January 2011 Moms

A friend suggested but didn't offer...

for me to have a shower as well as a meet the baby party.  My knee jerk reaction is that this is tacky- I've never seen anyone have a shower AFTER the baby is born.

A little background:  We are in SC, my fam is in IN, DH's fam is in MD and we won't be in either state before baby is born except for the weekend of BIL's wedding- which I refuse to have a shower then because I don't want to steal FSIL's thunder (I love her to death and by no way did she suggest I'd be doing it.  She asked if I would be having a shower, I explained why, and said I didn't want one the weekend of her wedding, end of story). So I won't be having a baby shower- which I am ok with.

I was telling my friend that I wanted to have a 'Meet the Baby' party at my parents' when I am in IN in March so that I don't have to do a lot of traveling and a lot of people can come.  My mom is like Martha Stewart on steroids, so she was going to make some finger foods, we are going to get a cake from a local grocery that makes THE BEST cakes.  No where is registry info going to be in the invitation, but my mom will tell people if they ask.  I'm not expecting gifts by any means, but I'm not going to refuse one if someone wants to get a gift.  We are completely prepared to pay for everything we need ourselves and I really just want to celebrate my baby!

No one has offered to throw a shower, but I want to be prepared as my friends talk,  to have an answer ready for them.  My first reaction is to politely decline....wdyt? TIA!

Re: A friend suggested but didn't offer...

  • Hehe, Cdobry- feel free to bring on your snark ;)  I seriously have no idea if it's tacky or not reading some of the posts about when people have their showers and whatnot!
  • Loading the player...
  • If your friends offer to throw a shower before baby is here, accept. If they offer to throw it after baby is here, accept. Free stuff, silly! :) If they don't offer, stick to plan A.
  • I think that if somone offers to throw you a shower and it's not a hassle for you or your friend then accept it! 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I would do one or the other as far as actual invitations going out, etc. However, if you have a shower by invite and would still like to have a meet the baby, I suggest that being just by word of mouth and just designed as a small get together. I would not send out invitations for two to the same people. If you were doing one with one group of people and one with another group, I don't think that's bad. People are going to get you gifts if it's a shower, if it's a meet the baby or even if you don't have either. People love giving babies gifts!

    P.S. Your question does not compare to the ones that cdobry was referring to!  Smile

  • Honestly, if the idea for a shower after the baby gets here is totally your friends offering, I don't see how that is tacky. If you were making a stink and suggesting to them to throw you an after the baby gets here shower, maybe, that would be tacky, but I don't think there is anything wrong with accepting a shower for your first baby. Besides, what difference does it make if it's after she's here? How does it become more tacky? Sometimes babies come early and end up being at showers that were scheduled for before their due dates.
    DD1 01/09/11 DD2 10/31/12 #3 EDD 10/22/14--Stick baby stick! Always in my heart, 4 sweet angels 2/10, 10/11, 12/11 & 10/13
  • In some cultures, baby showers are traditionally held after the arrival of the baby (in the Jewish tradition, for example, it's considered bad luck to have baby things in the house before the baby arrives, so showers are done afterwards).  That said, if someone offers to throw you a shower, either before or after the birth of the baby, I think you should accept.  I see the offer of a shower as a gift in itself, and it would be considered rude to turn down a gift, so... have the shower.  If no one offers, stick to your original plan.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMicheleR96:

    I would do one or the other as far as actual invitations going out, etc. However, if you have a shower by invite and would still like to have a meet the baby, I suggest that being just by word of mouth and just designed as a small get together. I would not send out invitations for two to the same people. If you were doing one with one group of people and one with another group, I don't think that's bad. People are going to get you gifts if it's a shower, if it's a meet the baby or even if you don't have either. People love giving babies gifts!

    P.S. Your question does not compare to the ones that cdobry was referring to!  Smile

    Haha, yea, I just thought it was funny- I posted this right after she posted that!  Just teasing ;)

    But as far as the parties go- I definitely wouldn't send out invites to the meet the baby if we are having a shower.  I don't like co-ed showers and the MTB party would definitely be smaller if I had a shower.  I just don't want to be like "Idk, let me think about it" if someone offers- I'd feel very rude.   

  • I don't think it's tacky to have a shower or "Meet the Baby" party after the baby is born. One of my good friends was on bed rest for months and couldn't have a shower at all. As long as you don't host it yourself, I think it's fine.
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
    Pregnancy Ticker


  • imagecompanion cube:
    Honestly, if the idea for a shower after the baby gets here is totally your friends offering, I don't see how that is tacky. If you were making a stink and suggesting to them to throw you an after the baby gets here shower, maybe, that would be tacky, but I don't think there is anything wrong with accepting a shower for your first baby. Besides, what difference does it make if it's after she's here? How does it become more tacky? Sometimes babies come early and end up being at showers that were scheduled for before their due dates.

    Where I'm from its just not typically done.  I didn't even know that showers get thrown after the baby comes (except in instances where babies come early) until being on TB.  I think some of the older folk that would be invited (church and grandma's) wouldn't like it, but I don't know fur sure.  

