My short list WDYT?

fairbl

DD1's name is Ashlynn. For baby #2 we are thinking...

Hadley Faith

Elsie Faith

or for a boy:

Garrett Robert (Robert after DH's late father)

TheWop

Love Garrett Robert!  Great name.

I'm not digging Elsie.  Hadley is ok, but for some reason it sounds weird when I say it outloud.  What about Natalie?

karen_loy

Garrett Robert is a good name

Elsie is too nicknamey to me, sorry, I'd go with Hadley

magsugar13

I like robert and faith

ycristina84

Hadley is ok. Elsie, sounds like the name of a cow to me...What about Elise? Elise Faith is pretty cute.

Pearl16

None of them are really my style, but they're not bad names. I like Garrett the best. I know that Hadley is a legitimate name, but it reminds me too much of the -ley trend going on right now, and that's what turns me off. I like Elsie a little better, but I prefer Elsa.

BLPL101

Love your boy name! Garrett is very underused. Elsie Faith is cute!

Abby7

I hate all of the first names, to be honest. Elsie = cow. Hadley = none-too-upscale town in MA. Garrett = not sure why, just not that masculine to me.

FrecklesInside

I like your boy name but neither of your girl names. Hadley is not attractive IMO and is trendy. I don't like Elsie - NN sounding ... or like a cow's name...

Some suggestions:

Adeline, Delia, Carmen, Lacey, Heather, Lydia, Lorelai, Emmaline, Florence, Evelyn, Chloe, Holly...

 

alohamora

I like Faith.  Elsie is better than Hadley IMO, but I prefer Elsie as a nn (like for Elsa).  Garrett Robert is nice.

sugarpumpkin716

i like the boy name.

jordanruthwells21

LOVE the name Hadley I really like it spelled with an i (Hadli). Sorry I don't like Garrett. I think its because I know too many weirdos named Garrett