July 2015 Moms

sprinkle or not to sprinkle?

2»

Re: sprinkle or not to sprinkle?

  • Loading the player...
  • I've never even heard the term sprinkle before. 
    Where I live, it's weird to not have a baby-shower with all your kids. I knew someone who didn't have a baby-shower for her second son, and seriously everyone thought it was weird. My whole family loves babies (I literally have over 25 first cousins and 5 brothers and sisters) and my family loves to give gifts to eachother. In my family and group of friends, it would be rude and insulting to not have a shower.
    Bobby Llewellyn born September 29, 2012
    Kade Wayne born July 23, 2015
    MC in February 2017
    MC in November 2017
    Oliver Dean (Ollie) due December 17, 2018

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015

    How about we all agree to disagree, and try to act like adult s with our responces.

    Way to many hormones going on in this thread but no point in name calling, or being rude to one another.

    Take a deap breath ladies and remeber that what is need here is support and friendship. No one should have to worry about being bullied or hurt when coming here to ask a question or give an opinion.

    :x

    For crying out loud nobody was "bullied" if you don't want honest answers and would instead like to her someone tell you to do exactly what you want no matter what then don't ask. Like I said before if I was doing something that is generally seen as a huge faux pas I would want someone to tell me. So really we are doing her a favor by letting her know her choice could be side eyed and talked negatively about. Does she have to listen? Of course not, but she asked and she got responses.

    @kaylee918‌ You obviously are like 16 and have no idea what you are talking about so I'll let your stupidity slide.
  • @Mamamads‌ I was mostly talking to the two going back and forth name calling that had nothing to do with the thread.

    I think at time when people feel strongly about a situation it is easy to be a tad snippy and not even realize how you are coming across to others. No one knows each other in real life, you cant see mannerisms when typing. It easy to think your opinion isnt rude even when 10 others see it that way.

    All I am saying is everyone has an opinion, they arent always going to be the same, but no one should be made to feel bad for asking a question. It good to get others opinions, it is why we all ask questions.

    Personally if I ask a question and have not posted much on a board and people start going hormone crazy, it leads me to not want to post anymore, and I think thw board has a great balance right now and dont want to see people who need to be here run off because adults are acting like children.
  • @Mamamads‌ I was mostly talking to the two going back and forth name calling that had nothing to do with the thread.

    I think at time when people feel strongly about a situation it is easy to be a tad snippy and not even realize how you are coming across to others. No one knows each other in real life, you cant see mannerisms when typing. It easy to think your opinion isnt rude even when 10 others see it that way.

    All I am saying is everyone has an opinion, they arent always going to be the same, but no one should be made to feel bad for asking a question. It good to get others opinions, it is why we all ask questions.

    Personally if I ask a question and have not posted much on a board and people start going hormone crazy, it leads me to not want to post anymore, and I think thw board has a great balance right now and dont want to see people who need to be here run off because adults are acting like children.

    Oye, I can assure you hormones have nothing to do with people's responses. That's kind of an infuriating thing to say. Also this is nothing, were U here a few months ago? This question would have gone done a lot differently and a lot less polite. Guess everyone has a different threshold for "meanies" lol
  • I was here and I never posted because I found the board childish and like highschool!!

    People were rude and thought it was funny and I have no patience for rude people who are rude just for fun.

    Im raising 4 children another on the way. Im educated and not a young mom, and I would have "spanked my kids rearends" for acting like 90% of the woman who were posting on here!!
  • Calling people names (ie stupid, smart ass, etc.) is mean and bullying. That was the point.
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015
    grlplz said:

    Calling people names (ie stupid, smart ass, etc.) is mean and bullying. That was the point.

    That is not what bullying is. Which is why I said something. I think it's ridiculous to cry "bully" when someone says something you don't like or insults you. That's not at all what bullying is and it's absurd to say it is. Maybe it's mean but not bullying.
  • *Bullying is the use of force, threat or coercion to abuse, intimidate or aggressively dominate others.

