September 2022 Moms

Product Spotlight: Breast Pumps and Accessories

What are you favorite tools for boobie squeezing?
Current pregnancy -
First BFP on 1/4/22.  Due date 9/13/22.

Four prior losses, no living children - 1 first trimester miscarriage, 1 blighted ovum, 1 chemical, and one extreme premature live birth daughter who died at 15 days old.


«1

Re: Product Spotlight: Breast Pumps and Accessories

  • For second/third/+ time moms, what durable medical equipment (dme) company did you like for ordering your breast pump? My doctor recommended today I go ahead and call insurance to order one. The 2 companies my insurance recommended have terrible reviews online: Byram Healthcare and Edge Park Medical. Any experience with these or recommendations for somewhere else?
  • Loading the player...
  • edited April 2022
    @laj0217 I used Byram last time (2019) and had no issues. I used Aeroflow this time and it was also flawless service. I would definitely recommend checking there.

    With my daughter I used the Spectrum S2 and it was a good pump. My one and only complaint was that I couldn't easily move it around the house, which ended up being very important for me. So this time I grabbed the Motif Luna with the battery option (I had to pay $30 for that option, but I'm sure it'll be worth it). I learned my lesson about 5 months in that I needed a hand pump as well for when I was out without baby and needed relief. I chose the Lansinoh hand pump (under $30) and I absolutely loved it! I would sometimes even choose that over my electric pump, especially toward the end of my "pumping for extra" journey.

    If you're having trouble getting good output, it's possible your flange is the wrong size. I needed to order different flanges and that helped with the pain and output immensely. I used Pumpin' Pal and loved them.

    And for those who are curious, yes, the Haakaa is 100% worth it, especially in the first few months. Latch it to the side baby isn't on so it catches all of the letdown. I could easily get 6 ounces extra a day that way. Look online for methods to keep baby from kicking it off and research how to use it properly. It's super easy, but used incorrectly it won't work well.

    For us, I used the pitcher method. It takes two extra bottles a day, but is worth it. I used a tall Dr. Brown's bottle for the first pump of the day (we didn't use this brand, but we got it free for registering and it held a lot), then the second pump would sit in the fridge next to the chilled milk. Once I went to the third pump session, I added the second pump to the first and washed the second bottle until next time. It's important you don't mix temperatures, which is why this is how most people do it.

    For bags, we used the Kiinde bags because we liked the bottle system and once she dropped using them for milk, we used the extras as food pouches. And they're recyclable. 🙌🏻
    DD 10/2019
  • newbabymama27newbabymama27 member
    edited April 2022
    Quick word on the Haakaa, pretty useless if you have a low milk supply (me 😞). I would barely get anything out of it even after learning proper technique and use, so if you’re like me and it doesn’t work for you, know that’s okay too. It was quite depressing for me to watch it be a fail. I still have mine though and will try it again. 

    I got the Spectra S2 based on my bump mom group recs back in 2019 and it worked really well. I had to pay extra for shipping and duties to get it into Canada from Target (they have since eliminated shipping to Canada completely), but it still ended up being half the price of the monopolized Medelas in Canada so no regrets there. 
  • I will second aeroflow they were great to work with. If you're insurance does resupply on parts, they'll send you those too on a 3 month schedule. 

    I had a spectra s2 for my first. It worked great. I need to be able to adjust suction and speed separately to get the best output so medela (that was available then, not sure if there's been changes) wouldn't work for me

    With my second I switched school districts so I was able to get two pumps one from each insurance agency because you can get a new one even after baby is born. I got the motif luna (battery one didn't come out until after I had my second). And I loved it. It's pretty much the same as the spectra just sleeker in design and smaller.

    When I had the new insurance I opted to get the motif duo.... I don't recommend. I could get more milk with my haakaa than I could get with it. I emailed motif and explained this they thought maybe it was faulty and sent me a new one. That one worked the same. I'd get 2 or 3 ounces total with it when it I were to use my normal pump I'd get 4-6 ounces. I gave one to my cousin and kept the other as a oh shit I need one with no electricity and even 2 ounces of relief would be good.

