Ergo or Tula

JustaMemory

When my youngest kids were Small Ergos were the new thing and I just KNEW I was going to have an Ergo with this froggy baby. BUT. My girlfriend has exposed me to the World of Tulas!!!!
O.M.G.
They are ADORABLE and have accessories!!!! But. Are they REALLY worth the price? I've seen some sets listed for over a grand!!!
I get it. They're rare. But can I truly justify the cost when I know Ergos are amazeballs?
The struggle is real for this excited baby wearer!
And here's a Bumpie just because I'm excited to share it and it's still a secret from a lot of friends and family.

ETA links to what I was babbling about!
https://m.ergobaby.com/baby-carrier/original-collection/night-sky-bundle-of-joy

www.tulababycarriers.com

JustaMemory

Sorry. I forgot to add links to what I was talking about.

https://m.ergobaby.com/baby-carrier/original-collection/night-sky-bundle-of-joy

https://www.tulababycarriers.com/products/standard-size-full-wrap-conversion-tula-baby-carrier-natibaby-asteria-dusk2365

WafflesFriendsWork

I found a special edition ergo at home goods for $90. IMHO, I doubt it would be worth the price difference. Maybe look for a second hand Tula? At least try them both out before a big investment.

Goodness you seem to have way more energy than me!

kjsmith9

I agree that the difference is probably not worth the extra expense.  We love our ergo, and still use it to back-carry DD at 2 years and 30lbs.

Also, google Kinderpacks and look at those - another good option that people love (and sometimes you can find for a little cheaper on ebay).

valigrl21

I bought an ergo with our second and love it! I have heard great things about Tula too. I am not sure what the differences are between the two though.

Brummy14

Also love our Ergo - it's been excellent!

catladymeow

They can fit different people/babies better/worse depending on how you are shaped. Here's a comparison chart.  

https://thehappyhippiehomemaker.blogspot.ca/2013/05/ergo-vs-boba-vs-tula-carrier-comparison.html

I plan on using a stretchy wrap for the newborn stage, and then trying on a few different soft structured carriers with the actual baby to see what works the best. My husband and I are both tall, so we'll probably have a tall baby, and in that case the Tula is probably a better option than the Ergo.

Brummy14

JustaMemory said:

When my youngest kids were Small Ergos were the new thing and I just KNEW I was going to have an Ergo with this froggy baby. BUT. My girlfriend has exposed me to the World of Tulas!!!! O.M.G. They are ADORABLE and have accessories!!!! But. Are they REALLY worth the price? I've seen some sets listed for over a grand!!! I get it. They're rare. But can I truly justify the cost when I know Ergos are amazeballs? The struggle is real for this excited baby wearer! And here's a Bumpie just because I'm excited to share it and it's still a secret from a lot of friends and family. ETA links to what I was babbling about! https://m.ergobaby.com/baby-carrier/original-collection/night-sky-bundle-of-joy www.tulababycarriers.com

And, why would it cost $1000? For some rare pattern or something? I see all of them for like $150 off of their website, on Amazon, etc. The only add-ons appear to be the infant insert or the convert-to-toddler extender. Maybe I'm confused, too.

melanie1422

I love my Ergo! Ive never seen a Tula irl, but Ive had my ergo for years and I love it so much I bought a spare.

allcampb

I love my ergo. However there is a site where you can rent a Tula, Ergo, beco, etc...before buying. The owners of the site are so helpful. If you tell them your height, bust, weight, etc...they will help you find the best carrier for your body. You can just buy it out right or rent to see if you like it. I would suggest this for moms that are on the fence. Here is the link or just google pax baby. The women are so helpful and knowledgeable.

https://paxbaby.com

Marinewife81

I'm actually looking at a become because they don't have the extra insert. The only downside is that they start at 7lbs. Dd was over 8 when she was born but DS was only 6lbs 14oz at birth and less when we got home.

Lentil1137

It really depends on how they fit you! That's the bottom line. I tried a Tula and found the wide waist to be uncomfortable and diggy, so I ended up with a Kinderpack. To me, the fit/comfort is most important. I also love KP's because they are super adjustable- a petite mom can pass it over to her large husband to wear or vice versa.
See if you can find a local babywearing group that has a lending library, you should be able to try various carriers. Oh, and you don't need an infant insert with a soft structured carrier, necessarily- I had a standard sized KP with my dd when she was an infant and I placed a rolled up receiving blanket across the bottom to prop her up. Worked perfectly and lots of moms do it. Have fun finding the perfect carrier!

0ashley

I'm a Tula lover. I've never tried an Ergo. $1000 Tulas are for the rich! I've owned a few canvas Tulas and one wrap conversion that was $400. I felt guilty after realizing the softness, etc wasn't really worth the extra money to me so I just sold the WC Tula. I have a standard canvas tula already purchased for the new baby, along with a couple of wraps and a ring sling.

allcampb

@0ashley‌ what wraps and ring sling do you have. I have an ergo with the insert but I want another option for when our lo is still tiny.

0ashley

@allcampb I have a new lenny lamb twilight size 4 and just ordered a Didymos Indio size 6. I haven't learned to use them yet. The ring sling I purchased from a local website with a good reputation for her own signature shoulder style- Wallypop.net. I've used it a few times for my two year old so far but I expect to use it much more for the little one.

And back to the OP- I also wanted to mention that Tulas have excellent retail value. If you buy a new canvas for $150, you can easily sell it for $140. Or buy for $140 and sell for $140 later. Usually you just lose the paypal fees (3%) and $12-20 shipping- zero if you can sell locally. So it's like paying $30 to use a Tula for a year or whatever. I can't speak to the resale value of Ergos. I think I see them used for $50-75 but have seen many warnings about counterfeit ergos so look that up before buying used.

yelah250

I mean, if carriers are your thing, I say go for the pretty one that sets your heart on fire. I have an ergo from my last baby that I'll keep, but I am getting a nice woven wrap and will probably spend a couple hundred on it (used) unless I find a steal of a deal. I know I'll get my use out of it so I don't feel guilty in the slightest.

Going to try a swimming wrap this time around. Can't wait!

Mamamads

bumppp