    Calling someone stupid one time doesn't even sort of fit this description/definition.
  • It's mean, it can cause physical or emotional harm to a person (an important part of the definition you forgot), and it is flat out childish. The point is she was telling people to stop name calling. There is no reason or point to argue with that because she is completely right. My 7 year old knows better than to call names, I think everyone here can figure it out too.
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015
    grlplz said:

    It's mean, it can cause physical or emotional harm to a person (an important part of the definition you forgot), and it is flat out childish. The point is she was telling people to stop name calling. There is no reason or point to argue with that because she is completely right. My 7 year old knows better than to call names, I think everyone here can figure it out too.


    Yeah that is part of the definition of bullying but calling someone stupid isn't bullying. Welcome to the Internet where you can't dictate how people speak to one another.
  • Oh okay, you can argue that calling names is a perfectly acceptable thing to do, really whatever. I just hope that in real life you do know better.
  • Do a shower but no gifts. That way it's really just a party and your mom can feel involved without it seeming like you just want gifts.
  • jonesy15 said:

    Wow I didn't realise there were so many rules!
    I live in the UK. I have noticed baby showers becoming more popular here over the past couple of years.
    Personally I don't like the idea of baby showers and haven't attended any.
    If people want to buy baby a gift or visit when he /she is born then so be it.

    Same. I didn't have one as (sorry guys) but it seemed like quite an 'American' thing hehe. Seems like they are causing a bit of trouble- last thing you need with all those raging hormones x
  • My sister in law's are talking about throwing one for us in the summer, just a small BBQ with close family and friends. My son is 7 (we are having a girl) and it has taken us 5+ years to get pregnant due to many fertility issues so BOTH sides are over the moon thrilled for this baby.
  • I agree if you want another baby shower why not? Why is everyone so uptight about the gift thing! Just tell people you don't expect anything i am pregnant with my first and having a baby shower it's not to grab presents it's to have fun and celebrate the fact I am having a baby with friends and family!!! If I have 5 children then I will have 5 showers and if that if that offends anyone then they can decline my invites! Who cares about etiquette do what's right for you!
  • sschwegesschwege member
    edited February 2015
    @Mamamads‌ I was mostly talking to the two going back and forth name calling that had nothing to do with the thread. I think at time when people feel strongly about a situation it is easy to be a tad snippy and not even realize how you are coming across to others. No one knows each other in real life, you cant see mannerisms when typing. It easy to think your opinion isnt rude even when 10 others see it that way. All I am saying is everyone has an opinion, they arent always going to be the same, but no one should be made to feel bad for asking a question. It good to get others opinions, it is why we all ask questions. Personally if I ask a question and have not posted much on a board and people start going hormone crazy, it leads me to not want to post anymore, and I think thw board has a great balance right now and dont want to see people who need to be here run off because adults are acting like children.
    @thismakes5
    I just have to say something here.  First of all if you scroll up to the top of the page you will see that I did give OP a constructive answer.  Second yes, we were going back and forth, but the name calling was one sided and notice how when she started with that I stopped posting.  Figured once you resort to name calling you have nothing to say worth reading.  I certainly don't believe I was acting like a child as you seem to be insinuating, merely explaining why I don't think others should be responsible for providing what every baby 'deserves' as pp was trying to say.  I just don't appreciate being lumped in with the other poster here, I decided to stop posting once the name calling started, decided not to take part in the name calling and also chose not to report her even though that would presumable be a violation.   
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015

    I agree if you want another baby shower why not? Why is everyone so uptight about the gift thing! Just tell people you don't expect anything i am pregnant with my first and having a baby shower it's not to grab presents it's to have fun and celebrate the fact I am having a baby with friends and family!!! If I have 5 children then I will have 5 showers and if that if that offends anyone then they can decline my invites! Who cares about etiquette do what's right for you!