    My cousin who has a second 6 months younger than my second got the motif luna with battery. She was having issues with it and contacted motif and was sent another. She found out she was an idiot and didn't push the cord in hard enough so that's why it didn't charge. So she gave me her second one, and it was so nice to be able to move about while pumping. Even something as simple as oh shit I forgot to lock the door and can't reach if I'm plugged in was so nice to be able to get up and lock the door. 

    I have 2 haakaas a smaller one, and then a larger one. I find the larger one gets in the way while breastfeeding and gets knocked off more. The smaller one, I fill quickly so I need to have a jar to dump in. 

    I love my Sarah wells pump bag, cooler, and pumparoos. 

    I keep all my milk in mason jars with pour able lids (amazon has many options) . On Fridays I dump it all together into a pitcher and separate into bags. The parents choice bags come in 10oz sizes and that's really handy when normally it's 6 oz, you use less bags that way. Both of my daughters didn't care for bottles, so I had a large freezer stash even though they went to daycare. I was able to donate through the human milk for human babies Facebook group. The last mom/baby I donated to a few times, made pumping and donating so worth it, unlike some of the others I met where it felt like a sketchy drug deal meeting them on the corner and handing over milk. 
  • @jhysmath How would you portion milk out of 10 oz bags? I would freeze them as her portions (4, 5, or 6 oz), but did a lot of 2 oz too on the recommendation from many on not wasting milk. It definitely would have saved me so many bags to freeze in larger portions, though!
    DD 10/2019
  • @newbabymama27 I had a completely different experience with the haakaa and low milk supply. I don't know how low is low but I started supplementing at 4 months. I would often get more milk with the haakaa in 10 mins than my pump in 30 mins. I'd get a good suction on my haakaa and it'd iterally suck everything out. I'd get a stream from the haakaa vs drops from the pump.
  • I went through Aeroflow last time and had a good experience. I got a Spectra s2 last time and loved it. Didn’t really like the lack of portability but it was manageable.

    I still have that and it still works so I’ll be using that and getting something else more portable probably this time around since I qualify to get a new one. I also plan on getting a haakaa this time around.
  • @babywiik wow that is super impressive!! I wish that happened to me!

    Low for me was supplementing starting at 2 weeks old 🥴 including domperidone prescription for me starting at 6 weeks postpartum. I really hope this time around is easier for me otherwise I’m out and formula feeding it is. 
  • I used various versions of the Medela Pump in Style in the past (2007 and 2013 versions) and will likely go with Medela again this time around. Insurance covers a new unit and I handed mine down to family many moons ago. It's familiar and portable. The Spectra ones look a little bigger than I'd like to be lugging around to work, home and everywhere else in between. However, I'll be looking into this Haakaa thing mentioned above! I typically only single pumped because I never tried a pumping bra to go hands-free, so I liked having one hand available for snacks or an e-reader. Any recommendations on pump friendly bras?
    [rant] Why are all our bras so specialized?! I'm already planning to get nursing bras, and a few nursing friendly tops, but now need to consider pumping ones, too? 
  • @mnmomma84 This is what I used last time and it worked pretty well if I needed to go hands free…

  • I hated my pumping bra (similar to the one @dsmith211 linked). It worked just fine, I guess, but I usually had to hold the flanges in place still to get proper suction. I did sometimes hack my nursing bras, but ultimately I found it much easier and less frustrating to just hold the bottles in place. Just my two cents and I know not everyone will agree. 🤷‍♀️
    DD 10/2019
  • Has anyone tried the cordless ones? Like Willow or Elvie?
  • I got the Freemie Independence (ordered through Edge Park, it was really easy and fast) and while I liked being able to move around and do things while I pumped, I never got a lot of output. I have heard that Freemies don’t have as strong suction as other brands, but it might have been user error.

