I'm asking this purely for feedback on your experiences, not to recieve judgement. The reason I'm considering a planned c-section is purely down to family history, but the thought scares me. Xxx
The question isn't specific enough... What exactly are you asking? Would I rather have a c/s or a vaginal birth? Should you have a c/s or a natural birth? Sorry, I'm confused.
I'm confused? If you are already having a planned c-section why are you asking the opinions on a vaginal birth. You may want to include some more details in your post.
Yes I'm asking about people's experiences with both natural births and c-sections, if you've had both how did they compare. I'm only 14 weeks and will not be discussing birthing plans with my midwife until my 16 weeks appointment. Possibility of a planned c-section comes down to my anxiety problems, my mum carried a baby full term and was still born, a highly traumatic experience obviously, the c-section would purely be to know that baby will be delivered safely and hopefully won't at some point become in distress which is more likely with natural.
Sorry I read the considering wrong- it seems you are pretty set on a planned c-section though. I will say what happened to your mom is highly unlikely to happen to you. A c-section is major surgery and if you can have a vaginal birth I would try. I have anxiety too and I'm more nervous about a c-section than a vaginal birth. A vaginal birth does not mean your baby will be in distress that can happen for all different reasons.
Okay thanks that's helpful. I had a c/s the first time - DD was breech and we didn't find out til after her due date so no chance to try and turn her because there wasn't enough fluid. It was scheduled before I even went into labor. The operation itself went fine but recovery was hard. I couldn't stand up straight for a week because my abdominal muscles were so sore and tight. I couldn't climb the stairs in our house, I couldn't stand up without holding a pillow against my tummy. I couldn't lay down on my side when I could finally get upstairs to our bed because my abs were so weird feeling. Couldn't drive the car for 6 wks. It was a pain, all the physical limitations. That being said, I'm completely healed (eta 2 years later), had no complications, DD was fine. I'm going to attempt a vbac this time - all of the stats are in my and my baby's favor to do so rather than repeat c/s.
Your moms birth experience has no baring in yours. I personally would not do an elective C/S because it is a surgery. If it came down to it, and a C/S was medically necessary, then yes I would do it. Otherwise, vaginal for me
I have never had a vaginal birth but I had a c section due to a breech baby. I was awake for the whole thing but couldn't move from my abdomen down. There were about 10 different healthcare professionals in the OR with me and I felt exposed and like I had no control. I have a lot of anxiety and I just hated that experience. I also had a lot of pain with my recovery. This time around I want to try for a VBAC if possible but we all know anything can happen. Talk to your health care provider and find out what your actual risks are (vs. Perceived risks) and hopefully you can both decide which both route will be best for you.
I had a vaginal birth with my first. I did have an epidural - and I literally felt NOTHING! It was so much easier than I expected.
As far as recovery goes, it was not bad. I had a few stitches, but cleaning wasn't hard, I didn't have limitations like not driving or being able to stand up straight.
I've heard horror stories both ways. I've talked with my doctors and they suggest remaining open to, and researching c/s just in case. The plan is vaginal but they agree that I should be informed about why, when, and how a c/s would be done so that I'm prepared for the possibility. I know I would feel uncomfortable with a c/s and everything that goes with it. My anxiety wouldn't handle that many people well. But what's best for the two of us is what I'll always go with bf agrees thankfully lol
I would definitely try for a vaginal delivery. Recovery is much faster. If something comes up and you need a c section, fine. But like others said, it's major surgery. I don't think that an elective c section is meant for people that are just worried and have anxiety about a vaginal birth. Just because people in your family had troubles, doesn't mean that you will, too. You need to keep in mind that when you deliver at a hospital they have so many monitors on you and on the baby (heart rate, etc.) that if anything is going awry then they will know about it.
I also just wanted to point out that if you're in the age range of most of us here, then your mom's experience was likely 20-30 years ago? Medical technology has improved much since then and I think the doctors are much more likely to catch an issue that could lead to a stillbirth now.
I'm pregnant with twins and will probably have a c section. I'd only consider vaginal if I go into labor naturally at 36ish+ and both are vertex. Even then I am on the fence.
