I know it screams Hunger Games. She was so awesome though! Could use Kat as a NN. Thoughts? I know you ladies will give it to me straight. Use it, or keep it a GP name?
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
I side eye twilight names sometimes but never make the connection effect my decision because at least they are real names. Katniss is just WAYYY to much.
I havent read the books and saw one of the movies. Id say no. Katniss screams hunger games. Its not like Bella(Isabella), Hermione, and Ginny(Ginerva) that had popularity and history before Harry Potter and Twilight
One of the reasons I didn't love the character was from page one I thought the name was ridiculous. And tho I kept reading it over and over again it never got better for me. Which usually names do, or I can at least begin to see past them. The fact that I never did is evidence of how bad I think the name is
I know it screams Hunger Games. She was so awesome though! Could use Kat as a NN. Thoughts? I know you ladies will give it to me straight. Use it, or keep it a GP name?
First thing I thought of was catnip. I never saw Hunger Games so I don't know of that connection
And this is where I tag JollyWife and laugh. Too bad I can't remember her whole screen name.
Why? Long story short, I made a comment on a thread not long ago that no one on this board would condone the use of Katniss. She commented something about eye rolling or side eyeing my comment. I asked her why and she never answered me. This thread proves my previous point and I'm laughing.
When I see Katniss all I hear is catnip/cat hiss. I don't see the appeal of the name at all. It is odd sounding - which is why it was fitting for the book set far in the future.
GP for sure and I have to say I think she sucked.....she just did what everyone told her to do or wanted her to do the entire series.....she never thought for herself!!
Not to get all English teacher-y, but that was kind of the point. It's a major theme of the series. The concept of being "just a piece in their games" is carried throughout the books. She's a child who is being used by everyone: the Capitol, the rebels, etc. There are moments where she breaks through that in each book: the berries, Coin, etc.
And, not to get all bitchy, but all of the PPs who answered referring to the movies, y'all realize Katniss is a LITERARY character, right?
GP for sure and I have to say I think she sucked.....she just did what everyone told her to do or wanted her to do the entire series.....she never thought for herself!!
Not to get all English teacher-y, but that was kind of the point. It's a major theme of the series. The concept of being "just a piece in their games" is carried throughout the books. She's a child who is being used by everyone: the Capitol, the rebels, etc. There are moments where she breaks through that in each book: the berries, Coin, etc.
And, not to get all bitchy, but all of the PPs who answered referring to the movies, y'all realize Katniss is a LITERARY character, right?
Literary? We're using the word literary to describe The Hunger Games now?
Perhaps mine is an unpopular opinion... :-)
I'll sit with you on the UO bench. I've never read the books, so I can't comment on their quality; Should I ETA: to delete the word LITERARY and replace it with the plain ol' word book? I'll explain my edit as being too generous.
Ok, I really don't like the name, but katniss is a real thing. It's a plant. So just like we use Magnolia, Juniper, Ivy, etc., Katniss would fall in that same category to me. If there was no Hunger Games reference, I might be able to get on board with it, but as it is, it's too much for me.
Just wanted to clarify for everyone saying it's made up.
I was thinking that too. It's a total plant name, which I usually like. So I will say I like the idea of the name, but I don't like the strong tie to the series. (FTR I only made it thru the first book. I hated it.)
OP-- it's probably hormones. There was a patch of time during my pregnancy that I was convinced I should name DD Topanga.
BFP 1- EDD 2/09/11 Missed MC DX @11 weeks D&C- 7/25/10 BFP 2- EDD 12/22/11 Natural MC @ 5w 2d BFP 3- EDD 1/25/12 DD Josephine born 1/16/12
"twi-hard"? That's a good one. While we're on Hunger Games names, if the baby was to be a boy we were leaning toward Seneca which is a long time fave of mine that now gets associated with the book/movie. How much does currently trendy pop culture get to sway one's opinion? There's got to be some sort of tipping point formula on that. I don't follow US TV or movies so I am unaware of many name associations within pop culture, yet want to be aware if I'm choosing something that has taken on a separate life of it's own. For example, there was someone here inquiring about Elmo which has one extra strong association above all else. Katniss does, too.
I'm not overly fond of Katniss, but I'm not going to hate on it either. If that is the particular character or book of literature that inspired you... go for it. It's better to have a name after something you like than some textbook tradition. I have gamer friends who have specifically named their children after characters. It's really your flavor, but be prepared for everyone to do the 'seriously?' face at you when you say your daughter's name is Katniss. Especially if she looks nothing like Jennifer Lawrence.
I'm looking at your baby badge and am in a state of paralyzing admiration. Where did the decision to use Atlas come from?
It's one of the few names I've always wanted (Duncan was our runner up). I'm pooling from Greek mythology mainly although Atlas was actually not that miraculous of a Titan. Some refer to 'Atlas Shrugged'. So then, I point them to the video game Bioshock. Just because it's fun. I already know what I'm going to be dealing with for my son. And I haven't had anyone besides my aunt mock it at all.
"twi-hard"? That's a good one. While we're on Hunger Games names, if the baby was to be a boy we were leaning toward Seneca which is a long time fave of mine that now gets associated with the book/movie. How much does currently trendy pop culture get to sway one's opinion? There's got to be some sort of tipping point formula on that. I don't follow US TV or movies so I am unaware of many name associations within pop culture, yet want to be aware if I'm choosing something that has taken on a separate life of it's own. For example, there was someone here inquiring about Elmo which has one extra strong association above all else. Katniss does, too.
I love hunger games, I got to work on the movie, I love J Law, but god no please don't. For the love of all that's holy. You couldn't find a fan bigger than me but even I think that name is coocoobananas.
Re: Katniss
Long story short, I made a comment on a thread not long ago that no one on this board would condone the use of Katniss. She commented something about eye rolling or side eyeing my comment. I asked her why and she never answered me. This thread proves my previous point and I'm laughing.
Absolutely nothing against OP.
^ Yup.
I was thinking that too. It's a total plant name, which I usually like. So I will say I like the idea of the name, but I don't like the strong tie to the series. (FTR I only made it thru the first book. I hated it.)
OP-- it's probably hormones. There was a patch of time during my pregnancy that I was convinced I should name DD Topanga.
BFP 1- EDD 2/09/11 Missed MC DX @11 weeks D&C- 7/25/10 BFP 2- EDD 12/22/11 Natural MC @ 5w 2d BFP 3- EDD 1/25/12 DD Josephine born 1/16/12
:P :P :P
How about Katrin?
#2 - EDD Nov. 15, '14
**RATE A NAME HERE!**