    Wow you sound like a special princess who deserves everything! 5 showers? I can assure you attendance will dwindle for each one along with your group of friends. Nobody is responsible for providing you with what your children need besides you. That's honestly just taking advantage of your friends and family and a super crappy attitude to have. Ya, screw etiquette lets start coughing in people's faces or not being polite in general because "that's right for us!"
    If you don't want gifts then don't call it a shower/don't have a registery and spare yourself the massive side eye from people who are in your life and will judge the shit out of you for having a shower for every single child you have.
  • Let your mom do it . It her granddaughter n your real friends and family will not think anything negative about a second baby shower. A baby is a gift from God celebrate it
  • In my family we pass all the baby clothes and larger items around. There's 7 of us in baby making age so we have a shower for each baby born. Mostly our 'gifts' are well used hand-me-downs in some pretty paper. Plus we like to eat and are some pretty good cooks ;) I say have fun and enjoy.
  • So I'm in a similar situation, my very good friend wants to have a sprinkle shower for me. Im having a girl and everyone is thrilled. I am against it my ds is only 20 months old I had a baby shower about 2 years ago. I finally agreed to it. I agreed if we make it more of a lunch/girls get together outside as the weather becomes nicer and no invitations just very close friends by word of mouth. I want to have my close friends who I don't get to see much together to celebrate but don't want lavish gifts, but again I only had my son's baby shower 2 years ago.
  • I just jealous that your mother is excited enough to want to throw you a sprinkle. My mother doesn't want anything to do with throwing a shower for me, and this is her first grandbaby. To each their own.
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015
    Rahxy said:

    I don't understand why not. What kind of gifts do you get at a baby shower? Or a sprinkle? Is it silly stuff just for mom? Or is it stuff that your friends and family want to give to your baby? I always thought a baby shower was essentially a first birthday party, but before the baby is born, since you're not exactly in a party throwing mood after baby arrives.


    It drives me crazy when people say it's for the mom. That's like saying their 1st or 2nd or any other birthday parties are for mom, too. Guess you can only throw your kid one birthday party, because more than one is just gift grabby, right?

    It's true that the onesies and toys and etc make it easier to be a mom, but that doesn't make those gifts FOR mom. I'm sure as hell not wearing those onesies or chewing on any rubber giraffe.


    The whole etiquette of showers has always turned me off, and people always seem so snobby about it. It's the whole reason I'm terrified to even want a shower now with my first child, because God forbid I seem greedy or like I'm unable to provide for my child. Geez.


    Sorry if I've upset some people who are into the whole etiquette thing.

    I just don't understand how you could see it as anything but a birthday party. You're literally celebrating the birth of a child. Their first BIRTH day. You have the option to give this baby one of their first birthday gifts they'll ever get.

    If I wanted stuff for myself at a baby shower, I'd put a new computer, an iPad, and. DSLR camera on my registry. Not obnoxiously loud toys i know I'll be sick of in -3 seconds

    /rant I know I'm going to get crap for, but I'm too tired to care at this point.


    Basically OP, do what you want. It's your baby, you can have a sprinkle if that would make you happy, and anyone who wants to celebrate this baby will be glad to join you. If you don't want one, don't feel bad telling your mom that. She'll understand, and can still buy lots of gifts for your baby girl! ❤️

    I'm so damn tired, I doubt I'll even remember posting this comment in the morning. Damn these migraines.

    But yeah, etiquette says tread lightly, I personally couldnt give a hoot about that kind of etiquette. (Obviously don't be greedy, but come on.)

