I didn't vote because it wont allow me to vote for more than one. Max is incomplete to me. Dylan is a boy name and horrible for a girl. If I saw Hannah and Dylan, I would assume that Dylan was the brother of Hannah. Plus if I was Dylan, I would be pissed my sister got a girl name and I got a boy name, and assume my parents were hoping for a boy but got stuck with me. The rest of the names I like, but if I had to pick two, I would also pick Benjamin (because I like the nickname Ben) and Claire.
I didn't vote, because you need 2 polls to get accurate results. I vote Max and Claire. I agree that Dylan for a girl is bad, especially with something as classic and feminine as Hannah. The other girl names pair much better.
They are all nice names. Although I would not use Dylan for a girl, especially since you already have a daughter with a feminine name (Hannah Jane)... as pp suggested, to give a second daughter a masculine name would risk mixed messages and maybe hurt feelings.
Max is cute but I would consider Maxwell as the formal name and Max as a nickname.
Re: Baby Name both genders
Max is cute but I would consider Maxwell as the formal name and Max as a nickname.
EDD for #1: 3/19/17