DH and I have a hard time with girl names - and both have strong feelings about our criteria... we want something strong yet feminine, classic, and generally sway away from nicknames. Getting to a name for DD1 (Maura) was a trial, but we love it and now face the same issues for DD2. While we have stayed at the bottom of the popularity lists, we keep coming back to Emma. We both love it and think it's a good fit with Maura, but are hesitating because of the popularity. For background, I have a relatively popular name for my birth year (about the same # born the same year as me as last year for Emma in the US) and while I do encounter other people with the same name, it isn't like my name is Jennifer and it doesn't bother me.
Emma 113 votes
Just name her Emma if you love it and stop worrying about the popularity
Don't do it - too popular
Give her a longer name (Emmeline) and use Emma as a nn
Re: Emma
BTW, Maura was on the list for my DD1's name - beautiful!
Also on the short list:
Sabrina
Rebecca
Tess
Kathleen
Leah
Margaret
Rachel
Jane
Elizabeth
And then Claire is our DD.
Baby Boy #1 born 1/9/17
Baby Boy #2 EDD 11/4/18
But I also love Tess! And I think Maura and Tess are maybe even better together. My vote is Tess
Married: May 2008
TTC #1 since August 2015
FET #1: November 4, 2016
BFP: November 13, 2016
EDD: July 25, 2017