June 2015 Moms

Formula mama's

btm013btm013 member
edited July 2015 in June 2015 Moms
I know we have a feeding thread but I'm interested to hear what kind of formula you all are using as well as your experience. I know every baby is different but we are in the throes of figuring out a good formula for LO and I'd love to hear your feedback. Also, what are you doing to save money on your purchase? Where do purchase formula at the best price?

We started off using the similac supplement as that's what we were doing along with breast milk. The "taps" are runny dry so he is now exclusively on formula. We switched to the similac advance and he seemed to be tolerating it well but doing a lot of grunting during bowel movements (never constipated) and was occasionally gassy. He never really spit up though. Doctor said it was normal but being a FTM its hard to gauge what's really normal. We had a free sample of enfamil gentlease so we tried a few feedings of that. He spit up so much and had so many explosive poops that he's back on the advance.

As for saving money, my husband is truly the cheapest man alive so it's killing him to buy formula (although he of course understands it's out of my control). But he scours store ads and sales for the best prices. We also receive the manufacturer coupons for similac. We've found Walmart to be the cheapest so far but babies r us is running a special now which will be where we purchase our next batch.

Edited: LO is almost 6 weeks old.
«134567

Re: Formula mama's

  • Our baby was born at 10lbs 6oz and was taking 3oz at a feeding the first week! I didn't produce anywhere close to enough breastmilk and he wasn't latching well at all. We started on Enfamil Newborn but noticed a lot of fussiness with gas. My husband (also being very cheap) wanted to try Kirkland brand from Costco. We did a few days of that but it caused very runny stools and our baby started smelling very metallic. The pediatrician recommended Enfamil gentlease since the newborn caused so much fussiness. We've been using that for a few days now and his poops have returned to normal and he is WAY less fussy after feedings and spits up WAY less. Unfortunately, gentlease is more expensive... We will buy it at Costco with company coupons unless someone else has a really good sale on it.
  • Loading the player...
  • My LO started out on Similac Advanced (what the hospital put her on) and she was taking about an ounce and a half for the first week. She was super gassy and I could hear her belly rumbling all the time and she just looked like she was in pain so when we went to the first doctors appointment I told the pediatrician and he gave me several cans of Similac sensitive to switch her to. After about a week of the sensitive she still seemed miserable with gas so when we took her to her last appointment they said to try alimentum or gerber gentle so she is now on gerber gentle. I still think her belly doesn't tolerate it too well, but they want us to give it a little while before switching to soy. She is now taking 3-3 1/2 ounces per feeding. I give her those little remedies gas drops every now and then and it calms her down so that's why I think the gerber gentle is still upsetting her tummy. It's hard to keep giving them something when you know it's hurting their belly :/ but anyways. I've heard good thing about costco's formula, but idk...I haven't tried it. I feel like the formula battle is never ending lol
  • ksimo6ksimo6 member
    We have LO on Gerber gentle as well. He tolerates it ok but struggles pooping. He's transitioning to formula exclusively right now... And my daughter had trouble pooping in this transition too. We gave her a little pear juice until her body adjusted to the formula, and will start that with my son as well.

    We get formula online via amazon mom. 20% off and you can buy it in a four pack.

    You can also use your similac/ Gerber/ enfamil bucks at SAMs club...
    • Married 6/1/2012
    • BFP #1 - 11/17/2012 -  MC 12/10/2012
    • BFP #2 - 2/12/2013 - EDD 10/17/2013 - DD Born 10/10/2013
    • BFP #3 - 1/29/2014 - Ectopic pregnancy discovered 1/31/2014
    • BFP #4 - 9/28/2014 - EDD 6/4/2015 - DS Born 5/31/2015


  • With my twins we had them on Gerber Gentle for the first two months and than switched to Costco brand.

    We've been supplementing with Similac Sensitive and she seems to be doing fine. But she only gets about 2/4 oz a day of formula.
  • Since day three he's been taking four oz of Similac sensitive. He's farting soooo much and constantly fussy. He's always hungry too. I think four oz is alot but when I was eating mil gave him two bottles and stretched his poor tummy out.I think I'll have to switch. Were still in the hospital. Hopefully early next week we can come home.
  • Davila21Davila21 member
    edited July 2015
    I use enfamil newborn since that is what the hospital provided when he was born. I have not experienced any issues with it myself. I'm not sure if it's an option for you, but I am on WIC which provides 9 cans a month. It has definitely been a life saver as formula is pretty expensive regardless or where you buy it from.
  • btm013btm013 member
    ksimo6 said:

    We have LO on Gerber gentle as well. He tolerates it ok but struggles pooping. He's transitioning to formula exclusively right now... And my daughter had trouble pooping in this transition too. We gave her a little pear juice until her body adjusted to the formula, and will start that with my son as well.

