I've been avoiding posting about my niece recently since I'm clearly emotional about it but I really need some totally unbiased and outside opinions. Everyone in my life I can talk to about this is too close to the situation.
After some recent behavior of my niece's I'm genuinely concerned for her baby's life. Tonight I was talking with my MIL and she confided that she is afraid my niece will kill the baby after it was born. That's been my fear and my DH's for a few months as well. The rest of the family either ignores her behavior or thinks if we're more supportive (throwing her a gender reveal party, showers and purchasing all her baby items) it'll end up being just fine. Nobody wants to really deal with her though. MIL absolutely will not report my niece and I know if I/DH do it'll truly ruin any relationship with his sister as well as a few other people in the family. Probably for good.
But when people are afraid for a child's life how can we really sit back and do nothing? I'm just a wreck about this and the whole situation has been getting worse as her pregnancy has gone on. What would you do in this circumstance? If it's reporting it how would you even go about it along with trying to keep family relationships salvageable?
Re: Report or not *possible trigger*
I removed myself after that because I'm too emotionally involved being pregnant as well. I'm not sure what happened with that or if anyone talked to her about it since I told the family they couldn't talk to me about her anymore. At least until I had my baby.
We're also concerned that it could be an accident. She's got terrible anger issues so it wouldn't be out of her character to snap and do something awful in the heat of the moment while frustrated.
If she's over 18 you can call the report in after the baby's born.
Good luck with whatever you decide.
I'm so sorry you are going through this both as a famy member and and a pregnant lady who is trying to keep your own stressors low. Fx & T&Ps for you and your family.
I'm not sure if she's still seeing the social worker anymore. When I walked away from the situation I know her mom wasn't forcing her to keep her weekly appts anymore.
Niece just turned 17 and a few of us have talked to her about adoption. It's not something she's even willing to talk about. It's like the family thinks if we all make this as easy as possible for her this pregnancy will help turn her life around. None of them want to
force her to look at the realities of what her actions result in.
In the beginning I had hopes that knowing she was about to become a mother would help her mature but every month she gets more out of control and dangerous.
Also I'd rather live with some people being pissed off at me than live with guilt that I could have done something to save this poor baby. I know it's a sensitive subject and I know you are trying your best and it's clearly weighing heavily on you. At the risk of sounding like a complete twatwaffle if you and / or your husband don't take action out of fear of family you're being selfish.
If this baby was born and caught in a burning building and there was no one else around to get him out would you just walk away because you were afraid. I'd hope not, I'd sure as hell try and go in to get the baby out.
Same logic applies here.
If they don't seem concerned be more forward and questions about how to handle it. If they are resistant, ask for a supervisor immediately.
Sending good thoughts your way, this is a tough place to be in.
IVF/FET #1 - BFP!!
DX - PCOS 2004
FET #2 - scheduled for 11/24/15
When you come on here stating that you, your DH and your MIL all believe that she will KILL the baby - potentially even intentionally - you already have the answer to the question.
In Utah, any person with reason to believe that a child has been subjected to abuse or neglect or who observes a child being subject to conditions or circumstances which would reasonably result in abuse or neglect has the responsibility by state law to report it to CPS. Willful failure to report is a Class B misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months, a fine of $1,000, or both.
Report of Abuse - https://le.utah.gov/code/TITLE62A/htm/62A04a040300.htm
Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Reporting - https://le.utah.gov/code/TITLE62A/htm/62A04a040400.htm
Failure to report - https://le.utah.gov/code/TITLE62A/htm/62A04a041100.htm
I suggest you stop posting about how awful your niece is and how enabling your husband's family is, and start doing something about it. No one on this board is able to report the situation because none of us know the details. You claim to have first hand knowledge, under the laws of the state you live in, you are REQUIRED to report it or face legal action.
I'm not new. I just hate The Bump.
Report her. I reported my SIL for various reasons and have never regretted it. It was the kick in the rear that she needed to get her life back in order and she is now doing much better. I would never have been able to forgive myself if something had happened to her kids and I had done nothing to try to stop it. Everybody in the family knows it was me, there was some animosity for a while but I stood my ground and they all know that the right thing was done.
