This has happened to us, albeit in different circumstances. We still have the dog.
In our case, my kid chased him under a table, cornered the dog, and made him feel threatened. We took that into account when making the decision whether or not to re-home. He's a 12 pound shih tzu and IMO isn't a threat unless backed into a corner and scared.
If I was genuinely concerned about my children's safety, the pet would go.
We had the exact same situation (12 lb shit tzu, cornered under table by son and his thumb got bit.) What was a deciding factor for me was that she only did it because she felt threatened and it was one nip and she was done. I didn't have to pull her off him. If she had been bigger or definitely if she had fully attacked him and had to be pulled off she would have been gone. After that they stayed away from each other for the most part and we were more vigilant.
___
Not what happened in this case. Not even remotely comparable.
I didn't know all the info at that time I posted because the original post wasn't 100 percent clear to me on all the details (although I do admit it seemed more like an attack than just a simple bite). Just trying to say if it had been a similar situation to mine, it wouldn't be an automatic get rid of the dog in my opinion. But if feel like your child might not be safe if they aren't kept apart 100 percent of the time, yes the dog cannot remain in the home.
OP, I'm so sorry this is happening. Can I talk to you a bit about euthanasia vs rehoming? I've been in rescue. I've done both.
Euthanasia... It's not "killing the dog". It's not "unfair". I've never had a dog be anxious or upset or dread it. They don't know what is happening and they just relax more and more and more and then they pass. They're not going to have a "mom is killing me!" moment. They aren't angry or sad or scared. They're just gone. They're free from any mental or physical issues they suffered in life. They're free. I TRULY believe that it's a wonderful gift. I've seen a LOT of euthasias. DS saw one (not really my choice but shit happens). They're peaceful and the animal is gone.
Now, rehoming. Over the years I've helped many animals find new homes. It is ALWAYS stressful. Health declines and stress increases and bad behavior increases for a month or two. In your dog's case, a bite would be very likely. They do miss you forever. Rehoming can be great and I love finding forever homes, but good homes are seriously limited. For every dog I place a dog in a shelter dies, so I try to be sure the dog I place is more worthy of a fresh start than that unknown shelter dog.
You'd be liable for that dog for forever. He bit and he lunged. Even if both were provoked, you knew he was dangerous (that's why you are getting rid of him) and you risked people by placing him in a new home.
I've lost track of a few dogs I've rehomed over the years. It's not a good feeling to know that a dog I care about is somewhere unknown. I have more than once wished that the dogs I loved had a nice death with me rather than face the unknown.
Think of who your priority is here. Your baby deserves to be safe. Priority number one. Other people do as well. Priority number two. The dog should be treated well and not frightened or neglected or upset. Priority three. Your heart should be considered. Priority four.
Euthanasia accomplishes all of those. Yes, your heart will break... But it would with rehoming anyway. This way you know you did what is best for the dog... Not best for YOUR feelings.
There are no fantasy homes out there. There aren't farm dwelling, far walking dog trainers who will never have or never see kids who have time and space and desire to adopt all the troubled dogs like yours. Don't send him off to a fantasy. Know you did right by him even though it tore you in two and euthanize.
Lurker, but have worked as a manager for a major city's SPCA, so thought I would explain what is likely to happen at a shelter-
Before any evaluation can be done, you will have to sign over your rights to the dog. This means that you will not get the dog back of he doesn't pass, nor are they obligated to tell you if he doesn't pass. The SPCA is a "no kill for space" shelter, which means that they won't euthanize an animal to make room for new ones, but they will euthanize for behavior problems, illnesses, ect. Anything that would make a dog "unadoptable". A dog with a bite history like this (unprovoked attack on a child), will be euthanized. Oftentimes, the dog must wait anywhere from several hours to several days until a behavior eval can be done, in which case they are in the holding area, surrounded by barking dogs and people they don't know. The shelter will not tell you what happens to the dog after they are signed over, so you may never know the outcome. (This may be different for a small, privately owned shelter, but not for the major ones)
The behavior evals are designed to determine if a dog will react to a number of stressful situations, including children (obv no actual children are used in the tests), food/resource guarding, general provocation, etc. It does not sound like your dog would pass.
I am so, so sorry that you are in this situation, it is heart breaking and it seems like none of the options are good ones, but for the sake of your dog, let your final act of love for him be to be there for him in his final moments, instead of him being surrounded by strangers and barking dogs. You are a good dog mom and want to do what's right for him, and what's right for him is to put aside your heartbreak and be with him in the end. I'm so sorry.
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Every day is easier. The guilt is the hardest. I still can't look at photos of my pup and I still have phantom feelings, like I can feel him right now under my feet. I can hear his collar sometimes and our home still feels just a little emptier. It's pretty much been the only thing I can think about but I am starting to accept what was right for our family. I mistakenly opted out to get his body back but I am working with the lab to get it back (they are not open until Monday). I plan to get him cremated and when we move into our forever home, I want to plant a tree in our yard with his ashes in the soil.
I am so very sorry this happened. My heart breaks for you. Knowing it was the best decision really doesn't make it easier. I hope that in time your heart will heal and you'll be able to think about your pup without the pain. I think your plan to plant a tree in the future is a really great idea.
Please keep reminding yourself that you did what was best for your whole family, including him. You chose the path that was hard for you but kindest to him. He will not be afraid or stressed or upset in a shelter or new home. He knew nothing but your love.
I'm so sorry you had to make that decision. Huge hugs. Personally I appreciated all the stories that were shared. It shed a lot of light onto the importance of training and having dogs around kids. Some just aren't compatible and I'm very sorry it didn't work out for you.