All the advice and stories here are great. I just want to add, vaginal births are safest for you and baby. There are complications from c-sections too. It doesn't guarantee anything. C-section baby's are more likely to have respiratory distress. Being birthed vaginally helps squeeze amniotic fluid out of the lungs. They are more likely to need NICU time compared to babies of the same gestational age born vaginally.
There are risks to both. Discuss it thoroughly with your midwife and SO. Good luck with your decision.
I don't really understand why c section automatically sounds safer for the baby? It's major surgery and doesn't come without possible complications for both of you. Not to sound like the broken record... But your body was made to do give birth and generally it works out as it should. That being said, if my doctor were to deem it medically necessary I would absolutely follow his orders on a c section... Nothing against them when they truly are needed.
I had a natural birth and I mean... It was birth, so it was hard as shit. I wouldn't change it though, I was glad not to have a c section to recover from.
I did not want a c section birth at all with my first, but researched it knowing it might happen. I went 41 weeks and went into labor naturally just 14 hours prior to a scheduled induction. Baby did have heart decels but nothing they couldn't manage by changing positions. I had a vaginal birth with no complications and no tearing (thanks to a wonderful nurse and dr who did massage to prevent tearing). I had a quick recovery and wouldn't change a thing. If this pregnancy requires a csection due to medical necessity I will be ok with it, but would never elect to have a csection as it is a major surgery.
I'm pregnant with twins and will probably have a c section. I'd only consider vaginal if I go into labor naturally at 36ish+ and both are vertex. Even then I am on the fence.
I had my twins vaginally at 35+1. Let me know if you want to hear more of my story. I can also tell you about my friend her had a c-section with her twins.
My DW had a scheduled section with our older girls so I know the drill, and am realistic about my odds. They were both breech so vaginal was never on the table. My practice won't do a breech extraction, so really it's a question of if I want to try or not. I will cross that bridge later when we know more.
my thoughts- either way... that baby needs to come out and there isn't one method that is always flawless.
My OB and I discussed that we are going to go into this assuming it will be vaginal but if he feels we need to do c-section on the day of delivery, i will not argue.
I have had both a c/s and vaginal birth. With my c/s I went into the hospital on Thursday, DS was born on Friday, we stayed in the hospital until Sunday. Recovery was about 2 weeks, that first week I couldn't even get out of bed on my own. After delivery I didn't get to see DS for 2 hours which was stressful and upsetting for me. With my vaginal birth, I was in the hospital just 30 hours, recovery was really quick. I was able to hold and nurse DD right after delivery and because of the quick recovery I felt like I was better able to care for her.
My vaginal birth was 100000x better than my c/s! I recommend trying for a vaginal birth unless a scheduled c/s is medically necessary!
FTM here and this feels like a silly question but...When do you even start addressing this stuff with the Dr? Touring hospitals and doing birth classes and what not?
I'm also interested in c-section options but it's due to a previous surgery. I'm going to have to ask my Dr when I see her on Monday if a vaginal birth will even be an option for me. This is my second pregnancy, I'm 16w2d but my first pregnancy ended in a miscarriage a few years ago due to a ruptured ovarian cyst and the surgery I had to undergo. Going into the ER they thought my fallopian tube burst because of all the internal bleeding they saw so they made a vertical incision just like a c-section. I have searched on Google and it says that a vertical c-section can cause complications if I choose to do a vaginal birth on the next pregnancy. Anyone have any experience with this?
@tankgrrl, c-sections can be very painful. I wouldn't recommend it unless it was absolutely necessary. The recovery took weeks but even then it took me months before I could do a proper sit up without my incision hurting. Everything hurts right after...breathing, laughing, getting up, laying down, going to the bathroom, walking, etc.
FTM here and this feels like a silly question but...When do you even start addressing this stuff with the Dr? Touring hospitals and doing birth classes and what not?
Tour hospitals sooner rather than later. Check their website to see if they recommend a certain point in your pregnancy. They usually have the birth class schedule too. I'd ask your doctor as early as possible about inductions and medical interventions you may have questions about. The more informed you are the more comfortable you will be going into L&D.
I had a csection - 11 lb baby, was induced but did not progress, they offered a csection and I immediately agreed and do not regret, but recovery was difficult. Walking up stairs with a giant baby was hell.
I have minor anxiety, and it was through the roof during the surgery, don't forget you are awake, I found it very stressful.
