December 2010 Moms

Marriage between first cousins

So now that Obama came out for gay marriage in the same week that NC came out against it, a lot of people on my FB are saying, "Sure, in NC you can marry your cousin but you can't marry your partner! Ridiculous"

Maybe I'm in the minority here, but am I the only one who actually thinks you should be allowed to marry a first cousin?  The risks for children born to these marriages are way overblown...I think the risk goes up by 1%...and people who have rare conditions aren't barred from having children.  Also just because you are married does not mean you are going to have children. So why not even allow cousins to get married in the first place?

I guess I'm just coming from the place that I believe any two consenting adults should be allowed to be married (I'm pro gay marriage).  To me, that includes cousins.  I think I'm in the minority on this one though, haha!

(btw, I do not have a hot male cousin I fantasize about or anything Stick out tongue)

photo IMG_6758_zps3fe7e628.jpg

Re: Marriage between first cousins

  • imagejillybean800:

    So now that Obama came out for gay marriage in the same week that NC came out against it, a lot of people on my FB are saying, "Sure, in NC you can marry your cousin but you can't marry your partner! Ridiculous"

    Maybe I'm in the minority here, but am I the only one who actually thinks you should be allowed to marry a first cousin?  The risks for children born to these marriages are way overblown...I think the risk goes up by 1%...and people who have rare conditions aren't barred from having children.  Also just because you are married does not mean you are going to have children. So why not even allow cousins to get married in the first place?

    I guess I'm just coming from the place that I believe any two consenting adults should be allowed to be married (I'm pro gay marriage).  To me, that includes cousins.  I think I'm in the minority on this one though, haha!

    (btw, I do not have a hot male cousin I fantasize about or anything Stick out tongue)

    My first thought was that ya married your first cousin, but to each their own! LOL

    Seriously, I don't care what people do...if you want to marry your 1st, 2nd, 3rd cousin or if you want to marry your gay 1st cousin or all your cousins...not my business. But, I personally would not consider hooking up with a cousin...to me, that's pretty gross. Like I said, to each their own.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers imageLilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • Loading the player...
  • Well, I have all female cousins - so I't not something I would have ever considered myself... But I agree with you.  My thoughts are that if you aren't hurting yourself or anyone else, what's the big deal???  H and I were talking about this last night because we saw a commercial for a show similar to Sister Wives.  Personally, it's not something I would ever go for, but seriously, they're all consenting adults choosing that lifestyle.  Let them live their lives!!!  

    I'm totally fine with inter-racial couples, gay couples, so why not first cousin couples?  Hey, if it makes you happy, what's the big deal  - and the bonus, you would already know what type of people your in-laws are :P

    photo 928560AF-AAA0-4036-A0DB-1781F180055B-8057-000009B95DF7BAAA_zps4aeff975.jpg Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • imagedee12807:

    Well, I have all female cousins - so I't not something I would have ever considered myself... But I agree with you.  My thoughts are that if you aren't hurting yourself or anyone else, what's the big deal???  H and I were talking about this last night because we saw a commercial for a show similar to Sister Wives.  Personally, it's not something I would ever go for, but seriously, they're all consenting adults choosing that lifestyle.  Let them live their lives!!!  

    I'm totally fine with inter-racial couples, gay couples, so why not first cousin couples?  Hey, if it makes you happy, what's the big deal  - and the bonus, you would already know what type of people your in-laws are :P

    I agree with you here too.  Although I believe that certain polygamists sects who force children into marriage should be stopped, their situation (Sister Wives) is entirely consensual, and they were all married in their 20's. I mean, hey, I think it's demeaning to women (because you can't be polygamist the other way, haha), but if they are fine with a subservient role, and they aren't being abused or forced into sex, etc. I'm cool with it.

    photo IMG_6758_zps3fe7e628.jpg
  • I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    photo 203b9128-895f-464c-a378-ff73eaf8c1ce_zps4de57ab1.jpg
    Xander, Hayden & Lily 5 1/2 and Jericho 3 My Blog!
  • imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 
  • imagejillybean800:
    imagedee12807:

    Well, I have all female cousins - so I't not something I would have ever considered myself... But I agree with you.  My thoughts are that if you aren't hurting yourself or anyone else, what's the big deal???  H and I were talking about this last night because we saw a commercial for a show similar to Sister Wives.  Personally, it's not something I would ever go for, but seriously, they're all consenting adults choosing that lifestyle.  Let them live their lives!!!  

    I'm totally fine with inter-racial couples, gay couples, so why not first cousin couples?  Hey, if it makes you happy, what's the big deal  - and the bonus, you would already know what type of people your in-laws are :P

    I agree with you here too.  Although I believe that certain polygamists sects who force children into marriage should be stopped, their situation (Sister Wives) is entirely consensual, and they were all married in their 20's. I mean, hey, I think it's demeaning to women (because you can't be polygamist the other way, haha), but if they are fine with a subservient role, and they aren't being abused or forced into sex, etc. I'm cool with it.

    You can't be a polygamist the other way around because no woman would be stupid enough to have to deal with multiple husbands! Haha.

    I think it would be a littlw creepy for first cousins to marry. I've always been pretty close to most of my cousins, so I could never see them in a romantic way. I do have a friend that dated her 2nd cousin, but they didn't meet until they were adults. It was still a little weird though.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker


    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagesofamonkey:
    imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 

    This is also my opinion! 