    This time around I’m getting the Willow. Might as well go big or go home with this pregnancy.
  • @newbabymama27 breastfeeding is hard and such a mind game when you're unsure if baby is getting enough or not. It was such a relief to start using formula and know my baby wasn't starving. Hope this time around can be smoother for you.
  • @trapperkeeper87 I very rarely had to use frozen milk for either of my children. My frozen milk pretty much just got donated every time. My first I sent 8 ounces with each day and I'd take home 16 ounces at work. My second refused to eat at all for the first month of daycare. Then she was doing 8 ounces for a month and I would take home 16 ounces. Then she went through a phase for 2ish months when she would drink 16. I have daycare done bags for the freezer if they needed it, but not sure they ever did. When my second was about 9 months she decided she was no longer taking bottles again so I'd send milk on Monday and Tuesday and likely wouldn't the rest of the week.

    This is the pumping/nursing bra I used is cheap one is falling a part after a year, but it did its job. Essential Pump&Nurse Bra, All in... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00UK9K06U?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share
  • @mnmomma84 being able to go hands-free is amazing! Plus, spending half the time pumping is a game changer. I loved this bra!! The Sublime® Hands-Free Nursing & Pumping Bra– Kindred Bravely
  • I used a medela with DS and it was fine. Nothing special/did the job. I'm excited to try Willow this time! I love the cordless idea, but I'm not sure how I'm going to justify the price. I'll definitely keep it this time though in case we go round 3. In a couple months I'll send out the insurance request to see if it'll cover some of the cost. I do have a backup (pink spectra) from a friend who just finished breastfeeding with her youngest, in case I decide against the Willow.
  • @leannechristina Through sites like Aeroflow, you can check about your insurance super easily by entering your info. They'll immediately tell you if you qualify and for which pumps (as well as if you can pay an extra charge for an upgraded pump, like I did). Then you can pick one and they handle everything for you. Super easy!

    My insurance (BCBS) approved me and sent it within the week while my sister's insurance (UH) approved her and will send her chosen pump shortly before she's due to deliver. Both of us went through the same site earlier this year and had the same experience.
    DD 10/2019
  • I think Kaiser chooses for us.  Last time they just sent one after the baby was born (although sadly I ended up not needing it) - I don't recall having to do anything special.
    Current pregnancy -
    First BFP on 1/4/22.  Due date 9/13/22.

    Four prior losses, no living children - 1 first trimester miscarriage, 1 blighted ovum, 1 chemical, and one extreme premature live birth daughter who died at 15 days old.


  • I used Aeroflow today. All of the free ones were not ones I’ve heard of. I paid a small up charge of $25 for the medela pump in style maxflow. The ones I’ve been eyeing were  all $100+ even with insurance. It says it’s eligible to ship after 4/18, which I’m guess means insurance will pay/send it after 20 weeks. 
  • Thank you @ trapperkeeper87! I didn’t know about Aeroflot. I’ll check it out today. I have BCBS too, there’s hope!
  • @laj0217 I'm curious which ones they showed you. Do you remember? I was thrilled to see the Motif Luna on both mine and my sister's list because it's one of the best reviewed ones out there that was free. We both also qualified for the Spectra S2, which is a great pump, but I already have that and wanted to try something different.
    DD 10/2019
  • @kboydbowman Don't quote me because Kaiser in WA seems to function as its own thing. But, I contacted Kaiser Member Services and they told me that there is a company that they go through for the insurance covered pumps. I had to fill out a form with this company and they sent me a list of covered pumps and upgrade options. They will send me the pump 30 days before my due date. 

    I am upgrading to the Spectra Synergy Gold after reading lots of reviews. 

    I also found this really helpful group on FB. I posted the couple pumps I was looking at and what I needed and tons of moms offered their opinions. 

     https://www.facebook.com/groups/breastpumpreviews
  • @trapperkeeper87 there was a motif but not a luna (for free) and then there was one I didn’t recognize at all and can’t remember now. But I also have the HMO plan, which limits you the most with providers etc. There were several options at $25 and then the spectra was $135, willow was $400. 