I am already seeing a nutritionist and following a gestational diabetes diet to try to ensure I do everything to prevent such a large baby again, (I also gained 70 lbs so it is for both our health) but it seems to be a theme in my husbands family (all his cousins were over 10) so if this baby turns out to be as big I will elect for a section.
After everybody's feedback I'll admit I'm feeling much more open to the idea of a natural birth, I understand it's what my body was designed to do and feel it would be a great accomplishment. Lots of positive thoughts needed xxx
A still-birth would be a terribly traumatic experience, however they are VERY rare these days...Dr.s are able to keep a close eye on baby's vitals during labor & will rush for a c-section if they suspect the baby is under too much stress (I have two friends who this happened to & they have beautiful, healthy kiddos).
I myself had a natural labor & delivery with our son. 22-hour labor including 4 hours of pushing...the most exhausting day of my life but worth every second. Recovery was also no walk in the park - but it's going to be tough no matter how the baby was born. At the end of the day, a natural delivery is just that: natural. You'd be surprised at how well mama's body & baby work together to make it happen.
Worst thing you can do for yourself & your baby is psych yourself out about either form of delivery. Trust yourself to make the right decision for YOU! You want to look back at your birth experience & have positive feelings (or at least, as much as possible)!
I'm also interested in c-section options but it's due to a previous surgery. I'm going to have to ask my Dr when I see her on Monday if a vaginal birth will even be an option for me. This is my second pregnancy, I'm 16w2d but my first pregnancy ended in a miscarriage a few years ago due to a ruptured ovarian cyst and the surgery I had to undergo. Going into the ER they thought my fallopian tube burst because of all the internal bleeding they saw so they made a vertical incision just like a c-section. I have searched on Google and it says that a vertical c-section can cause complications if I choose to do a vaginal birth on the next pregnancy. Anyone have any experience with this?
The vertical incision refers to the way the incision is on the uterus. Did they have to make a cut on your uterus for that procedure? It would be fine if the skin was cut up and down and the uterus was not cut at all, or if they made a cut on it horizontally. You'll need your records of the surgery for your doctor to look over I'm sure. The surgery on your tubes should not matter in regards to vaginal or c/s, but again you'll need to make sure with the doctor. Good luck!
I've only had c sections , I haven't experienced natural vaginal birth.. unfortunately my pelvic area is too narrow to deliver any children naturally. I don't progress past 3 centimeters I only learned this after being In full blown horrific labor for almost 2 days with no progression lol at least now I know. Anyway I've had 2 c sections the 2nd one was alot easier to recover from then the first.. the only down part was I was very nauseous and threw up almost the whole procedure... but not everyone has a choice on delivery methods I again will be having a 3rd c section. . If u have the option I would definitely try naturally ..
When your baby passes through the vaginal canal, you pass on critical antibodies to him/her. You're also more likely to be able to have immediate skin to skin contact.
FTM, so just some thoughts here. As women, our bodies really were made to naturally deliver babies, despite the fact that we are supposed to be able to do it in so much pain... ; ). Now there are obviously plenty of medical reasons that women need to have c-sections and it's great that we have the means to do so for the safety of both mom and baby! But I personally think it is better to attempt the natural birth. Now this isn't for everyone, and I've never done it but there are inspirational or therapy type audio out there that is meant to help with labor. Some people aren't in to that stuff, and that's cool, but since you mentioned anxiety the ability to work on your thought process might be helpful to you? Just an idea. Whatever you decide, you go momma.
I'll be having a repeat c-section. I had one with my first after 36 hours of labor and no progress. My pelvis is narrow and oddly shaped and although I had an extremely healthy pregnancy and baby, we most likely would not have survived a vaginal birth. My midwife and doc agreed last time that it was unlikely that I'd ever be able to give birth vaginally and I've become okay with that. My procedure was quick, easy and recovery was almost completely painless and also very easy.
A lot of women, myself included, find that calling or implying that a c-section is "unnatural" (yes, I know ideally our bodies are intended to give birth vaginally) or somehow less than a vaginal birth, can be... off putting. Just throwing that out there. C-sections aren't horrible or evil or "failing." It's a very sensitive subject for me because there is so much judgment around it, so I'm not trying to call anyone out or be a jerk, I just wanted to put my two cents in about it.