    We get formula online via amazon mom. 20% off and you can buy it in a four pack.

    You can also use your similac/ Gerber/ enfamil bucks at SAMs club...

    Is all formula 20% off? I see diapers are off by that much but don't see the formula. I never knew Amazon mom existed!! Is it worth it?
  • Make sure to always ask for samples at the pediatrician office!
  • btm013btm013 member
    Haha oh I always do!! It's getting to the point where they just hand me a sample pack or two!
  • We started on similar advance, but she was very constipated (was only pooping once a week) and seemed very uncomfortable. Our doctor suggested Gerber soothe and it fixed everything. She now poops twice a day and only occasionally has uncomfortable gas.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • HoosOnFirstHoosOnFirst member
    edited July 2015
    Formula mom here! Thanks for starting this thread for us, I was hoping someone would :)

    We started with Enfamil Newborn but LO was gassy. We thought it was related to Palm oil in it. Switched to Similac, which doesn't. Gas got better at first, but back to being bad again :(

    I would love to go back to Enfamil since it's cheaper but DH is convinced Similac is still better, ugh. We've been getting a lot of coupons for $5 off a can, which helps. I'm finding them for roughly $27-$30/each before the coupon. (I'm in MA so possible regional cost differences).

    I'm a good 25 min drive from Target and Walmart, so I have not been able to check out their prices yet.

    We did try Similac Sensitive for a few days but then realized it was for lactose intolerance and stopped using it because we shouldn't have done that before consulting the pediatrician.
  • ksimo6ksimo6 member
    edited July 2015
    btm013 said:

    ksimo6 said:

    We have LO on Gerber gentle as well.

    We get formula online via amazon mom. 20% off and you can buy it in a four pack.

    You can also use your similac/ Gerber/ enfamil bucks at SAMs club...

    Is all formula 20% off? I see diapers are off by that much but don't see the formula. I never knew Amazon mom existed!! Is it worth it?
    We are HUGE prime users so the amazon mom discounts are additional perks for us. They have a subscribe and save program that gives you 15% off a shipment of five items or more... You decide how frequently you get it (monthly, bi-monthly...). I have found that TP, paper towel, hairspray, deodorant, diapers etc are comparable to target/ SAMs, if not cheaper on amazon via subscribe and save so I use it all the time.

    Yes- formula gets the same discounts as diapers.

    I know target offers a discount if you subscribe to items as well. I have not used it so I don't know much about it but it may be worth looking into.
    • Married 6/1/2012
    • BFP #1 - 11/17/2012 -  MC 12/10/2012
    • BFP #2 - 2/12/2013 - EDD 10/17/2013 - DD Born 10/10/2013
    • BFP #3 - 1/29/2014 - Ectopic pregnancy discovered 1/31/2014
    • BFP #4 - 9/28/2014 - EDD 6/4/2015 - DS Born 5/31/2015


  • LO is 11 days old. We are bfing and pumping and using formula. But I'm sure the majority of his diet is formula. We bf to start our feeding sessions, then pump and give him that, then we have 2 and half ounces of formula made up and finish with that. He doesn't always finish the bottle, but he does sometimes, and always takes at least half.

    We are using Similac Advanced, because we for two cans of it in the mail as samples and when the Dr told us to supplement it was right here. LO tolerates it pretty well, I think. He does spit up sometimes, but I think that's more from us giving him too much or not burping enough when we feed him. Stools seem normal, I guess (I don't know what an abnormal stool would be like). He does fart a fair amount, but his tummy doesn't seem to be upset usually. I think he's doing well on it. Well enough that I don't want to switch away right now.