Harry Styles = Life Ruiner
There’s a lightningin your eyes I can't deny Then there’s me inside a sinkingboat running out of time Without you I'll never make it out alive But I know, yes, I know we’ll be alright
I am so sorry It will get a little easier with time. After we put my cat down, I would cry every night I came home from work because she used to greet me at the door when I came home. It was a reminder that she was gone. You made the most humane decision for your dog. I hope you find comfort in that.
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
I read this thread a few nights ago and just read your update. I'm so sorry for the loss of your dog. The loss of a pet is extremely sad and painful, regardless of how it happens. ((Hugs))
2 years, 2 surgeries, 2 clomid fails, 2 IUIs, 1 loss, IVF #1 - 10/25/10 = BFP!, DS is now 3.5yrs!
TTC #2 - 6/12 surgery #3, FET #1 & 1.2 = BFN, 12/2012 FET #2 = BFP! DD is 1.5 yrs!
Surprise! 12/16/14 BFP, loss #2 12/31/14
I can't wait for the "im getting a divorce" post in 5 years or so because your husbands were fed up with your disgusting chair asses from playing on the knot all day and getting fired 4-5 times for not doing any work. you guys are all winners!! ~ Laur929
Re: my dog bit my baby.
I didn't know all the info at that time I posted because the original post wasn't 100 percent clear to me on all the details (although I do admit it seemed more like an attack than just a simple bite). Just trying to say if it had been a similar situation to mine, it wouldn't be an automatic get rid of the dog in my opinion. But if feel like your child might not be safe if they aren't kept apart 100 percent of the time, yes the dog cannot remain in the home.
Euthanasia... It's not "killing the dog". It's not "unfair". I've never had a dog be anxious or upset or dread it. They don't know what is happening and they just relax more and more and more and then they pass. They're not going to have a "mom is killing me!" moment. They aren't angry or sad or scared. They're just gone. They're free from any mental or physical issues they suffered in life. They're free. I TRULY believe that it's a wonderful gift. I've seen a LOT of euthasias. DS saw one (not really my choice but shit happens). They're peaceful and the animal is gone.
Now, rehoming. Over the years I've helped many animals find new homes. It is ALWAYS stressful. Health declines and stress increases and bad behavior increases for a month or two. In your dog's case, a bite would be very likely. They do miss you forever. Rehoming can be great and I love finding forever homes, but good homes are seriously limited. For every dog I place a dog in a shelter dies, so I try to be sure the dog I place is more worthy of a fresh start than that unknown shelter dog.
You'd be liable for that dog for forever. He bit and he lunged. Even if both were provoked, you knew he was dangerous (that's why you are getting rid of him) and you risked people by placing him in a new home.
I've lost track of a few dogs I've rehomed over the years. It's not a good feeling to know that a dog I care about is somewhere unknown. I have more than once wished that the dogs I loved had a nice death with me rather than face the unknown.
Think of who your priority is here. Your baby deserves to be safe. Priority number one. Other people do as well. Priority number two. The dog should be treated well and not frightened or neglected or upset. Priority three. Your heart should be considered. Priority four.
Euthanasia accomplishes all of those. Yes, your heart will break... But it would with rehoming anyway. This way you know you did what is best for the dog... Not best for YOUR feelings.
There are no fantasy homes out there. There aren't farm dwelling, far walking dog trainers who will never have or never see kids who have time and space and desire to adopt all the troubled dogs like yours. Don't send him off to a fantasy. Know you did right by him even though it tore you in two and euthanize.
Before any evaluation can be done, you will have to sign over your rights to the dog. This means that you will not get the dog back of he doesn't pass, nor are they obligated to tell you if he doesn't pass. The SPCA is a "no kill for space" shelter, which means that they won't euthanize an animal to make room for new ones, but they will euthanize for behavior problems, illnesses, ect. Anything that would make a dog "unadoptable". A dog with a bite history like this (unprovoked attack on a child), will be euthanized. Oftentimes, the dog must wait anywhere from several hours to several days until a behavior eval can be done, in which case they are in the holding area, surrounded by barking dogs and people they don't know. The shelter will not tell you what happens to the dog after they are signed over, so you may never know the outcome. (This may be different for a small, privately owned shelter, but not for the major ones)
The behavior evals are designed to determine if a dog will react to a number of stressful situations, including children (obv no actual children are used in the tests), food/resource guarding, general provocation, etc. It does not sound like your dog would pass.
I am so, so sorry that you are in this situation, it is heart breaking and it seems like none of the options are good ones, but for the sake of your dog, let your final act of love for him be to be there for him in his final moments, instead of him being surrounded by strangers and barking dogs. You are a good dog mom and want to do what's right for him, and what's right for him is to put aside your heartbreak and be with him in the end. I'm so sorry.
Harry Styles = Life Ruiner
There’s a lightning in your eyes I can't deny
Then there’s me inside a sinking boat running out of time
Without you I'll never make it out alive
But I know, yes, I know we’ll be alright
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
J. 1.14.13 my reason for breathing
I'm so sorry for the loss of your dog. The loss of a pet is extremely sad and painful, regardless of how it happens.
((Hugs))
2 years, 2 surgeries, 2 clomid fails, 2 IUIs, 1 loss, IVF #1 - 10/25/10 = BFP!, DS is now 3.5yrs!
TTC #2 - 6/12 surgery #3, FET #1 & 1.2 = BFN, 12/2012 FET #2 = BFP! DD is 1.5 yrs!
Surprise! 12/16/14 BFP, loss #2 12/31/14
I can't wait for the "im getting a divorce" post in 5 years or so because your husbands were fed up with your disgusting chair asses from playing on the knot all day and getting fired 4-5 times for not doing any work. you guys are all winners!! ~ Laur929