If all of those names are the same in terms of level of importance to you, I would nix Mamie (it rhymes with Lucy), Lois and Lotus (just my personal style, I'm not a huge fan of the alliteration). I voted Evelyn because I think it's a pretty name that goes well with Lucy, but I think Eve and Ethel are fine.
For the love of all things decent just scrap Mamie -- and Ethel too unless you plan on doubling down on the theme and naming your next born Little Ricky or something.
BTW my daughter is also Lucy. People always compliment her name and while it seems like it should be very popular, I really don't run into many other baby Lucys too often. Not yet atleast.
Lol @cortney227 no little Rickys planned here. And my 2nd is Henry and it's similarly popular but we haven't met so many that it's been a problem. Just a couple here and there.
Ok Lucy Evelyn it is! Thank you everyone! I still don't know if we are having a boy or girl yet but once I figure out middle name options for boy I might post again lol.
Re: Which middle name with Lucy?
Lucy Evelyn is the safest choice though. And it's quite nice too.
BTW my daughter is also Lucy. People always compliment her name and while it seems like it should be very popular, I really don't run into many other baby Lucys too often. Not yet atleast.
Ok Lucy Evelyn it is! Thank you everyone!
I still don't know if we are having a boy or girl yet but once I figure out middle name options for boy I might post again lol.