March 2015 Moms

Which car seat?

I have an uppababy vista that we got when our first born was about 1.
For anyone who has this stroller, which infant car seat do you recommend for it?

Thanks!
«1

Re: Which car seat?

  • I really disliked anything graco but that may be personal preference. When in the market for car seats I usually run them past my uncle who is Phillys fire chief because they really know their stuff as far as car seats go. You can go by your local fire station and ask opinions and they will also help to make sure your seat is properly installed and will install it for you for free if needed. I think that's something everyone should take advantage of
    autism photo: AUTISM autismglitter.gifBabyFruit Tickerphoto d61f26e5-4fb2-4a0b-b301-b0af2b53d4d3.jpg
  • Loading the player...
  • I just bought this stroller too and REALLY wish they were compatible with britax. I might get the chicco keyfit if I don't go with the uppa baby mesa. I heard the Mesa is really heavy though and of course costs way more
  • I really disliked anything graco but that may be personal preference. When in the market for car seats I usually run them past my uncle who is Phillys fire chief because they really know their stuff as far as car seats go. You can go by your local fire station and ask opinions and they will also help to make sure your seat is properly installed and will install it for you for free if needed. I think that's something everyone should take advantage of

    I'm actually really curious why you don't like graco? I got their pack and play and it seemed pretty nice! They have varying designs which I found there are several cute ones. Is it the name brand thing? Or a safety thing you've come across? Definitely keen to know since I was looking at them for a car seat!

    I got the key fit 30 infant car seat. Decided to go with the infant one after some research and recommendations on the board. Will move up to a regular one when baby outgrows the keyfit. (Technically, I ended up with 2 keyfits, but that's because the extra base we wanted would have run about 90$ new but we found a deal on craigslist)
  • And now I'm irrationally annoyed they don't have any all black chicco keyfits. One reason I got the vista was because of how sleek it was and the all black is my favorite.
  • I really disliked anything graco but that may be personal preference. When in the market for car seats I usually run them past my uncle who is Phillys fire chief because they really know their stuff as far as car seats go. You can go by your local fire station and ask opinions and they will also help to make sure your seat is properly installed and will install it for you for free if needed. I think that's something everyone should take advantage of

    I'm actually really curious why you don't like graco? I got their pack and play and it seemed pretty nice! They have varying designs which I found there are several cute ones. Is it the name brand thing? Or a safety thing you've come across? Definitely keen to know since I was looking at them for a car seat!

    I got the key fit 30 infant car seat. Decided to go with the infant one after some research and recommendations on the board. Will move up to a regular one when baby outgrows the keyfit. (Technically, I ended up with 2 keyfits, but that's because the extra base we wanted would have run about 90$ new but we found a deal on craigslist)
    I guess it's more a quality thing. I'm speaking strictly about car seats and mind you I haven't been in the market for baby stuff in ten years and I'm sure they have made great strides since then. I saw a really cute graco pnp at toys r us for 80 dollars!!! It was a floor model and it had the bassinet thing in it and all kinds of stuff. Had it not been pink I would have snapped it up but my h was overly concerned that if we have a boy we won't use it( as if an infant cares what color his pnp is lol). I just remember graco having a bad rep back then as far as the safety of their car seats there were many recalls but again don't let my opinion sway you because this was a decade ago. Do go to your local fire house though because for me I felt loads better knowing for sure that my seat was properly installed. My uncle says he sees improper installation a lot in his line of work and it can be the difference between life and death in an accident god forbid but we know these things happen so better safe than sorry
    autism photo: AUTISM autismglitter.gifBabyFruit Tickerphoto d61f26e5-4fb2-4a0b-b301-b0af2b53d4d3.jpg
  • I love the Uppa Baby Mesa. That's what we ended up going with. It wasn't too heavy and the reviews were great.
    BFP 7/10/14--EDD 3/17/15

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • Thanks for the feedback. Does the uppababy Mesa require an adaptor or does it just click in?
  • I really disliked anything graco but that may be personal preference. When in the market for car seats I usually run them past my uncle who is Phillys fire chief because they really know their stuff as far as car seats go. You can go by your local fire station and ask opinions and they will also help to make sure your seat is properly installed and will install it for you for free if needed. I think that's something everyone should take advantage of

    I'm actually really curious why you don't like graco? I got their pack and play and it seemed pretty nice! They have varying designs which I found there are several cute ones. Is it the name brand thing? Or a safety thing you've come across? Definitely keen to know since I was looking at them for a car seat!

