Your girls names are nice, but NMS. My favorite is Elsa, but I might be a bit deterred by Frozen. I love Eli, dislike Weston, Prefer Finnegan or Finn to Finley
For girls I would choose Fiona and stay away from Elsa just because it's becoming so popular this year. For boys I love both Eli and Finley. Great choices!
I like all of your girl names. Not crazy about Eli as a stand-alone name. Nn for Elijah? Finley is a trendy girl name. I know two little Finleys. It might be okay if you called him Finn?
I don't like Weston as much as the others - I really like Eli and Finley (a coworker has a 4 yr old Finley and he is a doll). I think because of the Frozen reference people will think that's where you got Elsa but whatever, if you like it, use it.
Re: Anyone have strong feelings about these names?
Amelia: beautiful
Fiona: love
Eli: good
Weston: eh. I much prefer Wesley
Finley: love
no strong feelings about any of them
Boys:
I like all of your girl names. Not crazy about Eli as a stand-alone name. Nn for Elijah? Finley is a trendy girl name. I know two little Finleys. It might be okay if you called him Finn?
I like Eli, Finley is okay, hate Weston