Babies on the Brain

MIL

My husband and I are excited about our baby due in early December.  I'm the youngest of four children, and the first to give my parents a grandchild.  My husband is an only child, with over-emotional, over-obsessed parents.  Obviously I have a problem with the attention they give us.  We are, for the most part, pretty private, chilled out, practical people.   I dreaded the phone call telling them that we are expecting.  I also dread talking to her...  'how are you feeling'  or 'are you tired?'  or 'oh you heard the heartbeat!!!!!!'   and 'when is your next doctor's apt?'    I do fully acknowledge he is an only child and our families are different, I just have no interest sharing the specifics about everything and acting fake-excited with her.  I don't know how to communicate without seeming distant or rude.   Anybody else have issues with in-laws?  Any advice on how to keep a good distance without seeming rude or disinterested? 
«1

Re: MIL

  • maybe write emails before she can ask you the questions.
     
     
     

    Lilypie Maternity tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers

  • Loading the player...
  • ^^^^ this. If you think you will be inundated with phone calls and questions.....just send emails or make the calls first...... :-)

  • This content has been removed.
  • Don't worry about the haters.  Yes, it is nice to have people that care, but some people don't have any idea how invasive they really are.  I'm not pregnant yet, but I also worry about how my MIL will react.  I truly have no clue if she will be overly exuberant or completely uninterested.  Either way, you will have to do whatever is best for YOUR family-- you, you husband and most importantly, your new baby.  I think the best way to do that is to be direct while still being kind.  I have had some extremely uncomfortable conversations with my MIL regarding her involvement (or lack there of-- depending on the week), but in the end, saying what I needed to say and addressing my concerns has improved the situation.  It still isn't perfect, but I am dreading our "We're pregnant" conversation far less these days than in the past.  Also, having a plan for how you and your husband will handle this change is a plus.  I think you should make sure you are both on the same page and maybe even mention your preferences to your in-laws when you share your good news.  Good luck and let us know how it goes or if you have any other insight for the rest of us!
    -Heather
  • also if not wanting to write emails. maybe start a blog and share with all family/friends. or maybe vlogs on youtube to share with family/friends. answer the same type of questions each week - symptoms, baby bump picture/viewing, cravings, etc. this is also a great way to document your pregnancy to keep for your LO. you can share with your MIL, that you know they are excited, but instead of answering the same type of questions with everyone, that you'll do this. if they continue to ask questions that you know you blogged/vlogged about, advise that they read/watch that. if they still have questions, make sure to pleasantly answer them.

     
     
     

    Lilypie Maternity tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers

  • This content has been removed.
  • mm529mm529 member
    My ILs can be very intrusive and disrespectful of normal boundaries. I found DWIL nation on babycenter very helpful. Those women have zero tolerance for bullshit and give great advice/perspective on IL situations. 
    image
    Together since Nov 2006. Married since May 2011. 
    TTC #1 Fall 2014 :)
  • Well said, DaisyZH!  I suppose I am a bit more sensitive than most on this topic after my my MIL was far too involved (in my opinion) in her oldest son's marriage/family and now he is divorced.  Of course there are always lots of reasons things like that happen, but family and boundaries was a big one there.  You make a lot of good points, and provided some great thinking points and suggestions. :)
  • This content has been removed.
  • The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • Wow I have only been on The Bump for one day.  There are so many girls who have been so great and supportive and who are here to give and receive encouragement.  Unfortunately, there are some girls who only have judgement and negativity to offer!  Geez!   I tell my middle school students that they don't always have to like what others say, but they do have to be kind and respectful.  Maybe some people need a reminder that the ladies here are not interested in "Mean Girls -The Mommy Version!"  For those of you who do understand what it is like to have a MIL who doesn't respect boundaries, it is nice to hear how you cope.  For those of you who have come to offer advice, thank you!!  Maybe those who don't have anything to offer but negativity, could just move on instead of trying to bring other people down.  Maybe some people joined this board to get an early start on practicing their MIL skills! ;)
  • MrsMuq said:

    also if not wanting to write emails. maybe start a blog and share with all family/friends. or maybe vlogs on youtube to share with family/friends. answer the same type of questions each week - symptoms, baby bump picture/viewing, cravings, etc. this is also a great way to document your pregnancy to keep for your LO. you can share with your MIL, that you know they are excited, but instead of answering the same type of questions with everyone, that you'll do this. if they continue to ask questions that you know you blogged/vlogged about, advise that they read/watch that. if they still have questions, make sure to pleasantly answer them.