    As for $, we haven't had to buy any yet. I have the feeling that we will probably end up continuing to use formula, even tho I really want to bf it seems like I'm not making much progress, just holding steady. I did get some manufacturer coupons from Similac that I will use, and I plan to keep watch at Target and Walmart for who has the better prices. I live in a really small town, so those are my only options other than a grocery store or a drugstore chain store or Amazon. I do have amazon mom, I haven't used it yet (we are well stocked on diapers right now and I didn't even look at formula prices as I wasn't thinking I would need it) but I wonder if the savings thru amazon mom (if any) would be better than using the coupons I get from similac.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • FYI Similac did not seem to be subscribe and save eligible on amazon, at least when I looked! I'm bummed. But also I don't think u can use the mail coupons so maybe for the best...
  • kkdb14kkdb14 member
    FTM here, was an exclusive pumper from day 4-day 21, and made the call that the stress of constantly pumping was beginning to make me a frustrated momma, so I switched to save my sanity and to make sure LO wasn't interacting with that version of myself.
    We started on Similac Sensitive simply because my mom had bought a can pre-LO, and I had gotten a can at the shower. We've since switched to Similac Total Comfort because Sensitive was giving her really painful gas. She still gets it pretty frequently, but it's not an all day ordeal anymore. She eats 4 oz every 3-3.5 hours during the day, and will sometimes go 5-6 at night.
    I've been planning on beginning to use Amazon Mom but hadn't yet. I'm glad some of you've had good experiences with it!
  • Does anyone recommend a brand of gas drops, or do you think store brand is fine? She's doing pretty good with her formula and gas, but she does have episodes during the night of painful gas. 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • We use little tummies gas drops but they all have the same active ingredient I believe. We just got a 3 pack on Amazon for 20 bucks
  • I'm so glad someone started this thread! We are using similac advance and LO is tolerating it well. He does get a little gassy occasionally but we do bicycle legs and that helps. He normally poops once a day. He will be 6 weeks tomorrow and is taking 4-5oz every 4 hours and about 6 hour stretches at night. I'm going to start buying formula at SAMs club. I signed up for similac coupons but still haven't received any.
  • rolson8947rolson8947 member
    edited July 2015
    @aliciac2008 we use Little Remedies gas drops. The pediatrician recommended gas drops or gripe water so when we went to the pharmacy we asked the pharmacist which gas drops he recommended and he said in his opinion Little Remedies was one of the best. I'm sure others are good too, but those seem to work really well for our LO :)
  • We've been formula feeding since week 2 using Similac Advance. Our pediatrician recommended it and she hasn't had any trouble thus far. In fact, as far as poop goes she still poops just as often as she did when on breast milk, so I think that's probably a good thing - or at least I'm certainly not worried about constipation issues at this point.

    We just bought a case of 6 formula containers (I forget how many oz they are) from Amazon. We're Prime and Mom members to get the 20% off diapers and 2 day shipping but I didn't see a "subscribe and save" for the Similac formula. Maybe I should look again because it sounded like someone was utilizing that. Is that only certain brands maybe?
  • @swaugh14 I did not see it either under subscribe and save so I think unfortunately we are both out of luck!
  • @hoodoll82 Boo! Although I love it delivered to my door, it makes me want to start saving coupons and buy it at the store.
  • ksimo6ksimo6 member
    Maybe the subscribe and save is a prime thing? I'm seeing subscribe and save discounts on all similac products. You may want to consider the membership... You will probably save money in the long run. I should really get paid for advertising amazon prime!
    • Married 6/1/2012
    • BFP #1 - 11/17/2012 -  MC 12/10/2012
    • BFP #2 - 2/12/2013 - EDD 10/17/2013 - DD Born 10/10/2013
    • BFP #3 - 1/29/2014 - Ectopic pregnancy discovered 1/31/2014
    • BFP #4 - 9/28/2014 - EDD 6/4/2015 - DS Born 5/31/2015


  • We are using Similac Advanced. We use the $5 off coupons at Sam's. We also use the store brand gas drops.
  • ksimo6 said:

    Maybe the subscribe and save is a prime thing? I'm seeing subscribe and save discounts on all similac products. You may want to consider the membership... You will probably save money in the long run. I should really get paid for advertising amazon prime!

    I have prime and amazon mom... Now this is just bizarre that @swaugh14 and I both are not seeing this! I'd be annoyed if it's regional or something. But I've checked twice now! Will be checking a third time to be sure, because honestly I buy almost everything through Amazon Prime and/or Subscribe and Save! Waaaaah!
  • ksimo6ksimo6 member
    @hoodoll82

    Check it out! So weird!
    • Married 6/1/2012
    • BFP #1 - 11/17/2012 -  MC 12/10/2012
    • BFP #2 - 2/12/2013 - EDD 10/17/2013 - DD Born 10/10/2013
    • BFP #3 - 1/29/2014 - Ectopic pregnancy discovered 1/31/2014
    • BFP #4 - 9/28/2014 - EDD 6/4/2015 - DS Born 5/31/2015


  • hoodoll82 said:

    ksimo6 said:

    Maybe the subscribe and save is a prime thing? I'm seeing subscribe and save discounts on all similac products. You may want to consider the membership... You will probably save money in the long run. I should really get paid for advertising amazon prime!