    I got the key fit 30 infant car seat. Decided to go with the infant one after some research and recommendations on the board. Will move up to a regular one when baby outgrows the keyfit. (Technically, I ended up with 2 keyfits, but that's because the extra base we wanted would have run about 90$ new but we found a deal on craigslist)
    I guess it's more a quality thing. I'm speaking strictly about car seats and mind you I haven't been in the market for baby stuff in ten years and I'm sure they have made great strides since then. I saw a really cute graco pnp at toys r us for 80 dollars!!! It was a floor model and it had the bassinet thing in it and all kinds of stuff. Had it not been pink I would have snapped it up but my h was overly concerned that if we have a boy we won't use it( as if an infant cares what color his pnp is lol). I just remember graco having a bad rep back then as far as the safety of their car seats there were many recalls but again don't let my opinion sway you because this was a decade ago. Do go to your local fire house though because for me I felt loads better knowing for sure that my seat was properly installed. My uncle says he sees improper installation a lot in his line of work and it can be the difference between life and death in an accident god forbid but we know these things happen so better safe than sorry
    That's good! I thought you were referring to all graco products. Was concerned since I also have my eye on a couple other graco items and I definitely take people's opinions and knowledge to heart on here (it was a driving factor for me ending up with the keyfit).

    Firehouse is a great idea. Do you just show up and they'll show you how to install it, securely? That will be super helpful to know before we move! I'd read a lot of praise about graco car seat reviews for current models. But need to find a sight to compare the safety I know someone listed one before, but can't remember where it was listed (probably on the other car seat thread).

    @janda426‌ I love the chicco elm color (a darker green) but it was so expensive on amazon that I ended up going for the bright green (can't believe there's a difference in price for colors!). Then the next day, I found the chicco in elm color for sale on Craigslist (with base and snap stroller) for a reasonable price (150$). You may want to check last year's model colors. I doubt they have it, but you might luck out with the color more close to what you're looking for. Also, go check out the black and grey one at Buy Buy Baby, because it's actually pretty nice/sleek in person. More so than I thought it looked online (and remember you can price match to amazon there).
  • @DragonflyDreaming‌ yes you usually can just show up at the station and some firehouses even have events where you can score free safety stuff for your baby. Fire fighters have a lot of down time in between emergencies and are usually more than happy to help someone avoid being in an emergency situation
    autism photo: AUTISM autismglitter.gifBabyFruit Tickerphoto d61f26e5-4fb2-4a0b-b301-b0af2b53d4d3.jpg
  • I got the peg-perego 30/30
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPic BabyFruit Ticker
  • ruemorganruemorgan member
    edited September 2014
    I have no experience but I was looking into the chico keyfit 30 carseat/stroller combo. A friend is giving me her chico keyfit 30 (she hasnt been in an accident) so hopefully seeing it and installing it might give me more of an idea if I like it. Car seats and strollers give me anxiety!
  • @DragonflyDreaming‌ yes you usually can just show up at the station and some firehouses even have events where you can score free safety stuff for your baby. Fire fighters have a lot of down time in between emergencies and are usually more than happy to help someone avoid being in an emergency situation
    I would call first and make sure they are actually car seat safety trained. There are some around here that are but definitely not all.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker


    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I agree with @honkytonk_kid‌, go to car seat.org and search for a car seat tech in your area. Most fire stations and police stations don't know squat around here. My husbands a cop and their station is clueless except for the laws.

    @kellbell1982 I also hate graco car seats! They're just heavy and bulky IMO. I loved our safety 1st onboard air.