    WTF is wrong with you. Do you not understand how to answer simple questions face-to-face or over the phone? IO mean it's really so invasive and hard to have a convo like this:

    MIL: OP, how was your appt?
    OP: Good. Baby is healthy.
    MIL: When is your next appt?
    OP: July 8th.

    (Repeat as necessary.... yes, so terribly invasive. So invasive that I will act like a twatwaffle and tell my MIL I answered that question already, but if she really wants to know, she can read my blog....) FFS.

    this is not my style. i was trying to give some ideas to this mom-to-be on how she could share information with others.
     
     
     

    Lilypie Maternity tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers

  • it doesn't have to be rude to MIL..

    MIL: how was your appointment today, you had one right?

    Mom: yes, i did, we listened to the heartbeat, it sounds great. i go again in four weeks for another visit where we may have an ultrasound. i'll be sure to show you the picture after the appointment. i also will be updating my youtube/blog with information. have you read that yet? i have been putting up pictures of the baby bump changing. i will share additional information with you too, but lots of people are asking questios and are so excited for this baby, and we couldn't be more thrilled.

    MIL: oh really? i remember you said something about a blog/youtube a few weeks ago. i'll check it out.

     
     
     

    Lilypie Maternity tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers

  • if she does. i don't have issues sharing information with family/friends. i don't have a blog or youtube - but i have read/watched many. OP never shared what her back history may be with her MIL. there may be more to all of this than she shared.
     
     
     

    Lilypie Maternity tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers

  • MrsMuq said:
    Wow I have only been on The Bump for one day.  There are so many girls who have been so great and supportive and who are here to give and receive encouragement.  Unfortunately, there are some girls who only have judgement and negativity to offer!  Geez!   I tell my middle school students that they don't always have to like what others say, but they do have to be kind and respectful.  Maybe some people need a reminder that the ladies here are not interested in "Mean Girls -The Mommy Version!"  For those of you who do understand what it is like to have a MIL who doesn't respect boundaries, it is nice to hear how you cope.  For those of you who have come to offer advice, thank you!!  Maybe those who don't have anything to offer but negativity, could just move on instead of trying to bring other people down.  Maybe some people joined this board to get an early start on practicing their MIL skills! ;)
    QFP.

    See, the thing is, nothing that the OP described could be considered invasive or an invasion of her privacy.

    It's a pretty normal thing to ask how a pregnant woman is feeling, how her prenatal appts (in general) are going. If you and OP think those sorts of inquiries are not normal, you are in for a world of pain when you are actually pregnant/have a child.

    Strangers coming up to rub your belly, random people questioning your parenting choices - from how you deliver to whether you BF or FF to co-sleeping or not... family members insisting on being there for the delivery, people wanting to stop by all hours of the day... that's invasive. General questions about how a pregnant woman is feeling is not invasive, especially coming from her ILs.
    You are exactly right that the OP didn't specifically bring up anything that was invasive.  I was thinking more of my own MIL, but didn't mention specifics either, so that was unclear on my part.  I do think that those questions are completely normal and am hoping that they will actually help to bring my MIL and I closer together.  I definitely hate answering the same questions a hundred times, but that certainly comes with the territory-- it is just people being concerned or curious!  I will however have a hard time being polite when strangers get up in my business at the grocery store!  LOL
  • I think a lot of this is matter of degrees. If OP's MIL is calling her every hour on the hour asking how she's feeling or whatever, yes, that's invasive and weird and probably needs to be talked about with her DH and MIL. If MIL knows you have an appointment and shows up uninvited and unannounced and wants to go into the room with you, then, yes, that's invasive and rude and another conversation needs to be had and maybe you don't tell her when the appointments are and who they are with.

    If she's calling you every couple of days, that's no biggie. It's a 5 minute phone call. I get that it can be  annoying to get the same questions over and over, but I'd just go through it. If she knows you have an appointment and calls that evening after it to ask how it went, then that's, again, totally kosher. Can your H talk to them sometimes about things? Or if they start getting actually pushy about things (ex: I need to be in the room for the birth! We're visiting for 3 weeks after the baby is born and we're staying with you!) you need to know your H is going to be on your side about actual issues, not ones that are overblown.

    I have a family that's all over the map, but we're really close. I talk to my mom, dad, and grandmother at least twice a week. H's family is the occasional check-in kind, and it's also pretty fragmented. Families work differently.