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers Labor Buddy to chulita425!
  • Hah, I didn't say I would encourage it!  I would probably feel weird about it too. I support transgender people, but if Alexander said he wanted to be a girl, I would have to really take some time with it and adjust to my little boy wanting to not be my little boy anymore. But that doesn't mean the government should feel a certain way about it!
    photo IMG_6758_zps3fe7e628.jpg
  • imagedesertlady86:

    imagesofamonkey:
    imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 

    This is also my opinion! 

    I am on this team. There is no way I would be ok with my son getting together with his first cousins.YUCK!!! Ick!

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • imageLuckyladyJ:
    imagedesertlady86:

    imagesofamonkey:
    imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 

    This is also my opinion! 

    I am on this team. There is no way I would be ok with my son getting together with his first cousins.YUCK!!! Ick!

    I'm on this side too. It's just too weird. Now if they were cousins that met while adults and didn't grow up together that would be different but still a little weird. I would not be okay with Lily dating or marrying any of her cousins. It seems wrong to me.


    Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic
    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • imageLuckyladyJ:
    imagedesertlady86:

    imagesofamonkey:
    imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 

    This is also my opinion! 

    I am on this team. There is no way I would be ok with my son getting together with his first cousins.YUCK!!! Ick!

    ::slides over beside these ladies:: 

    image

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers

    Married my best friend 01/01/09

    BFP#1 05/06/10. Jarebear born 12/29/10.

    BFP#2 06/22/12 (DH's birthday). EDD 02/23/13. M/C and D&C 08/09/12

    BFP#3 02/04/13. Alaina Beth born 10/09/13.
  • imagejillybean800:
    Hah, I didn't say I would encourage it!  I would probably feel weird about it too. I support transgender people, but if Alexander said he wanted to be a girl, I would have to really take some time with it and adjust to my little boy wanting to not be my little boy anymore. But that doesn't mean the government should feel a certain way about it!

    I couldn't agree more!  I like to believe that i'm not the type to say 'it's ok as long as it's not my family/kid' but there are def some things that would take a bit of getting used to.  It doesn't mean that I'm against it or for it, it just means that it's not something that I look down on. (by 'it' I guess I mean 'other' lifestyles... I hope that doesn't sound wrong, but I think you all know what I mean...)

    photo 928560AF-AAA0-4036-A0DB-1781F180055B-8057-000009B95DF7BAAA_zps4aeff975.jpg Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • imagedesertlady86:

    imagesofamonkey:
    imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 

    This is also my opinion! 

    Ditto!

     
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
     
     
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I don't like it but I think it should be legal. I agree with jilly...according to science it's not a big deal (the way it is for siblings). It might seem icky...even to me...but maybe it should just be legal.

    Baby Birthday Ticker TickerBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I'm pretty sure it's legal in NJ. I remember it being a question on our marriage license application. That being said, I am not comfortable with it for my own family, but, I file this under "to each their own".

    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • imageStrunella:
    imagedesertlady86:

    imagesofamonkey:
    imageTripMomma:
    I may be the odd one out, but there is NO way I would be OK with my kids getting together with my brother's or sister's kids. Way icky for me. I would say what other people allow their kids to do is their business...but if I am being honest I would totally side eye anyone who was with their 1st cousin. JMO.
    OK, that's not just your opinion.  Squicky icky. 

    This is also my opinion! 

    Ditto!

    Yup, no way would I be ok with it, sorry! The thought gives me the hibee jibees (if those are even words) but hey each to their own just not in my family! JMO 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • klinkyklinky member
    imageSpitsNGiggles:
    imagejillybean800:
    imagedee12807:

    Well, I have all female cousins - so I't not something I would have ever considered myself... But I agree with you.  My thoughts are that if you aren't hurting yourself or anyone else, what's the big deal???  H and I were talking about this last night because we saw a commercial for a show similar to Sister Wives.  Personally, it's not something I would ever go for, but seriously, they're all consenting adults choosing that lifestyle.  Let them live their lives!!!  

    I'm totally fine with inter-racial couples, gay couples, so why not first cousin couples?  Hey, if it makes you happy, what's the big deal  - and the bonus, you would already know what type of people your in-laws are :P

    I agree with you here too.  Although I believe that certain polygamists sects who force children into marriage should be stopped, their situation (Sister Wives) is entirely consensual, and they were all married in their 20's. I mean, hey, I think it's demeaning to women (because you can't be polygamist the other way, haha), but if they are fine with a subservient role, and they aren't being abused or forced into sex, etc. I'm cool with it.

    You can't be a polygamist the other way around because no woman would be stupid enough to have to deal with multiple husbands! Haha.

    I think it would be a littlw creepy for first cousins to marry. I've always been pretty close to most of my cousins, so I could never see them in a romantic way. I do have a friend that dated her 2nd cousin, but they didn't meet until they were adults. It was still a little weird though.

    Can you imagine how much work that would be??  No thanks, 1 husband is enough for me!

  • imagebosha711:
    I'm pretty sure it's legal in NJ. I remember it being a question on our marriage license application. That being said, I am not comfortable with it for my own family, but, I file this under "to each their own".

    Saw this on FB yesterday:

    I learned something today. You can marry your first same-sex cousin in the following states: Connecticut, Massachusetts, New York, Vermont, and Washington D.C. 

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Personally, the thought of being romantically involved in any way with a cousin really creeps me out.  

    However, I know it is fairly common in other countries and that those countries think the US is silly for thinking it is so gross.   

    I used to be a big deal.  Now I'm just old. 
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"