  • @DragonflyDreaming‌ yes you usually can just show up at the station and some firehouses even have events where you can score free safety stuff for your baby. Fire fighters have a lot of down time in between emergencies and are usually more than happy to help someone avoid being in an emergency situation

    I would call first and make sure they are actually car seat safety trained. There are some around here that are but definitely not all.

    I was going to say the same thing. My husband used to be a firefighter and none of them where trained to do anything with car seats. People would show up all the time and they would have to turn them away.
    BabyFetus Ticker
    image
  • FTM. I had been looking at the britax b-agile b-safe combo. It seemed to have good reviews. Anyone have any personal experience with Britax?
  • broads said:
    FTM. I had been looking at the britax b-agile b-safe combo. It seemed to have good reviews. Anyone have any personal experience with Britax?

    My SIL has this and I heard great things. It was second on our list.
  • I wasn't aware that all stations weren't equipped it may be a philadelphia thing but definitely call cause it's so worth it
    autism photo: AUTISM autismglitter.gifBabyFruit Tickerphoto d61f26e5-4fb2-4a0b-b301-b0af2b53d4d3.jpg
  • We got the Vista and the Mesa because you don't need any adaptor, it just clicks right in!
    miscarriage 4/16/14 . new baby due 3/14/15!!!

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • Here's a link for car seat inspection locations in the US:

    https://www.safercar.gov/cpsApp/cps/index.htm

    I know our state police recently promoted a car seat check day. They paired with a local safety organization to do it.
  • ollieinca said:

    Thanks for the feedback. Does the uppababy Mesa require an adaptor or does it just click in?

    I don't think so, because it's made to fit the Vista. I don't have an Uppa baby stroller, so I have to get an adapter. I would check with the company.
    BFP 7/10/14--EDD 3/17/15

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • DH is actually the guy who trains the car seat tech instructors in the state. Not all cops and firefighters are certified- def check the link provided.
    That being said, we had a Chicco Keyfit for the first 2 and will either get the same this time or the Graco Click Connect (bc I like the patterns/ colors better and DH is fine with Graco car seats).
  • ruemorganruemorgan member
    edited September 2014
    @052806‌ earlier my sister had mentioned shes a self-proclaimed car seat snob and she would love to work as someone to trains others on carseats. I didnt realise that was actually a job. How did your husband get into that and what qualifications did he need to meet?
  • ruemorgan said:
    @052806‌ earlier my sister had mentioned shes a self-proclaimed car seat snob and she would love to work as someone to trains others on carseats. I didnt realise that was actually a job. How did your husband get into that and what qualifications did he need to meet?

    Haha these people are certified techs, not just car seat aficionados. The classes are offered through SafeKids.org. My husband is a cop, was sent to the course, excelled- and got really into it, eventually ran the carseat checkpoint for his pd, and became an instructor after more training. 

    There's a whole community of untrained "car seat snobs" on car seats for littles, and carseats.org. Some know their stuff, many don't.   

    He is now a captain and doesn't have much time to devote to carseats anymore, but he's still an up to date instructor.
  • I got the Graco SnugRide Click Connect 35. My whole family swears by graco products and I absolutely love the the carseat that we selected.


    Me: 31 DH: 28
    BFP #1- 1/30/13  Natural MC- 2/8/13
    BFP #2- 6/24/14  EDD- 3/7/15  Born 2/14/15 Due to Pre-eclampsia

    Team Green turned Team Blue

  • I had a Graco with my son 2 years ago and I loved it!! The infant carrier clicked into the stroller and a swing which was so convenient. I will most likely get another set for this baby!
  • We will be repurchasing a Chicco Keyfit 30. We have one that DS used, but it will be expired right after the time this baby is born.

