The great pop tart debate......

DogLoverX3 · July 2015

as I lay in bed this Saturday morning, enjoying my UNFROSTED strawberry pop tarts, the debate resurfaces between my husband and I. According to H, it's not a pop tart if it's not frosted?! What kind of logic is that?! Furthermore, UNFROSTED pop tarts are apparently inedible to him?! Obviously, unfrosted are my FAV!! Unless it's brown sugar and cinnamon pop tarts, the frosting ruins it! Thoughts anyone?! Am I alone out there?!

modanz1 · July 2015

You're husband sounds like a crazy person!

I am a frosted girl myself but there are only a couple of flavors I will eat. For instance, smores? No thank you. If you watch Family Guy there is an episode where Peter sings a song called, "Have you Ever put butter on a pop tart?" The song is hilarious and my husband and I need to try that now!

Escheffler34 · July 2015

I only eat the brown sugar cinnamon pop tarts, frosted of course!!!! That's the best flavor

I don't think I've ever had an unforseen pop tart!

lulamagoo · July 2015

modanz1 said:
You're husband sounds like a crazy person! I am a frosted girl myself but there are only a couple of flavors I will eat. For instance, smores? No thank you. If you watch Family Guy there is an episode where Peter sings a song called, "Have you Ever put butter on a pop tart?" The song is hilarious and my husband and I need to try that now!

I grew up putting butter on unfrosted pop tarts. Delicous

KeHill08 · July 2015

I'll have them if they're unfrosted, but I definitely prefer frosted. Smores is my absolute favorite!

grapesoda1111 · July 2015

I love unfrosted strawberry poptarts! Pop them in the toaster & put some butter on them. Nom nom. I'm also a fan of the hot fudge sundae ones

DogLoverX3 · July 2015

I'm going to have to look into this butter business!! Lol

nmwheel1 · July 2015

I'm a toaster strudel person preferably! But if I have pop tarts I'm team frosting!

VexedMommy · July 2015

Also a toaster struedel person here.

RaisingJulian · July 2015

I only like it frosted. Plus I freeze them also so it's like ice cream

kwaldy · July 2015

I like frosted blueberry...Or the fudge ones. The fudge ones MUST be toasted, with a giant glass of milk.

Dammit I want pop tarts now.

DogLoverX3 · July 2015

Toaster strudels are also amazing, but sometimes I need more frosting for those!! Lol

ash413 · July 2015

I eat strictly frosted blueberry or in frosted cinnamon.

And toaster strudels ALWAYS need more icing.
When I was a kid I would offer to make my brother a toaster strudel and then steal half his icing lol!

tayzav · July 2015

Smores all day. I've never had an unfrosted pop tart. And I never toast them for some reason. But now I really want a toaster strudel.

Edited because auto correct is a jerk and I don't eat "snores."

helsbels222 · July 2015

I'm with your husband in this one. Frosted all the way!!

nmwheel1 · July 2015

I honestly ate an entire box of Apple toaster strudels last week, I had a very week moment at the store but it was worth it!
And @ash413 I did the same thing to my little brother hahaha!!!

thegingeravenger · July 2015

I haven't had a pop tart since I was a kid. I ate to many of them when I was younger and now just the thought of them grosses me out!

I ate the purple and blue frosted ones, whatever flavor that is.

ks24119 · July 2015

I will only eat a frosted strawberry nothing else!!

strimble26 · July 2015

lulamagoo said:

modanz1 said:
You're husband sounds like a crazy person! I am a frosted girl myself but there are only a couple of flavors I will eat. For instance, smores? No thank you. If you watch Family Guy there is an episode where Peter sings a song called, "Have you Ever put butter on a pop tart?" The song is hilarious and my husband and I need to try that now!
I grew up putting butter on unfrosted pop tarts. Delicous

Yes. The best thing ever. Slightly toasted with butter. Amazing. I remember mentioning this here like 6 years ago and people were all aghast.

queenwog · July 2015

Team frosted. They're boring otherwise. Strawberry, blueberry, or brown sugar cinnamon, plz.

Gapeach83 · July 2015

I like both but only the berry flavors. But if it's is unfrosted it has to be buttered. I been buttering since I was a kid. Now I want pop tarts gee thanks if I wasn't hungry for everything today already.

Abonsut · July 2015

@RaisingJulian whoa in the feeezer? I need to try this. This may just be a game changer. I love a traditional strawberry (frosted) pop tart.

DogLoverX3 · July 2015

I'm def trying this butter business in the morning!! Love when I know at 5 in the evening what I'm having for breakfast-or maybe a midnight snack!! Lol

cbolton19 · July 2015

Mmmm. I have been craving pop tarts. Now I want them soooo bad! Brown sugar and cinnamon is by far the best! I need to try the unfrosted strawberry. That sounds awesome.

BowWowBowie · July 2015

why is there even a debate? poptarts are amazingly delicious no matter what flavor or icing!

Destini89 · July 2015

I only eat frosted brown sugar, and I unfrosted blueberry and strawberry pop tarts. I don't like any other kinds.

jscasher · July 2015

Brown sugar and cinnamon for me, and NOT toasted. Just right out the package. Yuuuum

ColoradoHiker · July 2015

Frosted 4 lyfe! My dad has always done the butter thing (on frosted), and I never understood it. Smores are my absolute favorite, with cherry being a close second.

Edit bc words are hard, apparently.

ecsmall08 · July 2015

I just bought 2 boxes of pop tarts at the grocery store the other day! Husband goes through them so quickly while I like to make them last. I will admit that I will only but frosted ( strawberry and cherry are my faves), but I won't turn down a pop tart if it's unfrosted!

hmf0245 · July 2015

modanz1 said:
You're husband sounds like a crazy person! I am a frosted girl myself but there are only a couple of flavors I will eat. For instance, smores? No thank you. If you watch Family Guy there is an episode where Peter sings a song called, "Have you Ever put butter on a pop tart?" The song is hilarious and my husband and I need to try that now!

One of my favorite Family Guy episodes..."have you ever put butter on a pop tart.. It's so freaking good..." Haha!!!! Oh and I looove frosted strawberry poptarts...I don't think I've ever tried the unfrosted!!

Edited because I can't spell!!!

lyankowi · July 2015

I have to drip warm, froasted pop tarts in milk...yum. I have never tried butter

elbou · July 2015

This thread made me drool. And start craving pop tarts. But the best part is that DH just bought some today! He never buys pop tarts, and I didn't even ask!! I think you guys are magic... <:-P

DogLoverX3 · July 2015

elbou said:
This thread made me drool. And start craving pop tarts. But the best part is that DH just bought some today! He never buys pop tarts, and I didn't even ask!! I think you guys are magic... <:-P

That's awesome!!!

Bootsie81 · July 2015

I'm so freaking hungry now. Thanks guys.

Also, team frosted poptarts.

august111966 · July 2015

As I just finished my last package of FROSTED brown sugar cinnamon poptarts this morning, I find this post to be offensive.

Also butter is good on everything.

dparker88 · July 2015

This post inspired me to go buy 2 packages of pop tarts and 3 packages of toaster strudels...

kmd91 · July 2015

Okay, so I am totally team frosted.

However, my favorite pop tarts are the chocolate chip ones. So they aren't quite frosted, they just have that drizzle.

chelmomma · July 2015

I'm all about frosted, strawberry pop tarts with butter. In the microwave for like 30 seconds. So evil, but so good. For the first probably 18 weeks of my pregnancy I craved pop tarts and peanut butter and jelly sandwiches!