Community› The Bump Message Boards› Baby Names
Baby Names
New Discussion

Three girls in a row

o_so_in_loveo_so_in_love member
in Baby Names

Meredith, Judith, Edith

Meredith, Judith, Beatrice

Meredith, Judith, Eleanor

Which sibling set sounds best? We were kinda liking Edith, We didn’t try to do -dith names on purpose with Judith. That just happened. But is Edith too much since it’s the last part or Meredith’s name? Our kids like Beatrice. Family members like Eleanor. 

? PgAL/PAL Welcome ? My Chart ?
Lilypie Kids Birthday tickersLilypie Kids Birthday tickers

Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Lilypie Angel and Memorial tickers

BabyFruit Ticker
Report Reply to Post

Re: Three girls in a row

  • BringmemylongswordhoBringmemylongswordho member
    I love Edith, but not with your sibset. 

    I like both Beatrice and Eleanor, I don't think you can go wrong with either.
    Report Reply
  • BabyBoyH92016BabyBoyH92016 member
    I like Edith best (love Edie as a nn)  It is a little much with the other “ith” names, but if they go by nicknames, I think you can do it.

    Beatrice is my second favorite, but I think all 3 are great choices. 
    Report Reply
  • Loading the player...
  • bbiutmcphbbiutmcph member
    Like Edith but it’s basically the same as Meredith

    Eleanor pairs great and is a nice name


    Report Reply
  • holli0801holli0801 member
    I vote Eleanor 
    Report Reply
  • Tawny87Tawny87 member
    Eleanor
    Report Reply
  • DanyTargaryenDanyTargaryen member
    Eleanor. Edith is nice but feels like to much ith with your other girls' names. Especially since Edith is the exact ending of Meredith.
    _______________________________________________________________________________________________
    MMC 8/5/15 at 8 weeks
    DS born 9/13/16
    BFP 1/13/18 - EDD 9/20/18 - It's a boy!
    Report Reply
  • neverblushedneverblushed member
    I'm another vote for "no more -ith" names.  It's just too much.  Either of the other names is lovely.
    High School English teacher and mom of 2 kids:

    DD, born 9/06/00 -- 12th grade
    DS, born 8/25/04 -- 7th grade
    Report Reply
  • Jyoung327Jyoung327 member
    eleanor 
    Me: 29  DH: 31, married 6/21/14, TTC since 7/14
    BFP #1 EDD 7/17/15, MMC 1/9/15 @8w
    BFP #2 4/3/15= ectopic treated with methotrexate 5/1, YET ruptured 5/18/15= One Tube Wonder!
    2 Cycles of Femara, Ovidrel, & Progesterone= BFP #3 DS born 5/17/16
    TTC #2 March 2017 (initially med free) 
    BFP #4 8/14/17 *natural cycle* EDD= 4/25/18, MC @5-6w D&C 9/22/17
    BFP #5 12/29/17 w/ Femara/Ovidrel/Progesterone/Synthroid, EDD= 9/11/18 found out 1/18 ITS di/di TWINS!!!
    DS and DD born 8/21/18 
    Report Reply
  • MagFranklin13MagFranklin13 member
    Eleanor 
    Report Reply
  • AlyLynn07AlyLynn07 member
    I would pick Eleanor. Edith and Beatrice are nms (just not very pleasing to the ear if that makes sense), and Edith is too similar to the sibling names. 
    Report Reply
  • magsugar13magsugar13 member
    eleanor
    Report Reply
  • JMU_Bride09JMU_Bride09 member
    I agree that another -dith name is too much.  Eleanor is meh.  I think that Beatrice sounds nice with your sibset. 
    image
     
    image
    Report Reply
  • mockingjay1mockingjay1 member
    Another vote for another -dith name being too much. I like Eleanor.
    *TW*
    Me:35 DH:35
    Dx: PCOS
    DS1 born 11/2014
    DS2 born 11/2018
    3 previous losses
    Rainbow baby due 12/2021 - Team Green

    Report Reply
  • cantrelljacantrellja member
    Eleanor
    Report Reply
  • neverblushedneverblushed member
    Edith is too similar and sounds cutesy when put with your other children.  I have no problem with Meredith and Judith, but you are right that the third name would be side-eye-worthy.

    I am always partial to Eleanor, but Beatrice is also nice. 
    High School English teacher and mom of 2 kids:

    DD, born 9/06/00 -- 12th grade
    DS, born 8/25/04 -- 7th grade
    Report Reply
  • virginiaunicorn11virginiaunicorn11 member
    I like Beatrice the best but think Eleanor goes best. But if you’re actually neutral on Beatrice and Eleanor, why not let her sisters name her? That’s really special!
    Report Reply
  • theglitteredpterodactyltheglitteredpterodactyl member
    Beatrice sounds great and i think it's cute that it's your kids' choice
    Report Reply
  • amama3amama3 member
    Edith or Gwyneth(Gwynith)?
    Report Reply
  • bawagsbawags member
    I like Edith even though it is contained in Meredith. I would use it unless you plan on having a 4th....trying ot find another "ith" name you like might be tricky and with 3 "ith" names the 4th kid could feel left out. Eleanor is nice too.
    Report Reply
  • briide2be2008briide2be2008 member
    Beatrice or Eleanore 
    Report Reply
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"