I'm not a huge fan of leashes, but I'm not completely anti them either. I've never needed to use one, but I'm not ruling out using it at some point in the future.
What I can't quite understand however, is people who are really anti a leash but completely ok with strollers.
I'm not talking about using a stroller in the case of going for a big walk that is too far for little legs. Or having it so LO can get in and out as suits them. I'm talking about using a stroller in the situation where it's easier to have your LO contained either for safety or convenience. You know where they are, they can't get away from you, and you don't need to keep your eyes or hands on them the whole time.
Now I'm ok with stroller use too, but to me using a stroller as above is no better or worse than a leash. Although perhaps with a leash your LO is getting some exercise and movement.
So if you're not ok with a leash, is a stroller better to you? and if so why?
This is in no way intended to be snarky, I just honestly don't see the difference. To my mind if you think a leash is treating your child like an animal, then isn't "caging" them in a stroller just the same?
Thoughts?


Re: S/O the leash post below
So if we called it a "safety link" people wouldn't immediately make the dog/animal connection? That makes sense.
Elizabeth 5yrs old Jane 3yrs old
There are definitely pet strollers! LOL not that I am justifying them in any way, mind you.
I don't like the idea of leashes necessarily, but I'm not too fond of strollers, either. We have one because someone bought us one and it would have been a nightmare to try to return (Graco, but I literally could not find this travel system anywhere). We didn't/don't really plan on using one for a while. We'll carry and wear the baby. We were planning on getting a higher quality umbrella stroller for when she's a toddler and wants up and down more than is convenient for wearing her all the time. I see WAY too many people pushing these Jeep sized strollers with one hand while carrying a child in the other arm because the kid didn't want to be in the stroller. I didn't feel like spending the money. Since we have one, we're going to try to use it... although it's huge, we live on a 3rd floor walkup, and I don't think our lifestyle doesn't really necessitate a big travel system.
I can't imagine using a stroller simply as a child "container" because I would not want to hear my kid throw an absolute fit because she wants out! If the kid is content, then they clearly want to be in it, so I wouldn't be opposed to keeping it that way.
blog! thescenery.net
i see zombie kids at the mall all the time. completely zoned out in the stroller. now to be fair they may have just run around all morning and simply be in the troller because now they're tired.
i've contained dd1 in a stroller twice. i felt bad for her but i had stuff that i needed to happen. i did let her out to stretch her legs when she got antsy, but i simply didn't have time to walk at her pace and stop and look at everything she wanted to. she zoned out and was generally content, but i didn't consider it excellent parenting.
Elizabeth 5yrs old Jane 3yrs old
I never had a leash on my when I was a kid. And I doubt my mother ever used a stroller to "contain" me in one spot. I do remember going to places like Disneyworld and my parents doing things like - *gasp* keeping an eye on me to make sure they knew where I was! We held hands, they never let us leave their side. You know, NORMAL things, rather than treating us like animals, teaching us that it's wrong to run off and that you must stay by mommy's side and where mommy can see you.
And my mother did it with not just 1 but 5 children! The horrors!
Ok sorry. I don't mean to be overly snarky. In all seriousness -people need to do what they need to do to keep their kids safe. Strollers I think are more of a convenience, most have spots to put drinks, snacks, bags...etc. Provide kids with shade when it's hot and sunny...etc. I think they're only considered OK because they are so widely accepted for so many years. Give the "safety links" time and they'll get there.
ADDED: Sorry. I really didn't mean to be overly snarky. I'm cranky and uncomfortable today. I think I'm better off not posting
I've had a stroller for all of my kids. But with Graco strollers you can attach toys to them. I used them more when they were babies. By time they were toddlers they all have became really independent and wanted to walk but they learned very quickly they had to stay with me.
For the twins we bought a stroller that has toy attachment spots plus the front seat turns around so the boys can interact with each other. I've always tried to make sure the stroller didn't feel like prison to them. For the most part its worked.
No kidding. And I think it's naive, pompous and honestly, dangerous, to think your parenting skills are SO amazing that you can keep a small human safe with a look and your "serious voice." Toddlers love nothing more than to make you doubt your abilities and to give you a virtual "f'uck you."
No clue. DS hated being in a stroller. He hates anything where his arms are pressed to his sides even lightly - tactile sensory - but other than that a stroller is so passive. So is babywearing. Both are convenient and great and have their place, but I think the monkey backpack was far better than the others between the ages of 18months - 3 years for DS. You can?t teach a kid how to behave in public or walk with you from a stroller or from on your back. A monkey backpack is a great safety device. And as I?ve said before, you can ignore your kid or interact with your kid in any of them - no item is inherently bad. That?s just ridiculous.
Not trying to be ugly but if my kid looked at me like that at any time they wouldn't be able to run because their little butt would be red. Same thing with the toddler playing chicken. You're going to have a lot of fun when your kids are teenaers if you let that behavior slide now. Trust me, I see it in my classroom everyday, I can tell the kids who were disciplined from the ones who were just shielded.
