June 2015 Moms

Unpopular opinion (U/O) Thursday!

Thursday is here! Time to write down those unpopular opinions!
«1

Re: Unpopular opinion (U/O) Thursday!

  • Loading the player...
  • edited April 2015
    klkonwi said:

    @karaelaine1991 this opinion you have actually is popular to me lol :) because I agree with you. It gets annoying and overwhelming between here and Facebook with the natural vs. epidural crap!

    Haha, maybe I'm not as much in the minority as I thought... but those "natural is the only way" people are so darn vocal that it makes me feel like I'm the only one who's not 100% on board!
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • My friend just completed a hypnobirthing course and she said it took "natural" to a whole new level. She said the tutor was seriously teaching them about aiming for an orgasmic birth and, ahem, "stimulation" being one of the best pain relievers. She said you can just ask the midwife to leave so that you can have some privacy and send DH down there! Let's hope for those of us who elect to give this a shot, that our waters don't break at an inopportune time and give DH a nasty shock :)
  • I actually really hate the "natural birth" vs using "med free". Because unless you gestated your child in a petri dish the entire time, all birth is natural, whether you go med free, with all the drugs, or need some other assistance to get everyone to the end safely. I feel it's almost demeaning to other moms. 


    I know I had another UO earlier this week, and I knew I should have written it down.... maybe it will pop back into my brain.
    Good point! :)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I agree - I don't think there should be any distinction. Who cares? Who even remembers and continues to discuss it months/years later like it matters - er, no one.
  • Westypet said:

    FloGirl82 said:

    I can't with the whole 'eating the placenta/placenta encapsulation/placenta jerky/smoothie/shake' thing. NOPE.  

    Oh my god, that pic just made my morning.
    Diane
    First Timer!
    EDD: 6-13-15
    Me: 34 Hubs: 37


    Pregnancy Ticker

    image
    imageimage
                                                                    Jean-Luc                                   Unna       

  • FloGirl82 said:

    I can't with the whole 'eating the placenta/placenta encapsulation/placenta jerky/smoothie/shake' thing. NOPE. Why would I want to eat an organ that my own body created, of which one of the main functions is to filter out waste/toxins....I mean, isn't it kind of cannibalistic? I wouldn't eat my own kidney/liver. I don't even eat those parts of an animal.  I don't think that there have been any scientific (key word) studies performed proving that it is beneficial to helping those suffering from PPD or helping out breast milk supply, or whatever some internet blogger claims it's magical effects are. 


    If you like it and are going to do it, good for you-spend that money, and make sure the person 'processing' your placenta does it in a sanitary way. I hope it will work out for you and do what you want it to do for you postpartum.  But for me, sorry, I view it as medical waste as soon as I expel it from my body after birth-throw it away. 
    I felt the same way you did as a FTM. It gave me the hebe jeebies. I'm probably in the minority here, and I don't really care, but after suffering from PPD, I'm willing to try anything this time, including taking my placenta in capsul form. I could never stomach a smoothie or "steak"...that's just not for me.

    As far as the feeling that it's cannibalistic, most other mammals eat their placenta and we don't chastise them, yet we drink a cows breast milk and don't bat an eye. Just food for thought. (Pun most definitely intended!) :D
  • mccall35 said:

    ElRuby said:

    FloGirl82 said:

    Snip

    Also, I'm pretty sure the main reason animals eat their placentas is so that predators are less likely to realize that there are new (and vulnerable) offspring in the herd. It's obviously not harmful to do it, but I'm not convinced it's some godsend for postpartum ailments.

    I was about to mention the very same thing, thanks!
    Diane
    First Timer!
    EDD: 6-13-15
    Me: 34 Hubs: 37


    Pregnancy Ticker

    image
    imageimage
                                                                    Jean-Luc                                   Unna       

  • ElRuby said:

    FloGirl82 said:

    I can't with the whole 'eating the placenta/placenta encapsulation/placenta jerky/smoothie/shake' thing. NOPE. Why would I want to eat an organ that my own body created, of which one of the main functions is to filter out waste/toxins....I mean, isn't it kind of cannibalistic? I wouldn't eat my own kidney/liver. I don't even eat those parts of an animal.  I don't think that there have been any scientific (key word) studies performed proving that it is beneficial to helping those suffering from PPD or helping out breast milk supply, or whatever some internet blogger claims it's magical effects are. 