    Haha it's not a first birthday party.. No clue where you got that idea. It is a party to shower the mother with gifts for her child and welcome her into motherhood. Look it up. And it is things for you because you are using them for your child. A newborn certainly can't use a blanket himself or bottles himself but nice try.
    Unfortunately there is etiquette for everything we do in life but you don't have to follow it of course.. Just be prepared for some funny looks if it's not something that is completely acceptable in your culture/circle of friends.
  • @rahxy I think the way you have to look at it is the purpose of the party and perhaps that will make it more clear as to the distinction between throwing a birthday party for your child and throwing your own shower or having one hosted for you.  The purpose of a birthday party is to celebrate the birth of your child, gifts while customary are not the purpose of the party.  The purpose of a baby shower is to 'shower' the MTB with gifts that will be useful once the baby is born.  Similarly the purpose of a wedding is to get married, gifts are customary but not the purpose of the celebration, this is why it is appropriate to host your own wedding.  People most likely will bring gifts, but some don't and again the reason you have a wedding is to get married, not for gifts.  The purpose of a wedding shower is to shower the new couple with gifts that will be useful once they are married.  Hence making it inappropriate to host your own wedding shower because the purpose of the shower is to give/receive gifts and it is never OK to solicit other people for gifts. 

    Some people argue every baby 'deserves' to celebrated, OK, but if that was the case wouldn't the guest of honor...the baby, in fact be in attendance?  Making hosting a 'meet the baby' party after the baby comes appropriate, the purpose of the party is to meet the baby, people will probably bring gifts but that is not the intention of the party. 
     
    As I said in my post to the OP in some circles they have showers for STM+ moms if that is the case then I guess that's one thing.  However, if you have to ask as OP is doing that seems to indicate that is not common in her circle and probably would be frowned upon. 
  • Celebrate every baby. You don't have to register for all new stuff. Maybe just have a diaper shower? People will probably still buy little girl outfits. If people don't want to celebrate with you, you may want to reevaluate those relationships anyway. I think that's terrible that a friend would not attend a shower just bc it's the second baby.
  • Mamamads I don't understand why u are so angry. Your posts here are indeed coming across and very mean, angry, and yes bullying. We are all entitled to our opinions but belittling someone for their opinion is uncalled for. We are all here to share and ask other women in our position their opinions on certain matters. Telling someone they think themselves to be a special princess because they want to celebrate their babies is just, well, unneeded.
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015
    twindlej said:

    Mamamads I don't understand why u are so angry. Your posts here are indeed coming across and very mean, angry, and yes bullying. We are all entitled to our opinions but belittling someone for their opinion is uncalled for. We are all here to share and ask other women in our position their opinions on certain matters. Telling someone they think themselves to be a special princess because they want to celebrate their babies is just, well, unneeded.

    I am not angry in the slightest. Just astounded by the lack of knowledge over what proper etiquette is for baby showers and all The different ways people try to make it acceptable to ask their friends and families for gifts. Obviously there are circumstances that allow for second showers and it can certainly be a cultural thing(something you do without question like someone mentioned previously). But to say something like if I have 5 babies I will have 5 showers And screw etiquette.. well you look like a brat. Like I've said before I don't care what you do or don't do I'm just letting you know it's usually frowned upon.. An op asked. But many of you have made it apparent you don't mind putting your friends and family out multiple times and forgetting manners altogether.

    And for the last time.. A baby shower does not celebrate your baby it celebrates YOU! YOU Are the guest of honor, YOU are opening the gifts and its your name on the invitation so stop acting like etiquette is a big meanie for not letting you "celebrate all your babies." It you want a party for your baby maybe they should at least be in attendance.
  • sschwege said:

    @rahxy I think the way you have to look at it is the purpose of the party and perhaps that will make it more clear as to the distinction between throwing a birthday party for your child and throwing your own shower or having one hosted for you.  The purpose of a birthday party is to celebrate the birth of your child, gifts while customary are not the purpose of the party.  The purpose of a baby shower is to 'shower' the MTB with gifts that will be useful once the baby is born.  Similarly the purpose of a wedding is to get married, gifts are customary but not the purpose of the celebration, this is why it is appropriate to host your own wedding.  People most likely will bring gifts, but some don't and again the reason you have a wedding is to get married, not for gifts.  The purpose of a wedding shower is to shower the new couple with gifts that will be useful once they are married.  Hence making it inappropriate to host your own wedding shower because the purpose of the shower is to give/receive gifts and it is never OK to solicit other people for gifts. 

