They are both beautiful! I can see why you're struggling. Haha Evelyn is a little more my style but my husband is very very Italian so Gianna would sound good with our last name. Haha either one is nice though.
Both are pretty popular at the moment. My daughters middle name is Gianna so I picked that one! But it's funny... I almost named her Evelyn and changed it at the last minute!
Re: Baby girl names....Help!