I originally went in to buy the Carson bedding, but walked out with the Noah. Now I think I might have made the wrong choice! Which do you like better:
Another option is to buy the sheet from the other set since they both have similar colors. I bought bedding from PBK as well, but ended up just getting the quilt from the set I liked to use with the toddler bed later, then I bought a few coordinating sheets.
Personally I like Carson a bit better... but both are cute. I would probably get one of each (or two and 1) because you'll want a couple of sheets anyway. Like pp, I didn't get the bumpers or quilts or anything due to safety, so I love that the pbk sheets can be bought separately.
We're actually going with Carson so I'm a little biased :-) Noah is really cute too though. I don't think you can go wrong with either. I like the ideas pp had about switching up sheets if you want. I want to get the sheet from Reese to add to our set.
Re: Carson or Noah Bedding from Pottery Barn??