    If you like it and are going to do it, good for you-spend that money, and make sure the person 'processing' your placenta does it in a sanitary way. I hope it will work out for you and do what you want it to do for you postpartum.  But for me, sorry, I view it as medical waste as soon as I expel it from my body after birth-throw it away. 
    I felt the same way you did as a FTM. It gave me the hebe jeebies. I'm probably in the minority here, and I don't really care, but after suffering from PPD, I'm willing to try anything this time, including taking my placenta in capsul form. I could never stomach a smoothie or "steak"...that's just not for me.

    As far as the feeling that it's cannibalistic, most other mammals eat their placenta and we don't chastise them, yet we drink a cows breast milk and don't bat an eye. Just food for thought. (Pun most definitely intended!) :D
    Well other animals don't turn it into pills or cook it so I wonder if the benefits remain the same... And how can anyone know for sure it's really your own placenta in those pills! What about cross contamination!
    I can't speak for how others do it, but dehydration doesn't remove the nutrients. A friend of mine is certified in it so she will be putting it in capsule form for me so I'm pretty damn sure she won't be sneaking anything else in there. As far as cross contamination, you're probably more likely to have that happen to you tonight when you're cooking your own dinner. Most people who do the encapsulation process don't just wing it. There's a process to it to ensure it's safety. But apparently I'm the one with the UO here. If you don't want to eat it, don't. If you don't want to do a natural birth, don't. If you don't want the drugs, don't take them. Good golly people! We've got some passionate people on here today.
    I think others are just sharing their thoughts on it... No one is telling you not to do it!
  • alcrimminsalcrimmins member
    edited April 2015
    I'm just really tired of the vaccination vs not vaccinating topic. Please do your own research and make a choice that is right for you and your family. Stop trying to tell me what to do and make my choice for me! Good gravy this drives me nuts!
    Maybe this is annoying me so much today b/c it was the topic on Law & Order SVU last night :P

    Edited for grammatical errors! Lol
  • Frogger5 said:

    I hate it when people call their unborn or baby sons "little man." It sounds so creepy and trashy to me. I see it a lot on here and I don't mean it personally, but ick.

    Lol. I'm so guilty of this!
  • FloGirl82 said:

    I can't with the whole 'eating the placenta/placenta encapsulation/placenta jerky/smoothie/shake' thing. NOPE. Why would I want to eat an organ that my own body created, of which one of the main functions is to filter out waste/toxins....I mean, isn't it kind of cannibalistic? I wouldn't eat my own kidney/liver. I don't even eat those parts of an animal.  I don't think that there have been any scientific (key word) studies performed proving that it is beneficial to helping those suffering from PPD or helping out breast milk supply, or whatever some internet blogger claims it's magical effects are. 


    If you like it and are going to do it, good for you-spend that money, and make sure the person 'processing' your placenta does it in a sanitary way. I hope it will work out for you and do what you want it to do for you postpartum.  But for me, sorry, I view it as medical waste as soon as I expel it from my body after birth-throw it away. 
    I felt the same way you did as a FTM. It gave me the hebe jeebies. I'm probably in the minority here, and I don't really care, but after suffering from PPD, I'm willing to try anything this time, including taking my placenta in capsul form. I could never stomach a smoothie or "steak"...that's just not for me.

    As far as the feeling that it's cannibalistic, most other mammals eat their placenta and we don't chastise them, yet we drink a cows breast milk and don't bat an eye. Just food for thought. (Pun most definitely intended!) :D
    A good friend of mine did the smoothie thing for her third pregnancy this past September. She had also struggled with postpartum depression with her first two, to the point where she was willing to try anything. For her, it worked. I hope you have a similar experience with the capsules!

    Now, me personally, I think it is, at least to some degree, a placebo effect... but, to each her own! I genuinely do wish you well with this, I hope you'll update us after the fact to let us know how it works out for you :)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Frogger5 said:

    I hate it when people call their unborn or baby sons "little man." It sounds so creepy and trashy to me. I see it a lot on here and I don't mean it personally, but ick.

    I feel the same way! and the other things that bug me are bow ties, and mustaches.  I know they are very trendy, but they drive me crazy! 
  • I call my baby chubby guy..... Condescending?! Maybe.... Lol I don't say little man though. Or man at all.....
  • klkonwi said:

    I call my baby chubby guy..... Condescending?! Maybe.... Lol I don't say little man though. Or man at all.....