    TTC #1 since 11/2012
    Me-31, H-27
    **Loss 1-Cycle 7(June 2013) at 5w6d-CP**Loss 2-Cycle 11(October 2013) at 5w4d-CP**
    **Loss 3-Cycle 14 (January-February 2014)-M/C dx 2/10, EP dx 2/24, MTX 2/25**
    Beta Hell--hCG finally down to 0 - 6/20/14
    SA normal. Genetic testing normal. Hormonal testing normal.
    HSG 6/30/14 - found blocked left tube and 2 'bubbles' on uterine wall.
    Hysteroscopy/Lap--8/4/14 - Tubes unblocked. Polyps removed from uterine wall. Septum removed.
     9/30/14--Off the bench! Unmedicated TI through December 2014
    BFP 12/14/14!!! Beta #1, 12/16: 990 Beta #2, 12/18: Over 2000! Beta #3, 12/22: over 8000!
     U/S #1, 12/23: gestational sac, possible heartbeat
    U/S #2, 12/30: HEARTBEAT! 128bpm, measuring right on at 7w EDD: 8/19/2015
    U/S #3, 1/9: BPM in the 180s, IT'S HAPPENING!!!
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • Dude, what is wrong with you ?  It is like you are looking for a reason to be a jerk to them.  

    I know I mostly take the side of the DIL in IL situations, but you are being ridiculous and almost cruel.  
    Your poor ILs have my sympathy.
  • This content has been removed.
  • I also didn't appreciate the OP comparing his family to hers.

    Dear Lord, just because his family is different that doesn't make them weird or bad or wrong.  They are just different and certainly doesn't make them " over -obsessed."

    It sounds to me like the MIL is considerate, interested and thoughtful.  The OP ( based on what she posted) just comes across as immature.  I still stand by what I said.  I think she is looking for reasons to be upset with them.  


  • prinsesslolliprinsesslolli member
    edited June 2014
    So by "haters", you mean anyone that disagrees with you? Gotcha.
    I can see why you use the word "prinsess" in your SN. Very fitting.

    Actually by "haters" I mean people who come here to criticize and judge instead of offer advice.  You actually seem to be the one getting nasty with anyone who offers an opinion different than yours without knowing all of the facts.  That says a lot more about you than it does about me.  You said yourself we only get a glimpse of people's lives based on what the write, yet you use extremely abrasive words here and assume to know about people's lives.  And in case you'd like to know, Princess Lolly is a Candyland character. If you'd like to know about me though, I live on a farm, run half marathons, backpack, camp, kayak, fish, bike, garden, work out and carry a 380.  Maybe you could
    ask instead of making assumptions next time... because we all know what assumptions make.  
  • OP Bottom Line: Without you MIL your husband would not exist, He would not be the man of your dreams or the father of your child. She obviously did something right. That role deserves respect no matter what you think of her; whether is it intrusive, invasive whatever. You owe her the common decency to include her in the growth her grandchild, and your well being. Share with her the same information you would tell your mother, even if it is not in as much detail. My husband would be horrified if I treated his mother that way (as he should be). Nor would I. I am blessed with an amazing mother in law,but I also have a deep respect for her as my husbands mother. 


    For the record, I know there are mothers out there who have their problems, and maybe were terrible mothers, I am not referring to those here. The MIL is assumed to be a "normal parent child dyad" 
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • My husband and I are excited about our baby due in early December.  I'm the youngest of four children, and the first to give my parents a grandchild.  My husband is an only child, with over-emotional, over-obsessed parents.  Obviously I have a problem with the attention they give us.  We are, for the most part, pretty private, chilled out, practical people.   I dreaded the phone call telling them that we are expecting.  I also dread talking to her...  'how are you feeling'  or 'are you tired?'  or 'oh you heard the heartbeat!!!!!!'   and 'when is your next doctor's apt?'    I do fully acknowledge he is an only child and our families are different, I just have no interest sharing the specifics about everything and acting fake-excited with her.  I don't know how to communicate without seeming distant or rude.   Anybody else have issues with in-laws?  Any advice on how to keep a good distance without seeming rude or disinterested? 
    If you're excited, why do you have to act fake excited with her? It sounds like you don't like your MIL and don't want to share the excitement that you're feeling. Normally I think some of the ladies here are too snarky but this time they're absolutely right. You need to stop being rude and just enjoy the pregnancy with her being that it is her first grandchild and she probably just wants to love and spoil it.
  •  Wow -- logging in for the first time after I posted this and reading all these heated responses.  Some things I've learned already:

    1.  I hate all these acronyms -- OP, DIL, DH, TTC,  WTF!!
    2.  I should be more specific about examples, because yes, the questions I wrote do appear normal.  I left out a LOT more shit that IS inappropriate, and it left a lot of you calling me a 'brat' and a 'whiner'.   I'd love to learn something you are struggling with and call you names.   
    3.  To those of you who understood I was looking on advice on how to cope a little better with some problems I'm having  (yes, I acknowledge it is MY problem) - thank you for 'getting me' and offering some advice.  Let's all remember this board is to be relate-able and offer support.  Why turn it into a bitch session?  I read a LOT of posts that I consider to be ridiculous, and if anything, I get a chuckle out of it.  I don't have the aggressive need to bash.  

