Milkshakes are a no go?

virginiamama85 · February 2013

I just mentioned to a pregnant friend that I was headed to McDonalds for a shamrock shake and she said I was a rule breaker for having a milkshake and she thought it was something about listeria... is this a "rule"? Not that it would change my plans of milkshakes in the future, but I was just curious!

Laurakat81 · February 2013

Seriously, have your milkshake! Your friend is crazy!

matthewsdm · February 2013

Um, no. Have as many milkshakes as you can possibly handle! I drank them all the time with dd and have had a couple this time too!

elplocho · February 2013

I personally never heard of this being a risk. The only thing I can imagine is that if the nozzle that dispenses the soft serve ice cream or the mixer isn't cleaned regularly that it can maybe have harmful bacteria.

But other than that I'm drawing a blank.

Also, I now have a milkshake craving. lol

adeladedyan · February 2013

Blah blah blah... Eat your milkshake and enjoy it. I ate them throughout my last pregnancy and this one to.and they were ALL delicious! Lol

girlmama83 · February 2013

I assume what your friend is referring to is the fact that the bacteria that causes listeria can indeed build in the machines that milkshakes, soft serve, frozen yogurt, etc. come out of.

If we stopped eating and doing things based on every worry out there though, pregnant women would literally be stuck in the house all day doing nothing! That being said, I've had a few strawberry milkshakes from mcdonalds so far this pregnancy and they were delicious.

V&G101808 · February 2013

Laurakat81:
Seriously, have your milkshake! Your friend is crazy!

Yes This. Enjoy your milkshake girl!

And whenever I hear the word Milkshake I think of that d@mn song, so here's a gif Stick out tongue

Sascha3 · February 2013

Your friend is over the top. Enjoy your milkshake.

Listeria is actually more common in uncooked vegetables and certain fruits. And no one tells us to avoid them.

amberyintar · February 2013

V&G101808:

Laurakat81:
Seriously, have your milkshake! Your friend is crazy!

This. Enjoy your milkshake girl!

And whenever I hear the word Milkshake I think of that d@mn song, so here's a gif

Bahaha! Your gif made my day!

virginiamama85 · February 2013

Oh, I never actually considered not having the milkshake. I am a happy coffee drinking, lunch meat enjoying mama Smile

I was last time too and my ob is totally ok with it... I was just curious as I have heard all the normal no lunch meat listeria business.... but never heard anything about milkshakes!

Cosmic+Love · February 2013

V&G101808:

Laurakat81:
Seriously, have your milkshake! Your friend is crazy!

This. Enjoy your milkshake girl!

And whenever I hear the word Milkshake I think of that d@mn song, so here's a gif

Haha! That is going to be stuck in my head for the rest of the day.

ludali · February 2013

I had jury duty yesterday (in which I was put on a messy criminal trial scheduled for mid-March)... Anyway, my reward for my civil duty was a shamrock shake, and I am not looking back! Cool

JGM281207 · February 2013

I know quite a few people who avoid them...not high on the list of worries for me!

lisamoe · February 2013

Wha??

I think your friend is just jealous because she's not getting a milkshake.

ChihuahuaLov3 · February 2013

Yum I want a shamrock shake now and I have never had one before lol are they good??

Lilmrslay · February 2013

In the Bounty Pack we get over here from our midwives, their is a food safety brochure and all soft serve products are listed as a definite no go.

I haven't thought to avoid them though, but I'm also not a big fan normally so haven't felt the need to go after them either.

I say have your milkshake and enjoy. My general rule of thumb for these less threatening foods has been if there are brands/products I've never been sick off before, then they're probably ok.

Missuskeekers · February 2013

Technically soft serve ice cream can be a risk if the machines aren't maintained properly. I wouldn't worry about McDonald's but I didn't eat any soft serve when I was in Mexico because I wasn't sure how often and meticulously the machines got cleaned.

virginiamama85 · February 2013

ChihuahuaLov3:
Yum I want a shamrock shake now and I have never had one before lol are they good??

normally I am a straight up chocolate milkshake fan, but the shamrock shake totally hit the spot. Not something I will be wanting every day, but just right in the moment Smile

AlexKate45 · February 2013

OMG I'm craving a shamrock shake now! I don't think we have them in Canada anymore...

