Which sibset?

o_so_in_love

Our youngest daughter is M.eredith Anne. She'll be 2.5 years when this our next baby is due. Which name goes better with M.eredith? Judith or Mabel? Also, if it makes a difference we have names in our family with the following first initials: J, J, M, M, H, H (miscarried), M. Names with these initials was coincidental. We weren't/aren't necessarily trying to keep a pattern.

bbiutmcph

Judith mainly because I don't care for same letter siblings and Meredith and Mabel while both great are too much together

jessnjuan07

While I dislike both names immensely, I think Judith is less terrible.

4N6s

Naf of Judith. Mabel by default.
What about Violet?

angc4

Judith and Meredith is farrr to close in sounds for me, not a huge fan of Mabel but it gets my vote

magsugar13

neither

o_so_in_love

4N6s said:

Naf of Judith. Mabel by default.
What about Violet?

Viola is a family name so I'd like to keep that one as is ☺️.

MWoodside

I don't care for either, but out of the 2 I'd say Mabel to prevent both names from ending with a "th" sound.

queenbone

I voted for Judith because I think it is a nice, underused, biblical name. Also I think the NN Judy would be super cute when she is young. I don't love that it rhymes with Meredith, but I strongly dislike Mabel. Also the names starting with the same first name bothers me more than having the same ending sound.  

oneblessedmess

Normally I would say Judith is way better than Mabel, but because Meredith already ends in the -dith sound I have to go with Mabel by default.

Personally, I would scrap them both and maybe go with Judy, Julie, or Julia. ETA: Juliet is also a nice option!