Torn between two girl names

mommytimesfour

I love each name equally although I prefer the nickname options for Evelyn (Eve/Evie). Which do you prefer?

mylilwildflower

Both are very popular. I prefer Evelyn of the two though. 

mommytimesfour

I should've added that popularity isn't a deciding factor for me. While I know both names have gotten pretty popular, I also consider them timeless names that have been around forever so I'm not too concerned with their recent popularity. 

bbiutmcph

Edit: clearly posted on wrong thread but for this one I vote Evelyn

MrsN092714

Both were on my list but hubby vetoed them.  Love them but think Evelyn is more timeless!  

MWoodside

I love Amelia most. 

growingournest

Amelia is less common (at least where I'm from) so it is my favorite out of the 2!

kmvisioli

Amelia is more timeless, less trendy (I know 4 Evelyn's born the past year!) Plus, cute nn options there too: Mia, Amy, Emmy

austinjl

LOVE THE NN EVIE!!!

DunkinDecaf

Two of my absolute favorite names. You can't go wrong!

jennyshawn0808

I like them both, but prefer Amelia

newbabymakes4

I'm no help because both of these names are in our top picks too!!

littleloves3

I love Millie as a nickname for Amelia 

ThisisNumber3

Evelyn is pretty but with the rise of all the Ava/Eva the Evie nn is overused  I think. 

mommytimesfour

Thanks for all the responses. I'm so torn! I'm just hoping a clear choice comes to me before baby is here. They're both equally great in my mind.