March 2014 Moms

Would you change doctors?

Okay ladies.  I've found myself to be in a little bit of a predicament.  Living in Key West, I have two OB options.  I chose the one that had midwives, because I am more comfortable with females (simply because up to this point, my GYN doctor has always been female.)  They told me at my first appointment that he will most likely not be delivering my baby unless there is an emergency. Only the midwives.   At any rate, some friends of mine that live down here told me that they've heard of people having bad experiences with him doing their C-section, so I should be careful.   I'm not anticipating needing a C-section, so I didn't really give that too much thought.

Well, a friend just had her baby on Monday.  She went in at 7:30 a.m. to be induced (because she wasn't dialated at all and she was already a week past her due date), and she has this same doctor that people were warning me about.  She only met him once in her whole 9 months.  Anyways, he put her on as light of a pitocin drip as possible, and she labored all day and into the night.  The nurses tried to get him to up her dosage to get things going, but he said no. I'm not sure if he was hoping she'd labor though the night and he'd get to sleep.  Anyways, about 4:30 that next morning, it was time for the baby to come, so he was called in.  She said he came in very grouchy from being woke up, was there for 10 minutes just enough for her to push the baby out, and left.  Before he left, they asked him to please make sure she didn't need to be sewn or anything. He didn't look, he just said she was fine.   About an hour later, the nurses had to call him back to the hospital because she did tear and needed a bunch of stitches.  He was rough, and even more grumpy for having to come back.  And apparently when he came back he pulled more of her placenta out even though when he left he said she was good to go.  So, all in all, she said it was a very horrible experience with him and he's not a nice doctor at all.  

What do you ladies think I should do?  I would rather have the midwife deliver, but she wasn't "on call" for this one, the doctor was. And even if I were to switch to the other doctor down here in Key West, if I have the baby on the weekend, it's anybody's ball game. It's whoever's on call.  So is it worth switching?  Is that something you STM's would switch over?  

Sorry this was such a lengthy post! 
         image
imageimage
                                 

Lilypie Angel and Memorial tickers Lilypie Angel and Memorial tickers

Re: Would you change doctors?

  • Loading the player...

  • snow527 said:
    It's hard for me to say, but I would probably switch if someone that incompetent had ANY chance of delivering my baby. Also, I'm a nurse, so I'm definitely biased, but doctors who don't listen to their nurses' and patients' opinions are usually very dangerous doctors.
    I agree. I would be very nervous/scared going into labor with someone that I felt that uncomfortable with delivering my baby.

    If you are still unsure, why not check out the other OB office? That way you can decide if you like that office better and if it would be worth switching to avoid the specific doctor.
    Kinley Diane
    Born 2/4/14
    Weighing 6 lbs 10 oz and 20 inches long

  • Are there better offices on any of the other Keys not too far? I'm not sure I would feel comfortable with him at all. 

    Me: 33 DH: 32 SA#1 low count (6mil) SA#2- now in IUI range!(30mil) Dx:MFI
    11/1- IUI#1,12/1- IUI#2, 1/2- IUI#3 all BFFN
    IVF#1. Long Lupron.ER 3/8 10R,4M,5F. ET 3/3-one 1AB, 2 frosties 5dp5dt-BFP!! Beta 3/25-794 Beta 3/27- 1794
    First u/s 4/8 saw hb. 4/22 missed mc 8w3d. d&c 4/26
    FET #1- bcp start 6/9. ET 7/12. 2 perfect blasts.5dpt-BFP!! 
    Beta 7/24 -1,239!! Beta 7/26- 2569 Beta 7/29- 7120.  U/S 8/7 hb 118! U/S 8/14 hb 143! U/S 8/20 hb 170. Graduated!! Stick baby stick! 


  • I wouldn't want to chance having him deliver my baby. Most practices have an on-call system for deliveries, though. My practice has 6 doctors and a mid-wife. My dr. did not deliver my son but the one who did (whom I had never met) was awesome. If you are worried about getting stuck with this awful dr. (and it sounds like you are and should be!), def. switch since there's a good chance that the person you want to deliver your baby may not get to. GL and I hope it works out for you!

    Also, my best friend's sister lives in KW and she's always complaining about dr's (and shopping!) down there. She delivered her DD there but I'm not sure where.
  • Switch. You don't need this extra stress or worry.
    Officially started TTC January 2012
    Dx with PCOS November 2012
    2/2013 - First round of Femara - No O
    Took 2 months to get vaccinated from the chickenpox
    5/2013 - Second round Femara - No O
    6/2013 - Third round of Femara + HCG Trigger Shot = O!
    7/18/2013 - Found out I was pregnant
    Dx with Gestational Diabetes at 28 weeks
    Dx with Macrosomia at 33 weeks
    Taking Glyburide and Metformin to control GD
    Due date is March 29th but we are moving forward with a scheduled C-Section on March 25th

