Do you like that for a first and middle name? I like it, but it does remind me of a southern belle. I think it's cute, but my husband isn't the biggest fan because of that reason (we live and have always lived in Oregon). Everyone I talk to says they love it, but I'm not sure if they're just telling me that to make me happy. Tell me straight, what do you ladies think?
Re: Avery May
I like May as a middle name though, I think it's pretty.
Avery being in the top 10 for girls would make me worried that she would end up with a bunch of other people with the same name. I prefer more uncommon names for that reason.
Precious baby boy "HC" born May 2013.

BFP#1 D&C May 18th 2012 at 9 wks. EDD Dec 17 2012BFP#2 CP Sept 17th 2012 at 4.5 wks. EDD May 23 2013
BFP#3 EDD June 24th 2013 IT'S A GIRL!
BFP#4 EDD March 2 2015
I find Avery May to be a nice name. No one will have an issue pronouncing it, and honestly I assume most people will think it's a girl's name as Avery is trending girl. I've had a few people assume Emery was a boy (particularly when she was a baby) and I would never get upset about it. I just said, "oh, I know it's traditionally a male's name but she's a girl!" I also have a grandparent who doesn't call her Emery because he knew a man named Emery. He calls her Emmy and that's A-ok, too.
So all of this to say, people here will generally not like Avery on a girl. But it's up to you what to name your baby!
My Ovulation Chart
Ava and Aria are similar and better choices.
Funny with the name Avery-11 years ago when I had #5, I considered Avery for a boy (it was a dd). This baby (11 weeks) I considered Avery for a girl. Didn't use it but it was up there. I don't actually know any boy Avery's.
I grew up with a lot of kids who had popular at the time names that were used on boys and girls-Tracy, Stacy, Kelly, Shannon...it's not unheard of.
I love Clara and Cora far more than Avery for a girl, and PPs have lots of other good suggestions.
Avery is my first choice for a girl's name and has been since I had my first child over 5 years ago. In my opinion, these days Avery is more so a girls name. For your reference on the Social Security Administration web site it was #12 for girls in 2013, for boys it is #196. The reason I am not using it is because it is too popular. I know quite a few little girls named Avery and just prefer to pick a name that is not as high ranked.
Mother of 4 beautiful babies - soon to be 5!
Elsie - 07/08/2015