  • I LOL'd at this only because with DS my shower was planned at 36 weeks and DS arrived at 35, so I ended up with a meet the baby shower when he was 3 weeks.
  • I am in a similar sit.  My friends have informed me that they are going to have my baby shower after the baby is born.  They had 3 reasons: 1.  so my mom can be there (my could really doesn't care, she didn't come to my bridal shower, this is the reality of life when families live 1,000s of miles apart); 2. people can get gifts that fit the baby (ie. I have a 10lb baby not a 6 lb baby, wtf? who cares?); and 3. a couple in our district (DH and I are teachers) lost their baby 4 days before the EDD, so my friends don't want me to have baby stuff around to remind me of my loss.

    I am overwhelmed at the thought of post-baby shower!  I suffer from depression and a huge fear of mine is that I will be so overwhelmed by the baby and my hormones etc. that I will not be able to handle my family visiting one at a time!  (post-partum runs really strong in my family).  I also have no idea what to buy...we registered thinking that my friends would throw a shower in Nov. and then our families would get what was left for us for Christmas and as gifts (this is what our mothers and g-mothers told us) and then whatever was left over we could get with a discount later...

    I feel ya, not sure what to do...

  • imagePrincessSarah1979:

    I am in a similar sit.  My friends have informed me that they are going to have my baby shower after the baby is born.  They had 3 reasons: 1.  so my mom can be there (my could really doesn't care, she didn't come to my bridal shower, this is the reality of life when families live 1,000s of miles apart); 2. people can get gifts that fit the baby (ie. I have a 10lb baby not a 6 lb baby, wtf? who cares?); and 3. a couple in our district (DH and I are teachers) lost their baby 4 days before the EDD, so my friends don't want me to have baby stuff around to remind me of my loss.

    I am overwhelmed at the thought of post-baby shower!  I suffer from depression and a huge fear of mine is that I will be so overwhelmed by the baby and my hormones etc. that I will not be able to handle my family visiting one at a time!  (post-partum runs really strong in my family).  I also have no idea what to buy...we registered thinking that my friends would throw a shower in Nov. and then our families would get what was left for us for Christmas and as gifts (this is what our mothers and g-mothers told us) and then whatever was left over we could get with a discount later...

    I feel ya, not sure what to do...

    I don't want people to think I am ungrateful...like pp said any free gift is great!  I just feel a little lost right now at the thought of doing the shower this way...particularly since I struggle with depression so badly even before pregnancy it was hard to get myself to go to parties and such, right now I feel great!!!!  This is when I would like to do stuff like this...with God all is possible though...I have to keep that in mind.

  • imagePrincessSarah1979:
    imagePrincessSarah1979:

    I am in a similar sit.  My friends have informed me that they are going to have my baby shower after the baby is born.  They had 3 reasons: 1.  so my mom can be there (my could really doesn't care, she didn't come to my bridal shower, this is the reality of life when families live 1,000s of miles apart); 2. people can get gifts that fit the baby (ie. I have a 10lb baby not a 6 lb baby, wtf? who cares?); and 3. a couple in our district (DH and I are teachers) lost their baby 4 days before the EDD, so my friends don't want me to have baby stuff around to remind me of my loss.

    I am overwhelmed at the thought of post-baby shower!  I suffer from depression and a huge fear of mine is that I will be so overwhelmed by the baby and my hormones etc. that I will not be able to handle my family visiting one at a time!  (post-partum runs really strong in my family).  I also have no idea what to buy...we registered thinking that my friends would throw a shower in Nov. and then our families would get what was left for us for Christmas and as gifts (this is what our mothers and g-mothers told us) and then whatever was left over we could get with a discount later...

    I feel ya, not sure what to do...

    I don't want people to think I am ungrateful...like pp said any free gift is great!  I just feel a little lost right now at the thought of doing the shower this way...particularly since I struggle with depression so badly even before pregnancy it was hard to get myself to go to parties and such, right now I feel great!!!!  This is when I would like to do stuff like this...with God all is possible though...I have to keep that in mind.

     

    I don't see anything wrong with tactfully telling your friends that you are worried or uncomfortable with having a shower after the baby is born.  Of course speaking up could mean no shower at all since this time of year is so busy for people.

    To be honest I think it is a little rude of them to presume they could without your consent.  After you have your little one in your arms your time should be 100% your own with no obligations otherwise imo.   No one knows what you will be contending with in those first few months whether it is unexotic as a fussy baby or something more serious.

  • Most people I know have multiple showers to meet the needs of different groups of people they know.  If your peeps in SC want to celebrate with you, enjoy that time!  

    It's only tacky if you invite the same people twice or as it may be thrice (close, close people like mom's and bestie's excluded - but the assumption is that the issue of not expecting mult gifts would be easily discussed with them)

  • imageemmacwn:

    Most people I know have multiple showers to meet the needs of different groups of people they know.  If your peeps in SC want to celebrate with you, enjoy that time!  

    It's only tacky if you invite the same people twice or as it may be thrice (close, close people like mom's and bestie's excluded - but the assumption is that the issue of not expecting mult gifts would be easily discussed with them)

    Oh, its friends in IN!  I don't have enough friends here that would fill a shower.... 

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"