    Pregnancy Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • We are planning on getting a peg preggo, it has the highest safety rating (in canada) but it's also one of the most expensive at $300 for an infant seat. We are planning on getting the uppa baby vista 2015 model which currently had no adaptors for any car seats, hopefully that changes soon or LO will be exclusively in the bassinet which isn't as convenient. I've read about the Mesa carrier but I don't think we have them here?
    Andrea (31), married Aaron (36) September 2012
    Parents to fur babies Tiki and Gizzmo and 2yr old Georgia
    IF veterans; #1 conceived on second clomid+HCG+IUI, #2 conceived on 1st Letrozole+HCG+IUI
    EDD: Feb 5, 2018


  • I am looking at the Graco smart seat All in one.
  • I was pretty set on Graco stuff, but after speaking to a sales person at Buy Buy Baby she sold me on the Britax stuff. She mentioned that Graco has had a good number of recalls recently and that they can be difficult to work with at times. We went with the Britax B-Agile travel system and the Britax marathon convertible car seat. I may just have been gullible, but I had read good things about Britax so I may have been an easy sell. I know this doesn't really reply to the OP, but maybe to some others in regards to Graco opinions.

    BabyFetus Ticker

  • @misshosejockey‌ Great info!! Thanks! :) Do you know which Britax you're looking at post-chicco?
  • edited September 2014
    I've seen this mentioned a couple times, but no car seat is safer than another as long as long as it's installed and used correctly. All car seats must pass the same safety tests. A $40 car seat is just as safe as a $400 seat, the more expensive seat will obviously have more bells and whistles.

    Graco most recently had a recall on their crotch buckle. I think evenflo had a similar recall recently.
  • I will be using a Chicco Keyfit 30, and then moving to a Britax Marathon when we need a convertable.

    image

    imageimageimage
  • I had a Graco Snugride with DD, and I was really happy with it. We got the smaller one, rather than the Snugride 35.  We had to move her up to a convertible sooner than we would have, but I liked that the smaller one was lighter and easier to carry around when she was little.

    I don't have a Vista stroller, but I will give you advice based on friends' experiences: they are HEAVY and a PITA to lug in and out of the trunk.  My friends mostly had Snap N Go's for their infant seats rather than dealing with the hassle of the big stroller at that stage.  I also went that route, and was very happy.  A Snap N Go is not very expensive, and IMHO, well worth the cost in terms of convenience.

  • @Haps92907‌ the snap and go is the way I'm going with the infant seat, but have you heard what strollers are manageable after that stage? Or did your friend have a good pick for that? Thanks!
  • This thread is awesome. We absolutely have more research to do! One question for all the STMs- do you have just one? Or one in your hat and one in your DH? Or for the ones with the water bases do you have a base in each?

    I'm nervous about taking them in and out of cars...
  • DragonflyDreaming I haven't decided just yet which of the Britax models I'm going with however I am researching all of the G-4 series.  I particulary like the Boulevard so far, but it all depends on price range and what changes will occur when upgrading the chicken nugget to a bigger seat.  Hope that helps.
  • colleen4019 I am a FTM but hubby and I are definitely going to get 2 bases for our infant seat. One for his 4-runner and one for mine.  This way we don't have to worry about reinstalling each time.  At the events that I've done I've had multiple family members come in to get their car seat bases and seats checked so that they know that they are all properly installed. Good luck with the research.
  • @DragonflyDreaming, I think there are pros and cons to any stroller after the Snap N Go/infant seat stage.  Some people love Uppababy Vista and BOB strollers, which have a lot of features, stability, and comfort.  BOB is nice since it works as both an everyday stroller and a jogger.  These bigger, fuller feature strollers are EXPENSIVE.  I had a City Mini, which I love.  It was a lot less expensive, is comparatively light and super easy to fold and carry.  It's also relatively narrow and easy to maneuver in tight spaces, which was great when we lived in the city.  Now that we're in the suburbs, that's less critical. 

    I also bought a used Bumbleride Indie a year or so ago, and now we use that most often.  It's great for hiking and off road, also for jogging. 

    My advice is to do a lot of research on the options and try to nail down what things are most important to you - features, price, weight, off-road ability, cup holder, etc. - and go from there.

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"