I would also recommend not shutting yourself out from the situation until after you have the baby. Your emotions and sensitivity to all things related to children and babies will be way more heightened after baby comes. If you are more involved now it might lessen the blow of the magnitude of the situation after you give birth.
GL!
Georgia 3/15/2012 Matilda 6/12/2014 TWINS!! Babies 3&4 EDD 11/22/2016
I seriously thought about calling CPS on my god-sister recently. She smokes a lot of pot (has a medical marijuana license and abuses it) and drinks a lot. None of that really bothered me until she and her bf split up and I found out she was putting the baby to bed in the PnP in her hotel room, and then smoking and getting drunk in that same room. To me that screamed dangerous. Her ex was also smoking a lot of pot and was apparently getting himself re-acquainted with crack as well.
I didn't call. First of all, they will try to place the baby with family (blood relatives, which I'm not). Her mother smokes as much weed and drinks like a fish in the middle of the day. The baby's other grandmother is just as bad. Neither grandfather is in the picture and neither parent has siblings. That leaves, potentially, my family. No one but me would be willing to take her right now, and I won't be given her because I'm pregnant. So that meant strangers. While I don't agree with what my god-sister was doing, at the time, the baby also wasn't suffering. There was never any one incident that showed that she was in danger, and she appears to be thriving.
There was also the chance that the mother would have turned around and reported me out of spite. Tit for tat. While the report would have been anonymous, there was little doubt at the time who of us were willing to make that call. A report to CPS will follow you forever, even if nothing comes from it and you show all clear. It remains on your record. That scared the shit out of me. In my case, there was also the chance of other types of retaliation if the father had found out I reported it. He does not have the best circle of friends.
It came down to her family or my family, and I chose my family. As in, me, DH, C, and Charlie. It sucks. I still wish I had said something, that I had done something official. None of us can tell you what's right in your situation. Honestly, whether you choose to report or not, you will always wonder how things went if you chose the other option. Right now, I have zero contact with that family. My god-sister and her ex got back together and are living together again. I cannot risk my children being around that environment, so we simply don't interact with them. I miss her terribly, but she's also not the person that I grew up loving anymore. It's an incredibly hard, personal choice and I don't envy that you have to make it. I shared my story in the hopes that it will make you really evaluate yours. Maybe your niece is in a worse situation and it does warrant that call (it sounds like it). Maybe it's not as bad as your ILs are making it sound. Either way, you have to do what's right for your family. I chose my immediate family over my extended family and I try not to look back because that does no good. If things had been different; different timing, different issues, I might have called.
Now I'm rambling, so I'll stop. But think about it. Talk over all the possible outcomes of both options with your DH. Make a choice that works for you.
Married DH 7/30/11
CSC arrived 5/7/12
CHC arrived 6/2/14
This. The bolded especially. We can't do anything about it and if that baby is in real, true, imminent danger, not just gossiped assumptions, you need to do something. Regardless of the fall out with the family-regardless if it will leave your DH on the outs with them. I know it's not a good place to be and to force your H into said situation, but it'd be an even worse place to be if something actually happened and you both had to live with yourself knowing that you saw it coming and said nothing about it.
I'm not asking anyone on here to do anything. Just getting unbiased opinions and making sure I'm not overreacting since I for sure am emotionally involved and this is a really serious thing to do.
DH and I have tried doing things to get her help, with the pregnancy and the problems before, but as her aunt and her mom not on board my hands have been pretty tied. We haven't been passive watchers but when she's not my child and her mom doesn't want to push certain issues I can't force anything. Her still being pregnant and a minor is also confusing to me as to what options there are until she has the baby.
I do want to say, if I saw her hurt her child it wouldn't even be a question to report it, family ties or not. After talking it out more on here my question should've originally been do/can I report her on concerns while she's still pregnant and get some help for her? Or will they ignore it until I've actually seen her do something? I really just want to get her help anyway I can. Personally, I think that's how our family should be showing her our love and support of her. They don't agree though which is why I was wondering if I could do it anonymously.
I hope none of this comes across as defensive. I really do appreciate all the responses.
Please keep us posted if you wish. Also, you can PM too if you have questions (I'm still hospitalized and on modified bed rest so I've got some free time as of now!).