Toddlers: 12 - 24 Months

Waldorf schools are terrifying.

I was researching different types of schools - Montessori, Waldorf, Reggio Emilia, just out of curiosity. Found a post on the AP board about Waldorf. 

I had no idea. No clue. How can parents get roped into this? Scratch that. I can see how, but man. I would just be horrified if I hadn't found this out and had ended up sending DD to a Waldorf school. 

https://www.montessorianswers.com/my-experiences-with-waldorf.html 

Re: Waldorf schools are terrifying.

  • Yep. Steiner or whatever his name is, was a real cuckoo.

     

  • Loading the player...
  • I had never heard of this either until I got sucked into reading the AP board last night.  Interesting (and horrifying) account you linked.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Stick with Montessori, I cant say enough about it!
    Like giveaways? Like my blog!
    www.facebook.com/TryVermontFirst
    I love these two beautiful children!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Oh, and they are discussing this on the AP board? Hmm I bet that is an interesting conversation :insert sarcasm:
  • image*blondiem*:
    Oh, and they are discussing this on the AP board? Hmm I bet that is an interesting conversation :insert sarcasm:

    One woman was very well informed about Waldorf and shared a lot of her information, thankfully. She can't say enough great things about Reggio Emilia, though.  

  • Oh no it is utterly terrifying. I mean really. The mirror-fearing, left-hand fearing GNOME fearing lot of them are a bunch of utter nutters. 

    Truly one of the most terrifying concepts I've ever  researched. I had looked into a Waldorf school mom & tot class and I was like "oooh creative expression! How exciting. That sounds good for... gnomes? oh.   Ok. I no. No."

    Has anyone researched Steiner????? ::shivers:: 

  • I used to like gnomes. Now I'm freaked out. There's one sitting outside my door, and I want to throw him to the neighbors. I don't want him to explain how a copying machine works - how he sits inside it and shoots out papers from his cave. What.the.hell.

    A gnome is a gnome. Not an intelligent living breathing creature that controls children.

  • Have you read the testimonies of "survivors"??? THERE ARE SURVIVORS!
  • wha...? this is all rather terrifying.  maybe homeschool isn't such a freaky option anymore...

     

    kidding, of course.

  • imagelanie26:
    Have you read the testimonies of "survivors"??? THERE ARE SURVIVORS!

    I have not. I'm a little terrified. I might have to treat myself with blueberry cream cheese and a bagel in order to do this.  

  • imagekelbrian:

    imagelanie26:
    Have you read the testimonies of "survivors"??? THERE ARE SURVIVORS!

    I have not. I'm a little terrified. I might have to treat myself with blueberry cream cheese and a bagel in order to do this.  

    there is a waldorf critics board. Thousands and thousands of child "survivors'' of their cults.

    I keep shaking my head. Am I wrong to be sending Jo to a coop nursery school where the teachers are fun and the kids get choices in what to do each day and where she gets to finger paint with pudding? 

  • Sounds pretty wacked out to me.
  • You mean there isn't a gnome asleep in my copier? Because if there was...it would explain a lot about why it keeps eating the paper.
  • imageLoriFalce:
    You mean there isn't a gnome asleep in my copier? Because if there was...it would explain a lot about why it keeps eating the paper.

    Oh Lori you slay me<3

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I only got half way through.  I honestly hadn't even HEARD fo Waldorf before ... but seriously, people don't actually buy into this shiit, right???  Come ON?!!  No maps?  No drawings?  No explainations of ANYTHING????  How is that even classified as school and learning??
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    The Mouse ~ 06.12.08 | The Froggy ~ 02.23.11

    image
  • imageMrsTotty:
    I only got half way through.  I honestly hadn't even HEARD fo Waldorf before ... but seriously, people don't actually buy into this shiit, right???  Come ON?!!  No maps?  No drawings?  No explainations of ANYTHING????  How is that even classified as school and learning??

    Duh.  Because they learn about the physiology and habits of gnomes.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Interesting.. there was a Waldorf school by my old house and I actually applied to teach there (and a million other places). I never got a call but this makes me glad I didn't. Not quite my teaching philosophy!

    I didn't know much about it to be honest. Of course that link is an opinion, but WOW. The first parts I could handle, though I really don't agree.

    Then I got to this part and I stopped reading after that. This is just so so so wrong on so many levels! It really makes me sad

    "Worse in my eyes than not teaching accurate facts in the classroom was the reality that children who had interests in things that were not part of the Waldorf curriculum for their age were not only not allowed to learn about those interests at school, but their parents were encouraged, (dare I say ?pressured?) to not allow them to pursue their interests at home either. Their parents were told that exposure to anything non-Waldorf would hurt their development. So no matter how interested, a child could not, even on his own time, read (below 3rd grade), look at a book that they personally did not make (below 6th grade), look at maps, draw lines and geometric shapes... ."

    CP 3/07
    BFP 5/07 - Kylie born 2/08.       BPF 2/09 - Alexandra born 10/09.
    TTC since 8/13 - diagnosed difficulty conceiving due to LP defect. Took vitamin B and Vitex Berry to help lengthen.
    BFP 2/14 - Missed M/C found at 8.5 weeks. D&C at 9w2d. Partial Molar Pregnancy.
    BFP 11/14
  • No colouring with dark coloured crayons, no mirrors, no left-handedness.

    People you have only started down the path of crazy. 

     

  • imagelanie26:

    No colouring with dark coloured crayons, no mirrors, no left-handedness.

    People you have only started down the path of crazy. 

     

    Wait, what??  WTH do they have against dark colored crayons???  And mirrors? 

    I iz confused. 

