I voted for the 2nd one, but I really only plan on using a mesh bumper if it's necessary. I'm not even buying one unless I notice baby sticking her little hands and feet out. I don't want them getting stuck, but it may not end up being an issue:)
I plan on using the regular one. I have a bassinet she'll be in for a couple months so I figure by the time I put her in the crib hopefully she'll be able to turn her head away from the bumper if she gets close to it.. if I find out she likes to wiggle to one side or the other I'll just take it out
We didn't use a bumper at all for my DD. I didn't feel a need for one until past her 1st birthday when she actually started getting her leg/feet stuck in the slats. Now she's big enough that she'd just get it suck above the bumper so I haven't worried about getting one.
I'll likely get one this time around though if the need arises
We've been using crib bumpers with ds since he's still fairly immobile. Once he starts rolling and moving when he chooses, we'll take them out. It may sound silly but I think the bumpers helped create the same sense of coziness of his bassinet. He had no problems with the bassinet to crib transition.
we registered for mesh one but have not received it yet. He will be in bassinet for awhile. We are going to use a sleep positioner. We shall see how that works and will see if we actually go buy mesh bumper.
Re: Crib Bumpers (poll)
DD#1 born June '09
DD#2 born April '11
TTC #3 as of July '14
We didn't use a bumper at all for my DD. I didn't feel a need for one until past her 1st birthday when she actually started getting her leg/feet stuck in the slats. Now she's big enough that she'd just get it suck above the bumper so I haven't worried about getting one.
I'll likely get one this time around though if the need arises