Well said Adventuremama I haven't had a c-section but I would absolutely have one if necessary. I don't think anyone is saying they are evil on here but I know in the real world a lot of people are cruel and judgemental and think they are. I am very lucky and had 3 natural births - all induced as I don't go into labour naturally! But they were no walk in the park either - they were quick but out of this world painful at the end, due to the last two babies misbehaving and being stuck in odd positions in the pelvis (waiting for them to change position was agony) but that said I got through it and I felt amazing afterwards (shattered and a bit bruised but normal). As I say though I'm one of the lucky ones. My SIL has had all of her 3 through c-section and has a lot of prejudice from people - that is until she puts them in their place and explains that she and baby would have died if she didn't have c-sections (she is very petit and has a tiny pelvis with big babies - it was never going to work naturally). She tried for a natural delivery with 1st baby and after 50 hours of labour she finally had an emergency c-section and due to the trauma of the whole thing nearly bled out on the table! Second and third babies were elective and were fine and she said she felt great after (with pain meds for a couple of weeks). Our cousin on the other hand is one of these anti c-section folk (c-sections are evil, unnatural all moms that do them are selfish and only consider the easy route etc etc) so when she was expecting her first she stupidly broadcasted her views on c-sections all over Facebook on a regular basis (you can see where this is headed) she also said how she WAS going to have a home birth (silly IMO with first baby as it's unpredictable) and low and behold when the time of the birth came around she lasted about 2 hours at home before she couldn't stand it anymore and went into hospital, had all pain relief going and then it wasn't progressing as it should as she was exhausted too so she had an emergency c-section and came out battered and bruised and in a pretty bad way!!! Needles to say their was a lot of "well that's karma" from people behind her back as she had been so actively anti c-section for months. So OP I guess what I'm saying is - yes try your body first but if it's not favourable then accept that c-section will happen. But I personally would never choose it unless their was a medical reason or my baby's life was at risk. C-sections aren't evil but they are no walk in the park either but then natural deliveries hurt like hell too. So my best advice - gas and air and lots of it I'll be trying a natural delivery again with no.4 - but we will see
Yes! No one on here was overtly negative about it. I just wanted to throw it out there to show the other side. Because you wouldn't believe the kind of comments you get about having a c-section... From "I'd never do that" (as if I had a choice?) to "Don't you regret that you didn't REALLY give birth?" (Uh, my baby is here in the world, isn't he?) to "C-sections are the easy way out...it isn't birth, it's surgical extraction." So yeah. Although my surgery went well and I didn't have much trouble with recovery, nothing about my birthing experience was "the easy way out" trust me. :P
Anyway, this is veering off topic, sorry OP. Talk to your doc, do lots of reading about vaginal births AND c-sections so you're prepared for anything, and see how it goes. That's my best advice. If you don't have a medical reason for a c-section (breech baby, placenta issues, etc.), prepare for the vaginal birth and if it changes, your doc will be right there to monitor and explain everything should you need surgery.
I did not know you could choose a c-section if there is no reason for it. Do insurance companies pay for that? I'll be having a C this go round and I'm terribly afraid! It's the safest way for my babies, so that's enough for me. My first was vaginal, I had an epidural and felt nothing.
I'll be having a repeat c-section. I had one with my first after 36 hours of labor and no progress. My pelvis is narrow and oddly shaped and although I had an extremely healthy pregnancy and baby, we most likely would not have survived a vaginal birth. My midwife and doc agreed last time that it was unlikely that I'd ever be able to give birth vaginally and I've become okay with that. My procedure was quick, easy and recovery was almost completely painless and also very easy.
A lot of women, myself included, find that calling or implying that a c-section is "unnatural" (yes, I know ideally our bodies are intended to give birth vaginally) or somehow less than a vaginal birth, can be... off putting. Just throwing that out there. C-sections aren't horrible or evil or "failing." It's a very sensitive subject for me because there is so much judgment around it, so I'm not trying to call anyone out or be a jerk, I just wanted to put my two cents in about it.
I absolutely agree. C-sections are wonderful things and save lives of moms and babies in emergencies everyday. I'm also annoyed when there is judgement tossed around about c-sections. The goal is a healthy mom and baby.