Hold the f'ucking phone. You would spank a toddler for a LOOK? If you aren't a troll, I'm going to go balls to the wall and say I feel sorry for your kid. I've never said that on here, ever. But really. If anyone needs to learn something, it's you. Patience, for one, and an understanding of typical toddler behavior.
You got the last part right.
You obviously had a unique situation. I didn't say all parents using leashes were irresponsible and full of attitude, I said most. Yes this can be determined from about 2 minutes in a Walmart,
Spanking is not abuse, and it works. The kid thinks twice before repeating the action. As I said, have fun with the teenage years and god bless the high school teacher that gets disrespected daily by your kid.
Hold me. I seriously think I'm having a stroke over here.
These are pretty cool for older kids if you have a smart phone.
https://www.safetyslap.com/
Yes, that look while she was explaining something that could be life or death is extremely disrespectful. It may be typical behavior but that doesn't make it ok, you have to teach them what's right and wrong. That attitude of trying your parents will blossom into much more if they get away with it at that age.
When do you plan to start teaching right from wrong? I would think you teach it as situations arise. Again a simple 2 to 3 pops on the butt is not beating. If you really don't like it then take away toys, use time out, whatever, but when my kid does something wrong they are going to get corrected right then and there not when I feel like they are "developmentally ready". If they are ready to do something wrong they are ready to find out its wrong.
You realize toddler don't comprehend the word "disrespectful" right? Wait, you don't, do you? They aren't teenagers and can't be treated the same. We shape them and guide them. We don't smack them because they did something natural. Your kid is growing to grow up afraid to do anything, mark my words. Stand up for myself? I'll get hit. Question mom? I'll get hit. Oh and since you think hitting is ok if someone disrepects you, I hope you've never uttered a pissed off word at any other adult because by your standards, that would warrant getting your ass kicked.
Hitting =/= teaching. What you are doing is modeling that violence is the way to handle situations that you are not intelligent enough to handle in any other way.
Good job, teach.
Hopefully, your DD will learn how to handle situations without using violence when she winds up in therapy because her mommy is a monster.
Yep, I'm having twins, even more reason to be strict. And I would never use an object to spank my kid. That would be abuse. Its not about hurting them, its about getting their attention. The same reason you pop a 1 year old's hand and tell them no when they try to pick up breakable objects off a coffee table. It gets their attention.
FFS, Are you for real? What are you going to do when your kid turns around after you have whipped their "little butt" and says "that didn't hurt". You can discipline and teach without spanking (and I am not against a swat on the behind) but some kids don't learn from having their little butt "reddened". That just sickens me.
Much like Mama SAS, I also had a kid that would bolt. And a harness helped him learn to stop and think prior to taking off. You know what? He was NOT a discipline problem in school, he managed to make it all the way through high school and graduate and is a very polite young man who didn't get run over by a car because he had a HARNESS!
SHE IS A TODDLER!!! She doesn't know that look is disrespectful. Man, you are thick.
What the actual fuucck. Not to be cliche, but honestly, I feel so sorry for your children. Congratulations on beating your kid into mindless compliance.
I don't hit my kid. I spank. Obviously there are some adults here who would have benefited from a few in their younger years. You think a toddler doesn't understand when you tell them something is ugly or not nice? You don't give kids enough credit.
I am totally for the use of a "leash"...I find it ridiculous for parents to be against them. My mother used one for me that went around her wrist and around mine. I have the same kind for my girls. And my girls like it b/c they are able to get out and walk.
For me the leash is good for toddlers that may be too big for a stroller or those who just need a break from riding. The leash is a safety factor for me and it makes it easier for the child to walk beside you rather than trying to hold your hand. Not to mention it keeps your child from running around like their at home instead of a public place. I say kudos to parents who care enough to use them!
Bless your hear, ks3.
As a mom of 2-year old twins, I would just like to say good luck with your theories and strategies. I wish I could be there to laugh at you when one kid runs one way, and the other goes a different direction, and you have a panic attack because you are in a parking lot.
Or when one kid refuses to hold your hand and makes you drag them while the other one wants to be put down because he doesn't want to be held anymore.
Trust me on this one - all of your parenting theories can go out the window when you have twins. You will be in survival mode the first couple years.
Bahahahahahha. Babyproofing is blocking wall sockets and locking cabinets. I would never put things away just because I had a kid in the house. What do you do when you visit someone who has pictures and what nots sitting around?
Yeah no. Hitting them so hard their butt is bright red and they can't run is not just spaking.
She'll just whip their azzes. Poor kids.
Only every parent I know. Some of you really need to visit the South I guess, maybe that's why my style seems so foreign. Its worked for ages.
You're a teacher, huh? Let me work it out for you. Spank, verb - slap * Slap, verb - hit Therefore, spank = hit
Dude, seriously, you are making me want to call CPS in Nashville, NC and have them knock on every damn door until they find your azz.
Thanks Red Wings, you beat me to it! I have 1.5 year old twin boys. And they hate the stroller. Yep, we have leashes.
And OMFG, this biatch has just got to be a troll. Nobody is this stupid, right? Right?!?! $hit, someone hold me.....
Glad you are able to find gifs to describe yourself. Guess you're out of adult reasoning.