ChihuahuaLov3 · February 2013

msspeedymarie:
ChihuahuaLov3:
Yum I want a shamrock shake now and I have never had one before lol are they good??
Honestly, they used to be better, but a couple of years ago, they changed the syrup formula and now I think they taste too fake.
I worked at McDonald's in high school, and easily 10lbs of the weight I'm carrying today was put on drinking Shamrock shakes those 3 years. They used to be amazing. Now, I'd recommend just going to Steak 'n' Shake or Sonic and getting a mint shake there.

Thanks!

I could never work at Mcdonalds. I would eat waaaayyyy to many fries!

AlexKate45 · February 2013

I love the response this thread is getting too! "WHAT DO YOU MEAN WE CAN"T HAVE MILKSHAKES!!" scream a bunch of hormonal, hungry, pregnant women! lol

virginiamama85 · February 2013

AlexKate45:
I love the response this thread is getting too! "WHAT DO YOU MEAN WE CAN"T HAVE MILKSHAKES!!" scream a bunch of hormonal, hungry, pregnant women! lol

Haha its not my fault if a riot gets started!!

anvloveskme · February 2013

I am so over the food hysteria and suggestions from people re: what we can/can't eat while pregnant!!! It seems to change all of the time. I have said it once and will say it again, at the end of the day, there are women in third world countries that have no prenatal care and live in huts with bare floors and without running water and they are still giving birth just fine. Other than no alcohol, I eat what I want!

Millie1984 · February 2013

I've heard of this, but I really think its fine. As PPs have said, have the milkshake

rfrazier611 · February 2013

McDonald's chocolate milkshakes are how I've been rewarding myself after doctor appointments/er trips.

virginiamama85 · February 2013

Thanks everyone! I am not really a worrier about all the different things they say you should or shouldn't do - I guess I just wanted to be reinforced by my statement to her that they were, most certainly, ok to have and that I was still definitely having one, which was delicious btw!

ktbear9512 · February 2013

virginiamama85:
Thanks everyone! I am not really a worrier about all the different things they say you should or shouldn't do - I guess I just wanted to be reinforced by my statement to her that they were, most certainly, ok to have and that I was still definitely having one, which was delicious btw!

Glad you had one. I've never heard of this either.

BlueJewelM · February 2013

virginiamama85:
Oh, I never actually considered not having the milkshake.nbsp; I am a happynbsp;coffee drinking, lunch meatnbsp;enjoying mama [:]nbsp; I was last time too and my ob is totally ok with it... I was just curious as I have heard all the normal no lunch meat listeria business.... but never heard anything about milkshakes!

Me too! And this summer I will eat blizzards from dq as well. Some bumpies clutch their pearls at that one too!

magdalina.h · February 2013

Oy

afrochick09 · February 2013

Can't say I've heard anything about milkshakes. Can't have them anyways so didn't look into that one.

virginiamama85 · February 2013

BlueJewelM:
virginiamama85:
Oh, I never actually considered not having the milkshake.nbsp; I am a happynbsp;coffee drinking, lunch meatnbsp;enjoying mama [:]nbsp; I was last time too and my ob is totally ok with it... I was just curious as I have heard all the normal no lunch meat listeria business.... but never heard anything about milkshakes!
Me too! And this summer I will eat blizzards from dq as well. Some bumpies clutch their pearls at that one too!

i would do a thumbs up here but my dumb computer isn't letting me, so just imagine there was one there... and YES to blizzards, yummy!

PackersFan315 · February 2013

My OB was fine with milkshakes, it's just that my DH ratted me out when telling her I had one every other night. Now she told him and me only once a week! WTH?!?? She only told me to stay away from cantelope because that food has had more cases of listeria than other foods.

woodsmm4 · February 2013

I would not be worried! My two favorite things are chocolate milk shakes and French fries. My husband asked my doctor about milkshakes and he said that I was free to have as many as I would like! Enjoy your milkshakes!

Want a personalized experience?

Milkshakes are a no go?

Re: Milkshakes are a no go?

Choose Another Board

Search Boards