      
  • Darling, you're on a message board - acronyms are common and it doesn't matter if you don't like them.  Yes, you should have been more specific.  You expect us to know things you didn't talk about?  How does that work?  We did NOT learn what you were struggling with - we learned what you told us - and the judgments were appropriate.  This board is not meant for anything other than entertainment.  Support comes when it's warranted but support for being irrational never comes.  YOU are the one who came on here to bitch and you're judging other people for turning this into a bitch session? 
    Formerly known as elmoali :)

    image
  • This content has been removed.
  • Wow I have only been on The Bump for one day.  There are so many girls who have been so great and supportive and who are here to give and receive encouragement.  Unfortunately, there are some girls who only have judgement and negativity to offer!  Geez!   I tell my middle school students that they don't always have to like what others say, but they do have to be kind and respectful.  Maybe some people need a reminder that the ladies here are not interested in "Mean Girls -The Mommy Version!"  For those of you who do understand what it is like to have a MIL who doesn't respect boundaries, it is nice to hear how you cope.  For those of you who have come to offer advice, thank you!!  Maybe those who don't have anything to offer but negativity, could just move on instead of trying to bring other people down.  Maybe some people joined this board to get an early start on practicing their MIL skills! ;)

    I would bet money that not one person out of the many, many people on here joined TB to get an early start on practicing their MIL skills.

    A lot of money.

  • I"m the youngest of 4 also but if you weren't having the first grandchild in your family you might think of it a little differently. I had my parents' 5th and 6th (twins) grandchildren so to them it was just more grandchildern. They haven't visited much or don't ask much about how the kids are doing, etc and they get super excited and are so involved with my sister's kids, who had their first grandchildren. It hurts really bad to not have them be as excited or ask questions so I'm so thankful that my inlaws have given me that with asking questions and wanting to visit and be involved. My advice is to not take for granted your inlaws and try to appreciate how much they care. I never thought that my inlaws would be the grandparents that would be the more helpful ones with support, buying diapers/clothes, etc. You may realize how important they are when your baby is here.

  • Eh, my MIL drives me crazy too.  My husband is an only child and his father has passed away, so the attention we get from her can be overwhelming sometimes.  

    HOWEVER, love is love and we are lucky to have it.  Also, it helps we live 2+ hours away.  I'm not going to bash you for your feelings, but I do think this is something you are going to have to just get over.  There are fleeting moments that make me roll my eyes when she's around, but ultimately this woman, my MIL is a very important person to me and I am glad to have her in my life.  I'm sure you feel the same way about yours, but you must understand how your OP came across to everyone else.
  • ks3pinkks3pink member
    edited June 2014
    Wow I must be a really nice DIL! My MIL went to at least 2 of my appts with me when DH nor my mom were available and she attended our a/s. She even came into the room to speak to me before my c/s where I was naked under a gown and had an epidural and all sorts of other medical devices hooked up to me. I was greatful that she cared. Hmmmm.....
    Photobucket Baby Birthday Ticker TickerBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • 4N6s4N6s member
    I'm not pregnant yet, but I feel like I'll be going through the same thing!
    Good luck, girl. I have no advice... haha
  • I certainly have an overbearing MIL. When DN was born, MIL followed SIL around non stop, everyday. She still goes to see the baby every day at the same time and it's been almost 9 months. THAT is overbearing. Asking how you are doing is not. There comes a point when dealing with such a family member that you just accept it and learn how to work around it. We are house hunting and MIL texts me almost everyday asking if we found a place yet. So what do I do? Either ignore her because I am too busy to chat, or just say "no." OP this may be what you have to do if she truly is "overbearing." Just give short one word answers. If she asks how the baby is doing, even though she just asked you yesterday, then just say fine and move on. There is nothing you will do to change it so you need to learn to just go with it.
  • Just explain that you don't want to tell every detail about your pregnancy.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"