me from their guest list because the other guests insisted on a full spread and unlimited drinks, I would be seriously hurt.
Overall, I think if you avoid the major faux pas, there's nothing wrong with having a budget friendly wedding. The trick is, like some others have said, cutting corners in places where it's not blatantly noticeable. Our best friends spend $5,000 on their wedding and had 300 guests. It was a wonderful wedding and no one noticed where they cut corners. They had a three course plated meal, two huge cakes, an ice cream and glass bottle coke station, and a fun photo booth. They cut costs by having the ceremony at the church and the reception in the church gym (both free), she ordered her flowers from Fresh Market (they were CHEAP and looked awesome), I made her cakes as my wedding gift to them, a family friend who was just starting out in the catering business did their food (they had never done a wedding of that size before, so they gave them a deep discount since it was kind of a guinea pig situation), and they didn't do favors (who even cares about wedding favors anyway?) I say all that to say that it CAN be done. You can have a cheap wedding without having a tacky wedding. You just have to put a little thought into it
Cash bars are more common in Wales where I grew up, but then guests aren't expected to give super expensive wedding gifts. I live in Canada now where every wedding I've been to has had an open bar, but then as a guest you're expected to give at least $100 per guest as a gift. So maybe it depends where you are and the traditions in your area.
One thing I'm not a huge fan of is multiple showers and parties leading up to the wedding where gifts are expected...just like I don't think the couple should go into debt, I don't think guests should either
We did destination and found a great resort which had good reviews and a reasonable price, and did no gifts. We had an amazing trip with close friends and family (40 ppl), had the most relaxed wedding day and have some great memories:)
Sorry, couldn't resist, it's my favorite movie.
I think people should have the wedding they can afford but still look out for their guests. I would rather have a backyard BBQ wedding with a keg before making my guests buy their own drinks or not give them enough food. I think there are many ways you can do a wedding on a budget and still provide a good time for your guests.
Also it doesn't matter what day of the week someone has a wedding, but they need to understand that not everyone might be able to make it. I had a Friday wedding and was totally understanding that it meant some people couldn't come.
DD Born 5.9.12
MC March 2016@8.5w
Expecting #2 4/30/17