After about 40 minutes of looking at bags last night I decided on the JJ Cole System bag in black damask.
I love the padded strap, there's lots of storage space and there are several SEPARATE compartments for things. This stood out to me since I want a place to keep dirty CDs separate from everything else in the bag!
It comes with a pacifier holder, changing pad that you can easily throw in a different bag, and straps to hook it to the stroller (as long as it isn't too heavy. My stroller is kind of a beast though so it would take a ridiculously heavy bag to tip it!).
I'd say it's medium sized, which I think will be good for day to day stuff and I'm sure we'll end up with bigger/smaller bags as well for other occasions. Best of all, the price was right. It's $69.99 but with the Bed Bath and Beyond coupon I saved $14. Can't complain there!
More pictures on this website: https://www.babyoliverboutique.com/jj-cole-diaper-bag-system-180-black-damask.html
Re: My diaper bag
[url=http://www.thebump.com/?utm_source=ticker&utm_medium=UBB&utm_campaign=tickers][img]http://global.thebump.com/tickers/tte03a3.aspx[/img]
I was tempted by the pink/graphite one but didn't want to push my luck
Yup- BB&B owns Buy Buy Baby so you can use their coupons. I remember thinking I was in BB&B when I went there because they are set up the exact same way.
Good buy, Morgan!