    So cute :)  We did a 3D US last week, and our baby has quite the chubby cheeks :)  
  • FloGirl82 said:

    I can't with the whole 'eating the placenta/placenta encapsulation/placenta jerky/smoothie/shake' thing. NOPE. Why would I want to eat an organ that my own body created, of which one of the main functions is to filter out waste/toxins....I mean, isn't it kind of cannibalistic? I wouldn't eat my own kidney/liver. I don't even eat those parts of an animal.  I don't think that there have been any scientific (key word) studies performed proving that it is beneficial to helping those suffering from PPD or helping out breast milk supply, or whatever some internet blogger claims it's magical effects are. 


    If you like it and are going to do it, good for you-spend that money, and make sure the person 'processing' your placenta does it in a sanitary way. I hope it will work out for you and do what you want it to do for you postpartum.  But for me, sorry, I view it as medical waste as soon as I expel it from my body after birth-throw it away. 
    I felt the same way you did as a FTM. It gave me the hebe jeebies. I'm probably in the minority here, and I don't really care, but after suffering from PPD, I'm willing to try anything this time, including taking my placenta in capsul form. I could never stomach a smoothie or "steak"...that's just not for me.

    As far as the feeling that it's cannibalistic, most other mammals eat their placenta and we don't chastise them, yet we drink a cows breast milk and don't bat an eye. Just food for thought. (Pun most definitely intended!) :D
    A good friend of mine did the smoothie thing for her third pregnancy this past September. She had also struggled with postpartum depression with her first two, to the point where she was willing to try anything. For her, it worked. I hope you have a similar experience with the capsules!

    Now, me personally, I think it is, at least to some degree, a placebo effect... but, to each her own! I genuinely do wish you well with this, I hope you'll update us after the fact to let us know how it works out for you :)
    After experiencing PPD, low milk supply, anxiety, and delayed bonding with my DS, I would happily take even the placebo effect. For me, I'd rather have the option to take it vs wishing I hadn't thrown it into medical waste.

    @ElRuby I'm all for people sharing their opinions, but I feel like it was turning into the same attitude of those who are tired of being guilted about having an epidural or formula feed. All I'm saying is to each their own. All I want is for all the mommas to be happy and not feel any more guilt than we already do/will have about our decisions. I was just looking at it from the perspective of someone who was on the fence about it. Being thought of as a cannibal (which technically is just eating fat and muscle of your own kind, not your placenta) might dissuade them from seeking out the (possible) benefits. That's all
    I was suggesting.
  • I don't know of that comment was meant for me @lovethatcolosun, but I never said someone was a cannibal for doing it..just it seemed cannibalistic. I never chastised anyone directly and just said if it works for those who do eat it then good, but it's not the choice for me.
    Pregnancy Ticker
  • klkonwi said:

    I call my baby chubby guy..... Condescending?! Maybe.... Lol I don't say little man though. Or man at all.....

    Totally acceptable to me.
  • I think twice weekly NSTs are a waste of time and I'm thinking about going AMA (against medical advice) and only coming in once a week until LO starts getting cramped in there and I'm not as confident about his movements/kick counts (probably around week 34, I am 29 weeks now). I mean, I work 9-5/M-F, how the heck am I supposed to just leave work for an hour or more for you to confirm LO's activity on a monitor that I feel consistently everyday? I'm a nurse for Pete's sake! Give me some credit here!

    Me: 31
         DH: 34
    Married 11/09/2013

    LO#1: LMP 09/14/2014  BFP 10/15/2014  EDD 06/24/2015  DS Born 06/14/2015
    LO#2: LMP 09/18/2016  BFP 10/19/2016  EDD 06/27/2017 DD Born 06/27/2017
    LO#3: LMP 05/16/2018  BFP 06/18/2018  EDD 02/20/2019

      
  • @westypet I was that woman warrior champ my last pregnancy and I ended up having DS a little early at 36 weeks.

    This time around, not so much. Even though it's doctors orders, I'm totally fine with it.

    #thetowelsbeenthrowninalongtimeago
  • The whole placenta eating thing is disgusting to me. I barely eat meat. I just couldn't do it. I'm not educated on it at all and have nothing against anyone who chooses to ingest their placenta. Animals do it. Different things float different peoples boats.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"