Let me know what you think of my top three!

LoveMoose85

So found out officially baby number two will be another beautiful baby GIRL this November. I'm far from a solid name choice at this point but am narrowing down my list. Would love opinions. My style is unique and whimsy I'd say, with it still feeling like an actual name she can pull off through out her life. She will be joining sister Nova Juliet.

1. Finley Belle (Belle is my grandmothers middle name)

2. Loxley Drew (or Belle) I'm open to either middle name. I admit I'm a little scared of this one but secertly love it! (I was scared of Nova too, but in the end I feel it picked me.)

3. Elliot Belle (or Drew again). nn Ele? I not sure about this one because I don't want people shortening it to the ever so popular Ellie. But I do love Elliot. 

Would love to hear your thoughts. Thank you!

bbiutmcph

Well with Loxley all I can think is salmon (Lox) so it's a big no. 

I dont care for either Elliott or finley on a girl but if I had to choose I would pick Finley vs any other possible name for a girl that leads to Ellie 

Bringmemylongswordho

Honestly? Nova is fairly cool, and Finley and Elliot are pretty basic in comparison.

I feel like Astrid, Hester and Celeste (off the top of my head) fit better than another Ellie or Finley.

ashleyandely

Definite dislike for Loxley, not a name someone can pull off through out life.

Elliott is not good either on a girl. So I guess Finley. But tbh I would keep looking. Or just use Elle.

FelicitousJinx

I like Loxley Belle best of your names. I like that it's reminiscent of Robin of Loxley/Robinhood.

I love pp's suggestions of Astrid and Celeste! I agree that Finley and Elliot aren't quite as cool as Nova, as much as I do like both names. 

I'd like to add the following: 

Astra
Bellatrix
Carina
Leda
Starla
Twila

magsugar13

I dislike them all

FakeFinn

They're all not my style. Loxley is too Robin Hood. Finley and Elliot are too 2010's boy name on girl trendy. 

I love Nova and thinking of whimsical, I suggest:
Tallulah
Wren 
Saffran 
Meadow
Clementine

harpseal135

None of them. Loxley definately NMS. The other 2 are pure boy names.  

NME44

None of them for me also, sorry. I do love PP's suggestion of Astrid with Nova. 

Finley and Elliot are more trendy than they are whimsical, and as far as I know Loxley isn't really a name.

lm45678

Please say no to Loxley.

If I had to pick I would say Finley Belle.

jessilee15

Love Astrid or Astra with Nova! Also suggesting Stella or Selene

No love for Loxley either. So I guess Elliott but I agree it's not as good as Nova

ladybugsamom

Please do not try to make Elliott a girls name. It's a very nice boy name but I do not like it on a girl. Of your choices, I would go with Loxley Belle.

mb0112

Sorry I don't like any of them.  Finley Belle if I had to choose.  Suggesting these to go with Nova (and I do like Nova!) or a whimsical, less common vibe 

Celeste 
Astrid
Willow
Phoebe
Odette
Xiomara
Zelda
Lucinda

nurse714

I don't like any of them. Really dislike Loxley and Elliot and Finley are all boy to me. Finley if I must choose. 

queenbone

FakeFinn said:

They're all not my style. Loxley is too Robin Hood. Finley and Elliot are too 2010's boy name on girl trendy. 

I love Nova and thinking of whimsical, I suggest:
Tallulah
Wren 
Saffran 
Meadow
Clementine

Ditto. Adding Lark and Luz to the list.

Maybe Quinn if you are dead set on using a boy name on a girl.