Once DS gave up his naps (shortly after he turned 2) we insisted on "quiet" time in the place of a nap. Generally he just goes in his room for an hour or two and plays nicely. Lately, however, this has been an impossible challenge. He is the KING of excuses to come out of his room (we used to have those door knob blockers on his door, but he figured those out pretty quickly). He comes out to go potty, to have some water, to give me some garbage he found, he takes off his shirt and then comes out to get help to put it back on, he opens his door and demands certain things get taken out of his room, etc. Lately he even just stands at the door and opens and shuts it repeatedly. Even if he is playing nicely, he's so loud, jumping around, etc. I've stuck with it for so long because I just feel like I NEED some kid free time in my day, but scolding him, telling him to keep his door shut, dealing with his excuses, etc is just so exhausting and leaves me stressed.
I don't really know what to do, because I so value my short time when the LOs are in their rooms, but it's just getting ridiculous! Any advice or tips?!
And if it is time to give up the "quiet" time, any tips on how to cope? I'll have baby #3 this summer and I'm really nervous about dealing with an infant AND having no respite from the older LOs (so I could catch a nap during the day, for ex). TIA!
Re: "Quiet time" is far from quiet! Help!
Maybe cut the quiet time down. My first thought when I was reading your post is that it is a long time. He's probably bored and lonely. Maybe 45 minutes? My DS has "down time" and it's for 20-30 minutes depending on what I'm trying to accomplish
Another thought is if you REALLY need the time, can you break it up into two chunks? Do one in the morning and more in the afternoon? Just a thought...
DS has to stay in his room and he has a timer that he can see counting down and he knows he only comes out once the timer goes off. It works great.
Maybe if your LO doesn't stay in, say the timer gets turned off every time he comes out (NOT reset, just that the time he is out doesn't count as quiet time) and explain it to him that the time is the time and every time he comes out, the timer gets stopped and once he goes back in it starts back up. He'll catch on!
Does he have a clock in his room? We got our daughter a digital clock and told her what numbers she can come out in. We also insist that when she does things to disrupt/delay her quiet time, that means we add time. It took a little time and a few punishments, but she learned quickly. We let her come out to go to the bathroom and now she goes right back in her room when she's done. Whatever she needs help with in her room, we refuse to do so until after "nap" time. We just tell her to play with something else.
Of course, it could be what a PP said, that he's bored. Does he have much experience playing by himself? Or has he grown out of his toys and needs more age-appropriate ones?
This is probably the best solution for our situation, and maybe a timer or clock would work well too.
Thanks for all the ideas!
* there are clocks that turn colors when it is time to get up. We have this one from Amazon to keep DD in her room until 7 am. I would probably start out with shorter time frames and then gradually lengthen them out until you are at the desired time.
* keep calm. Kids, like dogs, smell fear.
* start taking toys. "Oh, I see you want to keep getting out/shutting the door/being loud/etc. when you aren't supposed to. I suppose these toys in your room are too great a distraction and that makes you want to leave/shut the door/jump around/etc. So I am taking this one and will keep it during quiet time. Next time I have to come back in for anything other than a need to go potty or a real emergency, I will take another until they are all gone." You can make a big deal next nap out of taking away some of them saying "okay, I remember these were too distracting last time but I'm not going to take all this time -- we'll see if you are able to play quietly and then maybe you'll get these back for your next nap time." So you are therefore incentivizing him and turning it almost into a competition.
* ETA one more -- try to do some outside time or super rambunctious time right before quiet time: tell him now is when he has to get all his jumps and bounces and running CRAZY out before quiet time. Let him go beserk. Give him 15-30 minutes of running and being wild and THEN get him going on his ritual for quiet time (like lunch and then quiet time). If he has a designated outlet, he may be inclined to use that. You might even consider sandwiching his quiet time with the rambunctious time so he knows he has that outlet both coming and going and you can tell him to save it for the designated time.
DD -- 5YO
DS -- 3YO
It seems like everything you mentioned for why he is leaving his room is "allowed". Which is okay except that he is smart enough to use all of them all of the time. (Really loved the shirt thing - very inventive).
I think you have to decide if quiet play for one hour is worth enforcing. If it is, then enforce it with whatever strategy works well with your tot. My DD has lots of toys on her bed and likes the door open during her naps (sometimes its just quiet play). I only had to close the door once and tough- out a very mad scream-fest to enforce 'no leaving the room'. Once. And I wasn't mad about it either, I just shook my head and said what a shame it was that DD needed the door shut since she didn't stay on her bed.
I don't agree that one hour in a room of lovely toys is anything you should stop doing. Self-soothing and self-entertainment is a very good skill to foster and develop.