    I have prime and amazon mom... Now this is just bizarre that @swaugh14 and I both are not seeing this! I'd be annoyed if it's regional or something. But I've checked twice now! Will be checking a third time to be sure, because honestly I buy almost everything through Amazon Prime and/or Subscribe and Save! Waaaaah!
    I also have prime and mom. When I was looking at similac formula I also only saw it on like, 2 products (probably the ones in the screenshot above). Not on what I'm using, anyway. Besides, it seemed like the subscribe and save price wouldn't be as good as me using the $5 off coupon at target (as long as I consistently have coupons).

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Hey ladies!
    I've been formula feeding since the beginning pretty much. The twins were never getting enough and it took 5 days for my milk to come in! We started on the Kirkland brand right away and it's fine for them. They had trouble with gas a bit in the beginning but that's worked its way out now. They drink every couple hours and finish their bottles (4 oz) no problem! The one thing I do find is that one of my girls spits out at much as she takes in. Like swallow, spit, swallow. Does anyone else have this problem? What do you do?
  • Hey ladies! I've been formula feeding since the beginning pretty much. The twins were never getting enough and it took 5 days for my milk to come in! We started on the Kirkland brand right away and it's fine for them. They had trouble with gas a bit in the beginning but that's worked its way out now. They drink every couple hours and finish their bottles (4 oz) no problem! The one thing I do find is that one of my girls spits out at much as she takes in. Like swallow, spit, swallow. Does anyone else have this problem? What do you do?
    Same here, I'm going to ask my pediatrician at her appt today. It doesn't seem to pain her, but I kinda hate feeding her, knowing 25% is going to end up all over her or me and there will be multiple clothing changes involved...

    @mellymar that's gotta be it re: amazon! The regular old Similac is not S&S. It's also more expensive on Amazon, which is surprising! At least it will get me out of the house and to the store every couple of days!
  • MommaswizzMommaswizz member
    edited July 2015
    I'm late to the party but Im super happy to see this thread. It makes me feel better to see so many of us doing what we need to do to get our babies fed and happy :) we're currently doing about 50%-60% formula at feedings and pumped breast milk at the others.It's working well for us so,far (I'm only 10 days pp). We're using similac advanced right now but have tried the similac supplemental and similac sensitive samples and didn't notice much difference for our girl. We've only purchased at cvs as of now but I'm hoping we'll see some better prices at BJs. It helps hearing how everyone is trying to save some cash on this. Eta: wow typos. Words are hard
  • lany07lany07 member
    Has anyone noticed a difference between the ready to feed formula and the powder? We were given ready to feed formula at the hospital but LO spits up every time.
  • I breastfed, pumped and supplemented for 3 weeks. Finally made the full switch this week. We use enfamil infant now, started on enfamil newborn.
    lany07 said:

    Has anyone noticed a difference between the ready to feed formula and the powder? We were given ready to feed formula at the hospital but LO spits up every time.

    I was wondering this but for different reasons. Does the ready to feed keep them fuller longer?
  • I've been pumping and supplementing since day 1... (Premie twin girls who never really got the latch, and I don't produce enough to just pump) and we've been using similac advance. In regards to powder vs ready to feed, we were given both from the hospital (we got like 5tubs of formula it was great!) and honestly i didn't see much difference. Since there's no blending involved , RTF is much smoother and I noticed my girls were less gassy. But for the price, we stick with powder
  • lany07lany07 member
    I don't think it makes him fuller. It's just super convenient in the middle of the night or for DH to feed him. But his spit up dries a weird color and is an awful, but I don't know if just my LO.
  • I'm glad this is here. I've been avoiding the new mom and BFing threads because it's gone so bad for us lately. LO was severely jaundiced at his weight check and was still under birth weight at almost three weeks. We knew then I wasn't making enough milk and our Dr gave us formula to supplement. Now we BF, pump, and formula feed. The stress and guilt and skipped feedings (suggested by Dr to "fill up" my breasts, total BS) has killed my supply even more. I'm trying but I'm not sure all the herbs, beer, or oatmeal in the world will help now. Not to mention boosting your milk supply is a full time job itself.

    I've been using Wal-Mart's 'like enfamil' and his gas has been awful. When I had DD five years ago Gerber was the "cheap" stuff, now it's crazy high. So I don't think the price or brand matters. I assume it's because we had been EBF and his tummy is used to my milk. I may switch to soothe or gentle.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"