  • If I was not comfortable with my doctor, I would switch. No questions asked. You don't want to have any issues with the doctor that is delivering your baby.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Elonah [3], Bentley [1]

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I Would switch, for all the reasons you have given plus when it comes to the day and you end up with him you will be a nervous mess. I switched drs. At 37 weeks last time. My new dr was awesome my son was born at 2:21 am and she came in at around 1:30 was super patient and encouraging. I had a natural birth. After Jorge was born she took her time with checking and massaging the placenta out explaining what she was doing. Stitched me up and I didn't even realize it because she was so good. My son had mecinium in his fluid so they were working on him while this was going on so she was answering all my questions about him. Honestly everything was perfect and she was great. I can't imagine your friends experience. That is scary.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker BabyFruit Ticker
  • I would switch, he sounds awful. 

    image


    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker



    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • He does sound pretty bad! But depending on how it works where you deliver, you may not know the doc. My OB was there for delivery only because he was working L&D when I went into labor. And I love him, but he was only there for about 10 minutes - pulled the baby out, made sure we were ok and left. At my hospital docs don't generally come in unless you are high risk, and aren't in the room much unless you have complications. I would definitely switch if you feel uncomfortable, but ask about how they run deliveries because you may still end up with someone other than your doc doing it!
    Due 3.27.14 (lame because I cannot figure out how to save a fun ticker.....)
  • Id switch. That's awful. I'd suggest your friend call and make a complaint to the college. Nobody should be treated that way, especially by a professional who's sworn to do no harm.
  • There wasn't much detail provided about the other practice so maybe it is worth checking into that one. I would say alot of people don't anticipate the need for a c-section, but it can certainly happen so it would be something you should at least give a bit of thought to. I had no thoughts of needing one, did all the birth prep classes, etc, but ended up having one in the end. Where I live, the dr only comes in basically to 'catch' the baby and sew things up, so they aren't terribly involved. It is the nurses who do the majority of the work.

    I had a crappy experience at my practice a while back with a very insensitive dr...ultimately I ended up deciding to stay because I'm having a RSC this time, so essentially anyone could be behind that curtain and I wouldn't know it...as long as they can get the baby out and get me put back together...there isn't really much of an 'experience' with a CS! The other dr in the practice (that I like, and who did my first CS) got me through it, so at this point, that is enough for me.

  • I would consider switching, but if you do stick with the MW practice, take an appointment with him. I've heard horror stories and glowing success stories about the same doctor depending on the patient. Sometimes people just don't mesh well together and press each others buttons.

    I would want to meet everyone who could possibly deliver my baby at least once. I'd hate for someone I've never seen to deliver my baby.
    image
    imageimage
  • I would switch. It seems like the only reason you're planing on staying is for the supporting staff (the midwives) because you really like them, but you should foremost make sure you are comfortable with the main person calling the shots and then work from there. I would start searching for another OB, especially after hearing your friend's horrible experience. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I'm so sorry to hear that you have so few options in Key West (love the Keys by the way!).  I definitely would look into the other practice and then go from there about where you feel most comfortable.
    BabyFetus Tickerimage
  • I would switch, even if you have to drive to one of the other keys it is worth it to find a doctor you can trust.
    IAmPregnant Ticker
    BabyFetus Ticker
  • I had a horrible male ob with dd and the birth and afterbirth were horrible as well. I've mentioned this before but he was cold and insensitive. Change now if you're uncomfortable. Trust your instincts.
  • I'd say follow your gut and check out your options. It's your body and baby! I'm switching dr's from my first. It will be awkward later when I'm showing cuz I work with my old doc lol
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Any midwives in private practice down there? I had a similar situation with my first pregnancy (m/c last fall), and it was the same deal... 6 providers (poor communication between them), bounced around, very cold and uncaring, whoever was on call delivers the baby, horrible experience. I live in a small town and thought I had no other options, but after some detective work found an awesome midwife with a private practice. Good luck!
  • snow527 said:

    It's hard for me to say, but I would probably switch if someone that incompetent had ANY chance of delivering my baby. Also, I'm a nurse, so I'm definitely biased, but doctors who don't listen to their nurses' and patients' opinions are usually very dangerous doctors.

    This! You don't want Dr. Butcher doing your delivery! You should also tell them why your switching if you decide to go. Maybe instead of having a midwife you could look into getting a doula? Doulas are suppose to be pretty helpful and they are always there for you even if it is a weekend. They may not be a midwife, but they'll be there for you even if things don't go as planned.
    Married my best friend October 28th, 2005
    Found out we're expecting August 7th, 2013  
    Anniversary
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker>
  • I would switch. At my practice there are 6 OBs and I was told any one of them or their partners could deliver my baby. But the two doctors I've met I love and I completely trust that the other doctors are just as sweet and enthusiastic as them. I never got a bad vibe once from this my practice. If you have any doubts, just switch, you might be surprised.
    AnniversaryBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Switch! That frightened ME!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"