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    The Mouse ~ 06.12.08 | The Froggy ~ 02.23.11

    image
  • imageMrsTotty:
    imagelanie26:

    No colouring with dark coloured crayons, no mirrors, no left-handedness.

    People you have only started down the path of crazy. 

     

    Wait, what??  WTH do they have against dark colored crayons???  And mirrors? 

    I iz confused. 

    Duh. Mirrors promote self obsessiveness. And dark crayons are the colours of lifelessness and aren't allowed until middle school age.

    NO REALLY. This is directly from a waldorf website. 


  • We will be montessori-ing from 2-K. From there, I'm not sure. I'm hoping we will be somewhere with really good schools. I probably sound like a whacko, but I'm really scared of the public school system based on my experiences. I'm going to be stringent in my choice and if I can't find something I like, we will homeschool or private school.  I'm serious about school (particularly high school, the rest, meh as long as he's learning)
  • image*Bre*:
    We will be montessori-ing from 2-K. From there, I'm not sure. I'm hoping we will be somewhere with really good schools. I probably sound like a whacko, but I'm really scared of the public school system based on my experiences. I'm going to be stringent in my choice and if I can't find something I like, we will homeschool or private school.  I'm serious about school (particularly high school, the rest, meh as long as he's learning)

    I'm ok with alternative choices but when a school is genuinely made up of whackjobs, I have to laugh at it. Montessori is a good option. I like a lot of their styles. I have 0 issue with public schooling though and am a big advocate, so Jo will go there. We're doing a coop nursery program next year and I love what I see in that place. She'll be there 3 mornings a week.

     

  • imagelanie26:
    Duh. Mirrors promote self obsessiveness. And dark crayons are the colours of lifelessness and aren't allowed until middle school age.

    Oh well THAT explains everything then.  ::side eye::  Seriously, what kind of a BSC weirdo comes up with this crap? 

    Just to spite said idiot, the first crayon that Jack gets will be black.  I might even make it a sharpie so it's PERMANENTLY lifeless. 

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    The Mouse ~ 06.12.08 | The Froggy ~ 02.23.11

    image
  • I think its weird too as generally children like to colour their families and friends and things familiar to them.

    Teaching any child that "Black" is the colour of lifelessness makes me feel rather queasy.

     

  • imagelanie26:

    No colouring with dark coloured crayons, no mirrors, no left-handedness.

    People you have only started down the path of crazy. 

     

    I am a lefty. Which is exactly why I turned my back on this nonsense.

    I am not kidding. This is some serious ridiculousness.

  • Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn! That is some crazy shiit.

    Momma to three boys: Henry - 4yo Alex - 18mo Jack - born 2/23/12 at 20w due to ruptured uterus (previa and accreta resulting in hysterectomy) He only lived here on Earth for an hour, but he will live in our hearts forever. m/c #1: sept '09, m/c #2: july '10
  • image*blondiem*:
    imagelanie26:

    No colouring with dark coloured crayons, no mirrors, no left-handedness.

    People you have only started down the path of crazy. 

     

    I am a lefty. Which is exactly why I turned my back on this nonsense.

    I am not kidding. This is some serious ridiculousness.

    I remember touring a turn of the century schoolhouse where they recreated that experience for my 3rd grade class. All the lefties giggled when the teacher made them write with their right hands (left was the devil's!) I still remember thinking "how crazy!" 

    But there's good old Waldorf, bringing it back. Of course in your case blondie, it may be true. have you thought about putting away the mirrors. 

    Did you read the part about "no recorded music?"

    BAHAHAHAHAAHAH. 

  • imagelanie26:
    image*blondiem*:
    imagelanie26:

    No colouring with dark coloured crayons, no mirrors, no left-handedness.

    People you have only started down the path of crazy. 

     

    I am a lefty. Which is exactly why I turned my back on this nonsense.

    I am not kidding. This is some serious ridiculousness.

    I remember touring a turn of the century schoolhouse where they recreated that experience for my 3rd grade class. All the lefties giggled when the teacher made them write with their right hands (left was the devil's!) I still remember thinking "how crazy!" 

    But there's good old Waldorf, bringing it back. Of course in your case blondie, it may be true. have you thought about putting away the mirrors. 

    Did you read the part about "no recorded music?"

    BAHAHAHAHAAHAH. 

    One more reason to hate on this. I have 17quadrillion hours on my Itunes right now.

    No, really. Are your crayons beeswax, lanie? Because if it's a light colored crayon and it isn't beeswax?? Well, poo on you.

     

  • wow, i just got nervous. i actually live in waldorf, md. =) yes, a few are not so good but the rest are great. thankfully, we live in the brand new school district.
  • imageMattsWifey<3:
    wow, i just got nervous. i actually live in waldorf, md. =) yes, a few are not so good but the rest are great. thankfully, we live in the brand new school district.

     

    im pretty sure they are talking about the 'concept' Waldorf schools, not the actual school district. Confused

  • imageirishgurlkt:

    imageMattsWifey<3:
    wow, i just got nervous. i actually live in waldorf, md. =) yes, a few are not so good but the rest are great. thankfully, we live in the brand new school district.

     

    im pretty sure they are talking about the 'concept' Waldorf schools, not the actual school district. Confused

    I thought she was kidding. No? Perhaps she went to  waldorf school. 

  • imagelanie26:
    imageirishgurlkt:

    imageMattsWifey<3:
    wow, i just got nervous. i actually live in waldorf, md. =) yes, a few are not so good but the rest are great. thankfully, we live in the brand new school district.

     

    im pretty sure they are talking about the 'concept' Waldorf schools, not the actual school district. Confused

    I thought she was kidding. No? Perhaps she went to  waldorf school. 

     

    hmm, I thought she was serious...but hopefully for her sake she wasn't?

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"