I just don't want OP to think that it's the 'easy' or 'safe' way to give brith. Most people would not argue with a c-section recommended by the midwife/doctor. It's the best option in some situations.
The only time I judge a C-section is when it is done purely for convenience of the mother or doctor. There certainly are very valid medical reasons for having one done. For those that have had them, I can't believe people told you it was the easy way out! Though common, it's still major surgery and I'm terrified of having one for that reason! People are crazy. If it makes you feel any better, people have said stuff like that about me choosing to have an epidural. SMH.
That said, I will try to avoid one if at all possible. I will also try to avoid inducing if I can. I was induced with both DD and DS for medical reasons so am not opposed to it, but I would prefer to go into labor on my own this time. I didn't enjoy being strapped to the bed the whole time. Although I'll do whatever is necessary for a healthy baby!
I'm hoping to attempt an all natural VBAC. I would like to avoid drugs at all costs only because I was so drugged up by the time they initiated anesthesia for the c-section. I was just so out of it. But I think I'll know better once I'm later in pregnancy.
One of my friends has had both and she was in FAR more pain and discomfort after the cesarean than the vaginal birth. Her baby was breach and unable to be turned so she had no choice. She's having another baby soon and will attempt v-bac.
I'm having a tough time with this decision. About a year ago, I met with a specialist prior to becoming pregnant because I have had 2 DVTs in the past (non pregnancy related, I'm FTM). She told me that I would need a csection for several reasons, so I have been been planning on that. Last week I went to my first OBGYN appointment and she told me I could deliver vaginally, no problem. So now I don't know who or what to believe. It's scary to have 2 different expert opinions that don't match.
The only time I judge a C-section is when it is done purely for convenience of the mother or doctor. There certainly are very valid medical reasons for having one done. For those that have had them, I can't believe people told you it was the easy way out! Though common, it's still major surgery and I'm terrified of having one for that reason! People are crazy. If it makes you feel any better, people have said stuff like that about me choosing to have an epidural. SMH.
That said, I will try to avoid one if at all possible. I will also try to avoid inducing if I can. I was induced with both DD and DS for medical reasons so am not opposed to it, but I would prefer to go into labor on my own this time. I didn't enjoy being strapped to the bed the whole time. Although I'll do whatever is necessary for a healthy baby!
IMO, it isn't my place to judge how someone chooses to give birth, no matter what.
Re: C-section or natural?
Sorry, I'm confused.
You may want to include some more details in your post.
I'm only 14 weeks and will not be discussing birthing plans with my midwife until my 16 weeks appointment.
Possibility of a planned c-section comes down to my anxiety problems, my mum carried a baby full term and was still born, a highly traumatic experience obviously, the c-section would purely be to know that baby will be delivered safely and hopefully won't at some point become in distress which is more likely with natural.
I will say what happened to your mom is highly unlikely to happen to you. A c-section is major surgery and if you can have a vaginal birth I would try. I have anxiety too and I'm more nervous about a c-section than a vaginal birth.
A vaginal birth does not mean your baby will be in distress that can happen for all different reasons.
I had a c/s the first time - DD was breech and we didn't find out til after her due date so no chance to try and turn her because there wasn't enough fluid. It was scheduled before I even went into labor.
The operation itself went fine but recovery was hard. I couldn't stand up straight for a week because my abdominal muscles were so sore and tight. I couldn't climb the stairs in our house, I couldn't stand up without holding a pillow against my tummy. I couldn't lay down on my side when I could finally get upstairs to our bed because my abs were so weird feeling. Couldn't drive the car for 6 wks. It was a pain, all the physical limitations.
That being said, I'm completely healed (eta 2 years later), had no complications, DD was fine. I'm going to attempt a vbac this time - all of the stats are in my and my baby's favor to do so rather than repeat c/s.
As far as recovery goes, it was not bad. I had a few stitches, but cleaning wasn't hard, I didn't have limitations like not driving or being able to stand up straight.
I would definitely recommend a vaginal delivery.
Medical technology has improved much since then and I think the doctors are much more likely to catch an issue that could lead to a stillbirth now.
I'm pregnant with twins and will probably have a c section. I'd only consider vaginal if I go into labor naturally at 36ish+ and both are vertex. Even then I am on the fence.
There are risks to both. Discuss it thoroughly with your midwife and SO. Good luck with your decision.