    The reviews I’ve read said the medela with maxflow is good for pumping at work, and that was the one recommended to me by my doctor and a friend who’s the social worker for mother/baby at the hospital. It was also a really good price point for me and has the option to be electric or battery powered. The downside seems to be the noise level, but I have a private office at work so I’m less worried about that. 
  • @laj0217 Wow! It's amazing the price difference a medical plan can make. I've heard good things about the one you chose, and the only con I saw as well was that it's loud. I think you made a good choice! 👍🏻 
    DD 10/2019
  • Just ordered mine.  Kaiser only gave me a choice of two, one of which was the Medela w/Maxflow. I used the Medela last time and it was fine, so I picked that one.
    Current pregnancy -
    First BFP on 1/4/22.  Due date 9/13/22.

    Four prior losses, no living children - 1 first trimester miscarriage, 1 blighted ovum, 1 chemical, and one extreme premature live birth daughter who died at 15 days old.


  • As a first time mom, this all sounds very overwhelming....did y'all take classes or work with a lactation consultant around the time of birth? I have an appointment Tuesday so I'm going to ask my doctor about pumps and figure out what insurance covers, but did any of you buy pumps in addition to what insurance provided? I'll admit reading above I have no idea 🙃
  • @dvmmomma A lactation consultant is provided in many hospitals after birth (in the U.S.), and a lot of hospitals actually offer breastfeeding classes through their maternity department. Look at your hospital and nearby ones for classes (you can usually take classes at any hospital), and if you find one, plan to take it around 30 weeks or so, that way everything is still relatively fresh at delivery.

    I bought a hand/manual pump in addition to the one my insurance covered, but that's it. For now, just take a deep breath and check out the Aeroflow site and others like that that were mentioned above. 
    DD 10/2019
  • @dvmmomma go to aeroflow and put in your insurance information. They will do everything for you except pick out the pump. I read many a review before deciding, there are lots on the internet. 

    I read Ina May's guide to breastfeeding and felt that gave more information than the lactation appointment before I gave birth. Mine felt more like a health class when she had diagrams and went over what tissues make up breasts. I felt she was useless after birth as well when she started to tell me I needed to use formula when I didn't. Thankfully I had educated myself, or I might have not been able to breastfeed like I had wanted. She did give me pump supplies in the hospital to use with the hospital pump that also have a manual pump so I had the medela manual pump and haakaa in addition to my electric pumps. 
  • Do you typically only have 1 breast pump or is it something you will want multiple of? My insurance, like most of yours, covers Aeroflow so I’m looking at the Spectra 2. That said, there’s a couple hands-free ones that seem intriguing and would be available at a super discount if I went through insurance. Since I’m a FTM I think I’m going to go with the basically-free option in case I struggle with breastfeeding, but curious if you guys think it would be worth it to pay out of pocket for a hands-free one as well if I am able to? Or just wait until the next kid to get one of those?
  • @mk2022x I personally would stick with the free one. That's a great pump (the Spectra S2) and you should be pretty happy with it. The women who really benefit the most from those hands-free ones are those who have very little time to sit and pump, like doctors and such.

    That said, I swear by my little manual pump for when I don't feel like getting everything hooked up. It was about $30 at Target and pumped so much for me. My electric pump was used daily, but sometimes I just grabbed that one instead to get the milk out because it worked so well for me. That's the kind of situation where you might consider getting more than one.

