Girl Name Help!!!

MollyC20 · May 2014

So I'm having the HARDEST time trying to decide on a girl name! DD1's name is Caroline, and our last name sounds like Scenario (same syllables and everything). Here are the names I have on the list, any opinions/suggestions would be great! We're not telling anyone the baby's name before the birth, but I need help!

Katherine (would call her Kate) Elizabeth -- so Kate "Scenario" -- Caroline and Kate (too close?) -- I LOOOOVE the name Kate, but not sure it goes with Caroline

Emma (no MN decided) -- Emma "Scenario" -- Caroline and Emma -- we've liked Emma, but worried now it's too boring/popular?

Charlotte (no MN) -- Charlotte "Scenario" -- Caroline and Charlotte -- not sure about the two C's names, maybe too matchy

Rowan Elizabeth -- Rowan "Scenario" -- Caroline and Rowan -- this one's the wild card -- I can totally picture a cute little girl Rowan, but don't know if it fits with Caroline?

The sibset names sounding great isn't a "must", but I don't want to say the two names and people be WHAT?!

Klavanga74 · May 2014

I like Emma or Charlotte. I've not heard of a girl Rowan before. My son has a bunch of boy Rowan's/Rowen?? In his grade.

sjb2419 · May 2014

I love Charlotte. I don't think it's too matchy with Caroline because it's the "sh" sound, not like the c in Caroline. I also really like Emma.

ladybug0088 · May 2014

I love Kate! We are expecting a Charlotte as our first and I suggested Caroline if we ever had a second and everyone says they are too similar...I kind of agree. I don't know what I'd name another girl...we decided on Charlotte 6 years ago.

femail · May 2014

I third Charlotte!

Sofia2529 · May 2014

I really like Charlotte but, for me, it's a bit too similar to Caroline. My next vote would be Emma.

heathera1979 · May 2014

Love charlotte!

jess545 · May 2014

I have an Emma and if this ones a girl Caroline is a at the top of my list

I also love Charlotte and Kate. I think those 3 all sound great with Caroline

fisk2005 · May 2014

I vote charlotte and my second would be Emma as well!

Kendrav4 · May 2014

I like Emma but agree with it being popular. I usually like boy/gender neutral names for girls but I am not fond of Rowan. I vote Charlotte

AmandaJean12 · May 2014

Kate and Charlotte are both beautiful

ariel06 · May 2014

I vote Kate. I like Charlotte, but it's so popular.

DaniW1984 · May 2014

I vote Kate or Rowan (that's a cute name regardless if sex!) I love Charlotte but not a fan of matching letter siblings.. But you have good taste!

Emerald27 · May 2014

I would vote Emma, maybe even Emma Katherine (or Emma Charlotte). IMO, popular or not, you should use a name if you love it.

Rowan is a boy name to me...not even close to neutral...so I couldn't really see a girl with that name. Also, since Caroline is feminine and sweet, if you want the names to "match", I would suggest choosing a feminine name for this baby too.

fisk2005 · May 2014

Oooh I do like Emma Katherine together it's very regal:)

ScientistLibrarian · May 2014

I think Kate and Caroline sound good together. Honestly I like ALL your names - a little girl that comes to the library is named Rowan and she's adorbs, so I'm biased there.

LindsC10 · May 2014

My favorites are Charlotte and Rowan

IrishHoney123 · May 2014

I like the sound of Caroline and Kate. My second favorite is Emma. Your choices are classic, except Rowan...not sure how I feel about that one.

JessAnnJ · May 2014

I don't like Rowan, but I like the others. For some reason Katherine and Charlotte seem too similar to Caroline so I guess my vote would be for Emma. As PP said Emma is very popular, but it doesn't seem like you have a super common last name so I think it's okay. If you are looking for other suggestions that are similar to your style there is Evelyn and Victoria. My daughter is named Cecilia after my great grandmother, but another name we were considering was Julia.