I had a natural birth and I mean... It was birth, so it was hard as shit. I wouldn't change it though, I was glad not to have a c section to recover from.
My DW had a scheduled section with our older girls so I know the drill, and am realistic about my odds. They were both breech so vaginal was never on the table. My practice won't do a breech extraction, so really it's a question of if I want to try or not. I will cross that bridge later when we know more.
My vaginal birth was 100000x better than my c/s! I recommend trying for a vaginal birth unless a scheduled c/s is medically necessary!
This is my second pregnancy, I'm 16w2d but my first pregnancy ended in a miscarriage a few years ago due to a ruptured ovarian cyst and the surgery I had to undergo.
Going into the ER they thought my fallopian tube burst because of all the internal bleeding they saw so they made a vertical incision just like a c-section.
I have searched on Google and it says that a vertical c-section can cause complications if I choose to do a vaginal birth on the next pregnancy.
Anyone have any experience with this?
@tankgrrl, c-sections can be very painful. I wouldn't recommend it unless it was absolutely necessary. The recovery took weeks but even then it took me months before I could do a proper sit up without my incision hurting.
Everything hurts right after...breathing, laughing, getting up, laying down, going to the bathroom, walking, etc.
I'd ask your doctor as early as possible about inductions and medical interventions you may have questions about. The more informed you are the more comfortable you will be going into L&D.
I have minor anxiety, and it was through the roof during the surgery, don't forget you are awake, I found it very stressful.
I am already seeing a nutritionist and following a gestational diabetes diet to try to ensure I do everything to prevent such a large baby again, (I also gained 70 lbs so it is for both our health) but it seems to be a theme in my husbands family (all his cousins were over 10) so if this baby turns out to be as big I will elect for a section.
I myself had a natural labor & delivery with our son. 22-hour labor including 4 hours of pushing...the most exhausting day of my life but worth every second. Recovery was also no walk in the park - but it's going to be tough no matter how the baby was born. At the end of the day, a natural delivery is just that: natural. You'd be surprised at how well mama's body & baby work together to make it happen.
Worst thing you can do for yourself & your baby is psych yourself out about either form of delivery. Trust yourself to make the right decision for YOU! You want to look back at your birth experience & have positive feelings (or at least, as much as possible)!
Good luck & best wishes!
A lot of women, myself included, find that calling or implying that a c-section is "unnatural" (yes, I know ideally our bodies are intended to give birth vaginally) or somehow less than a vaginal birth, can be... off putting. Just throwing that out there. C-sections aren't horrible or evil or "failing." It's a very sensitive subject for me because there is so much judgment around it, so I'm not trying to call anyone out or be a jerk, I just wanted to put my two cents in about it.
Anyway, this is veering off topic, sorry OP. Talk to your doc, do lots of reading about vaginal births AND c-sections so you're prepared for anything, and see how it goes. That's my best advice. If you don't have a medical reason for a c-section (breech baby, placenta issues, etc.), prepare for the vaginal birth and if it changes, your doc will be right there to monitor and explain everything should you need surgery.
I'll be having a C this go round and I'm terribly afraid! It's the safest way for my babies, so that's enough for me. My first was vaginal, I had an epidural and felt nothing.
Two years, two losses and three IUIs...
We are having TRIPLETS!
EDD 1/26/16
GGB born November 2015!
I just don't want OP to think that it's the 'easy' or 'safe' way to give brith. Most people would not argue with a c-section recommended by the midwife/doctor. It's the best option in some situations.
The only time I judge a C-section is when it is done purely for convenience of the mother or doctor. There certainly are very valid medical reasons for having one done. For those that have had them, I can't believe people told you it was the easy way out! Though common, it's still major surgery and I'm terrified of having one for that reason! People are crazy. If it makes you feel any better, people have said stuff like that about me choosing to have an epidural. SMH.
That said, I will try to avoid one if at all possible. I will also try to avoid inducing if I can. I was induced with both DD and DS for medical reasons so am not opposed to it, but I would prefer to go into labor on my own this time. I didn't enjoy being strapped to the bed the whole time. Although I'll do whatever is necessary for a healthy baby!
DD 12/20/99, DS 12/14/12, M/C 9/2014, M/C 1/2015