    Some people argue every baby 'deserves' to celebrated, OK, but if that was the case wouldn't the guest of honor...the baby, in fact be in attendance?  Making hosting a 'meet the baby' party after the baby comes appropriate, the purpose of the party is to meet the baby, people will probably bring gifts but that is not the intention of the party. 
     
    As I said in my post to the OP in some circles they have showers for STM+ moms if that is the case then I guess that's one thing.  However, if you have to ask as OP is doing that seems to indicate that is not common in her circle and probably would be frowned upon. 

    Exactly. It's amazing how much this has to be broken down for people and how they literally can not grasp the concept of what a baby shower is. Hint: it's not to celebrate the baby.
    Amazingly I miss some of the old "meanies" who would have shut this conversation down a while ago.
  • BANGING MY HEAD AGIANST THE WALL....

    ::SIGH::
  • To each her own. Follow original etiquette and rules or whatever, go rogue and make up new ones. Do what feels right to you. If you believe baby showers should be about welcoming mothers into motherhood than have one. If you feel it's more about the new baby on the way have as many as you see fit. Don't let anyone else push you one way or another but don't judge others opinions based on your own. There is no way to ever please everyone so who cares anymore?
  • MamamadsMamamads member
    edited February 2015
    grlplz said:

    To each her own. Follow original etiquette and rules or whatever, go rogue and make up new ones. Do what feels right to you. If you believe baby showers should be about welcoming mothers into motherhood than have one. If you feel it's more about the new baby on the way have as many as you see fit. Don't let anyone else push you one way or another but don't judge others opinions based on your own. There is no way to ever please everyone so who cares anymore?

    This is a great sentiment except one thing. Etiquette isn't an opinion nor is what a baby shower is.
    Just saying.
  • Personally my family would love to celebrate with me. Love some of the ideas here like the sprinkle shower if you are having a boy after having a girl a few years before. Sounds like the guests invited to this would be your close friends and family anyway and that group should know better than to think your just wanting gifts but wanting to celebrate instead. Beyond having a shower and a "sprinkle" for a different gender I would really not feel comfortable accepting a friends request to host.
    If I were you I would let her celebrate with you with a small party with diapers and other small items. Have fun :)
  • Not to sound rude and no disrespect but it must be an american thing to think that having multipule baby showers is bad etiquette.. or it's the first time I've ever even heard that and I have 3 kids lol I know so many ppl here in canada that have had multipule baby showers and no one ever said anything about it being bad etiquette.  and having a baby shower doesn't necessarily mean that it's to shower the mom with "gifts", I've always belived that it was a get together to show support and "LOVE" to the mom and baby, gives have always been optional..  I dunno maybe things are just different here lol

    but to answer the posters question, it honestly doesn't matter what other people think, all that matters is what you think and you want, if you want another baby shower/sprinkle  then have one, if you don't then don't, at the end of the day the ppl that matter most will be there..
    Pregnancy Ticker

    Married

    BFP: December 2006
    Due: September 10, 2007
    DS: August 28, 2007
     
    BFP: August 2012
    Due: May 8, 2013
    DS: April 23, 2013

    BFP: January 2014
    Due: October 11, 2014
    MMC Detected: May 8, 2014 (17 Weeks)

    BFP: November 2014
    Due: July 8, 2015
    For Our Rainbow Baby


  • @rahxy I agree that there is no pleasing everyone and plenty of people like to share their unsolicited opinions regarding how you should birth your child, feed your child, sleep your child and diaper your child.  I think the difference between those examples and something like shower etiquette is that etiquette affects all of us, whereas where your child sleeps does not.  I feel like I get to have an opinion if I start getting invitations for someone's 4th shower or requests to bring a book instead of a card or diapers for a diaper raffle.  Once you (general you) start asking me to open my wallet it becomes my business. 

