Needing feedback on girl names shortlist.

Inanigloo

Hi all. 

I've posted before about being stuck on names for our soon to be arriving girl. I really cannot decide how I feel about these because they seem to be out of my usual style. List has changed slightly since last post with a few additions. Big sister is Rosalie. Last rhymes with line but starts with a K. Looking for feedback on name list please. 

1. Georgia- Love but seems plain next to big she's name. 

2. Magnolia- For some reason this is sticking with me. But seems odd with big sis being Rosalie. Too flowery?

3. Stella- Seems so common when I read name lists. Weird flow with big sis's name. 

4. Eloise- Feeling meh about it the more I think. 

5. Alice (Only name DH even partially likes but it's not love for me.) Really common here and plain compared to the rest on the list.

6. Penelope- Love how it flows with big sis's name. 

Bringmemylongswordho

I like Alice the best of your list. I personally don't find it plain at all. 

1.Alice
2. Eloise
3. Penelope
4. Magnolia
5. Stella
6. Georgia

Maybe Eloide or Elise feels fresher to you than Eloise? I also feel Margot would go well with Rosalie.

avalentine81

If you like Georgia the best (not sure if they are ranked?) you could always do Georgina which doesn't feel as plain. That or Magnolia gets my vote.

mb0112

I like Alice a lot.  Elise might be an option too.

With Rosalie I also like Penelope nn Penny.  

Suggesting:

Gabrielle
Virginia
Serena
Francesca
Beatice
Fiona

FelicitousJinx

I don't think Georgia sounds plain at all. You could use one of its variants like Georgette, Georgiana, or pp's recommendation of Georgina.

I also like pp's suggestion of Elise if you're having a hard time getting behind Alice, though I think Alice does sound quite lovely with Rosalie, too. 

If Alice/Elise and Georgia/one of its variants end up being your top 2 frontrunners, I think they sound nice together in a first and middle name combo. Then you both could have your top picks included. 

magsugar13

Georgia is my favorite
not a fan of most of the others
IMO alice is a cold name and rosalie so pretty it doesnt go together at all

queenbone

I don't mind Rosalie and Magnolia together at all. Do you use the NN Rose for big sister? Would you use the NN Maggie for Magnolia? Because Rose and Maggie sound lovely, and not at all too matchy when used together. 

Of all the female George variants, Georgiana is my favorite. You could use Giana as a NN option.

FakeFinn

Georgia and Magnolia are my faves. I'm with queenbone all the way: Rose and Maggie are adorable!

Inanigloo

queenbone said:

I don't mind Rosalie and Magnolia together at all. Do you use the NN Rose for big sister? Would you use the NN Maggie for Magnolia? Because Rose and Maggie sound lovely, and not at all too matchy when used together. 

Of all the female George variants, Georgiana is my favorite. You could use Giana as a NN option.

Big sis does go by Rosie exclusively but I hadn't thought of Magnolia shortened. I love the idea of Maggie with Rosie. By far this is my favourite together. Thank you!

holli0801

I like Georgia and don't think it's plain. Same with Alice! Eloise I really like but dislike all the "Ellie" nn's of the world. Don't really like Magnolia or Penelope. Stella I like but honestly it seems to be a big dog name :-/ 

you didnt ask ask for suggestions, so take them or leave them... :-)

Caroline, Sadie, Iris, Fiona, Lorelei, Aurelia, Calliope, Seraphina, Gemma 

cloeelizabeth

 Magnolia and Penelope  are my favorite:)