    Save your money for other baby gear and don't risk having an extra pump lying around, not being used.
    DD 10/2019
  • @trapperkeeper87 yeah, that’s my thought process as well. Thank you for confirming!! 
  • @mk2022x my sister in law got 2 and never used the second one. She and the baby had a lot of medical issues the first 6 weeks, so they ended up formula feeding (totally get it!). I’d at least wait until baby is here and see if breast feeding is for you, and if so, what features you feel like you’re missing in the spectra. 
  • I'm a little behind reading this thread so there's too many posts to keep up with. So I apologize if it was already asked and answered. If you choose to breastfeed do you also have to pump? And does pumping hurt during and/or after? FTM and twitchy at the thought of having nipples being sucked and pumped. Can't believe I just typed that 🥴🤦🏼‍♀️
  • @nightknight it really depends on your situation. I’m in Canada and will take at least 12 months of mat leave (US ladies - I’m sorry. I can’t believe your country is so f*cked up about that) so I’ll be with baby all day every day for that whole breastfeeding journey. I didn’t get a pump ahead of time thinking hey I won’t need it since I’m not going back to work for so long but then my supply was shit and I had to pump after every feed for weeks to try to build it up after he turned 2 weeks old. It was also nice to have one for when I went out without the baby and missed a feed. I came home really engorged and absolutely NEEDED that pump because baby was already sleeping. So yeah short answer: if you have a short mat leave, you’ll need to pump. If you don’t, you can probably go without one if you have a good supply and can maybe just get a cheap manual one for those one off’s when you’re away from baby for a long time. 
    In terms of whether it hurts, it’s uncomfortable at first but it really shouldn’t hurt. A lot of the pain comes from using the wrong flange size (which you should learn about depending on the pump you get). Though I agree it’s such a weird feeling to pump and hear all those noises lol. I definitely felt like a cow every time. 
  • @nightknight I'd have at least a hand pump in case you need it. Being engorged is terribly uncomfortable. My supply was ok but not great. Around 4 months baby starting sleeping through the night so I would stay up a few hours later than her and then pump right before I went to bed so I'd be fine until morning. In the hospital, my milk took a while to come in and it was more comfortable to have the pump attached than baby attached. Baby got their turn but I needed breaks from them. Your nipples will be super sensitive at first and it hurts pretty bad but after a week or so they get really tough and it's not a big deal. 
  • @mk2022x I think one is fine. I only have multiples because I have had one for each of my kids, I had two insurance companies in my second daughters first year, and then my cousin gave me one with a battery I would suggest if the Motif Luna with battery is only $30 extra like it is for me you go with that one through aeroflow. The spectra s1 which is the same as the spectra s2 usually ends up being an extra $125 and I don't think that's "worth it". The S2 works great it's just a bit bigger than the motif luna. 

    As far as hand free pumps. I really wanted one as I wasn't sure I was going to get pumping time with teaching at a new school when I had my second. I ended up buying a portable one and it didn't work as well as the big models so it was useless to me and made me think that I can't use the hand free pump and they'd be making me lose what supply I had. 

    @nightknight If you're home with baby all the time, you won't need a pump. If you're one of those amazing moms that can hand express really well, you won't need any pump. I remember with my first, the first time she slept a 4 hour stretch I was in a ton of pain and didn't have a pump as we were traveling and at a hotel, I had to hand express a bunch of milk into the shower just to get the ladies to not be rock hard and allow my daughter to latch on. 

    I will say that pumping hurts less than baby especially in the beginning because you're not working on perfecting the latch of a machine. After a few weeks, if you don't have any complications with latch and such, it shouldn't really hurt. That being said, my nipples were really sensitive from when I ovulated until my period came and nursing during that time was never comfortable, with my first when it happened the first time, I thought she was getting teeth and biting me, I was so sad I thought I was going to have to stop breastfeeding and she was only 6 months old. Thankfully after I got my period, it went back to not hurting and everything was fine. 
  • lalarose22lalarose22 member
    edited April 2022
    I got a Medela through our insurance and it worked really well for me. I also registered for and got the harmony manual breast pump from Medela which I only used a couple times, but really came in handy when I needed it! This weekend I'm going away and my 17 mo still nurses before bed, so I'm bringing my harmony with to express some milk before bed both nights to keep my supply/avoid any discomfort.

    Harmony - Manual Breast Pump | Medela | Medela
  • Both hospitals I've delivered at, if you ask to use the pump while there, they give you the pieces plus the manual pump from above to go home with. It comes in clutch in the early days when you need relief. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"