I definitely want a firm mattress for DD, but she's not the biggest fan of the one we have now and I'm wondering if it's because it's rock hard. Ok, maybe not rock hard, but at least eraser hard.

I was reading about the sealy soy plush, and it sounded like it could be a good option. I was wondering if anyone had any experience with that, or had any other recs to make. TIA!
Re: Comfiest crib mattress? Sealy Soy Plush?
We have the Sealy Soybean and like it alot. It's nice and firm but not hard. It's light and easy to change the sheets on. It fits perfectly like it is supposed to in our crib.
We got ours from Amazon.
Highly recommend it!
Yep, this. Nice and firm but not like a rock.