    Some would argue if people don't like it they just don't have to show up, but it's not always that easy, due to social or family obligations it may not be so easy to just decline.  Prime example, I remember when my cousin was getting married, their wedding date and the bride's due date were about a month and a half apart.  In that time, the plan was for her to have her bridal shower, wedding and baby shower all in the span of about 50 days.  Now in our circle you give a bridal shower gift along with a wedding gift, a baby shower gift along with a 'welcome home' baby gift when you go to meet the baby.  So basically that's 4 gifts in about 2 months.  I remember when I heard there was going to be a bridal shower I called my mom to complain and said I was considering not going to the bridal shower (also the bride's second marriage (she had had a bridal shower with her first marriage as well).  My mom was like, "You should be there to support your cousin and your other cousins who are hosting it, etc" So out of guilt and a sense of family obligations I RSVP 'yes'.  They ended up canceling the bridal shower in the end anyway because I was not the only one who felt that was a little over the top, it was actually the mother of the groom who was the most vocal and said, "You are asking too much of people."  Anyway a long story to explain why it doesn't work to just say, "Those who don't like it don't have to come." because it's not always that simple.  Was I annoyed at the time?  Yes.  Do I hold it against them?  No.  It didn't change my opinion or love for them, I just think they were not being very considerate of their guests.

    Anyway, you have a nice way of explaining your side of things and I enjoyed chatting with you, but I think it's safe to say we are not going to agree on this one :) Congratulations to you as well!
  • i think proper etiquette can be argued over and over. When it comes down to it, the appropriate etiquette breaks down to what's acceptable in your own circle of family and friends.

    Like I said before, my family does welcoming parties for me. My cousin has 8 years between her first and second child. We had a full on shower for her, with the family. It's simply what we do, for all babies. If your circle wants to do something for you, isn't it rude and a slap in the face to say no you don't want it? Or even go and act like an ungrateful ass to your closest circle of family and friends for doing something so thoughtful? Or maybe I'm one of those people trying to justify improper etiquette, I don't know and don't much care. I do think everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but I also encourage thinking outside the box. Not everyone's circle is the same. Personally, the OPs mom wants to Sprinkle her, I'm assuming it is not improper etiquette within their family.
  • kladd7182 said:
    i think proper etiquette can be argued over and over. When it comes down to it, the appropriate etiquette breaks down to what's acceptable in your own circle of family and friends. Like I said before, my family does welcoming parties for me. My cousin has 8 years between her first and second child. We had a full on shower for her, with the family. It's simply what we do, for all babies. If your circle wants to do something for you, isn't it rude and a slap in the face to say no you don't want it? Or even go and act like an ungrateful ass to your closest circle of family and friends for doing something so thoughtful? Or maybe I'm one of those people trying to justify improper etiquette, I don't know and don't much care. I do think everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but I also encourage thinking outside the box. Not everyone's circle is the same. Personally, the OPs mom wants to Sprinkle her, I'm assuming it is not improper etiquette within their family.
    I agree with the bolded.  I think what is giving me reason to believe it might be frowned upon in her circle is that she says she feels bad asking her friends for more.  If it was the norm for her wouldn't she just accept without question?  I don't think it's rude it decline a shower or a slap in the face to decline.  I mean a simple, "That's so thoughtful of you, but everyone was so generous the first time we are all set with all that we need!"  Then if she was so inclined she could offer an alternative, "Why don't you and I go out for lunch and do some shopping for girls' outfits together?"  Something along those lines. 

    And I wouldn't be so quick to assume that just because one person, her mother thinks it's proper etiquette with her family then it must be.  Perfect example, my mother was hosting my baby shower in a hotel in downtown Chicago.  Parking is outlandishly expansive and when I heard the proposed location I gently asked my mom to either choose a different location or make sure the hotel was willing to validate the guests' parking.  She really and truly did not see a problem asking guests to pay $25 to park on top of their already generous gifts.  To me that just seemed like it was asking too much.  She fixed the problem and the guests were validated, but even after that she didn't see the big deal.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"