Hi ladies - I don't make my own posts too often around here but I do lurk and occasionally chime in on someone's post. Hope it is okay to ask a TMI question since I am not sure I'd be considered a 'regular poster' --
Anywho, what do you call consider CD1? TMI alert*** I've had dark brown blood on the toilet paper for 2 days (very light, and only sometimes) and I'm positive it is the start of AF and not implantation bleeding. Would you consider that CD1 or would you wait until you have regular red flow to consider it CD1?
Thanks for the help!!


BFP#1 8/24/11, EDD 5/5/12, D&C 10/24/11 due to missed m/c
BFP #2 2/1/12, EDD 10/11/12. Baby arrived 10/9/12
BFP #3 5/6/14, EDD 1/14/15
Re: What do you consider CD1? Likely TMI
This.
BFP #1 9/25/2011 | EDD 6/1/2012 | M/C 10/26/2011 at 8w6d
BFP #2 3/13/2012 | EDD 11/23/2012
9DPO hcg: 45; Prog: 41 | 14DPO hcg: 694 | 17DPO hcg: 2733 | 28DPO hcg: 53,006
First u/s 4/13 showed a beating heart! Second u/s 5/2 showed a HB of 163! Let's GROW, baby!
He's here! Kellen born 11/16/12 - 8 lbs 8 oz 22 inches long via scheduled c-section (breech baby, gestational diabetes mama)
First, no such thing as TMI on this board.
Sounds like you're spotting. I'd mark it as spotting and wait for the first full day that you need a tampon or pad for CD1. I'll also add that, as Rizza correctly told you, it's usually stated as the first day of red flow. Some of us don't always get bright red flow, so--if you're in that category with me--it's more about the amount than the color.
Married my love 6/11/11 | MMC 10/11/11 | Eliza Frances born 9/18/12 | Rhett Garland born 2/24/14
BFP#1 8/24/11, EDD 5/5/12, D&C 10/24/11 due to missed m/c
BFP #2 2/1/12, EDD 10/11/12. Baby arrived 10/9/12
BFP #3 5/6/14, EDD 1/14/15
Nothing, and I mean, nothing is TMI here.
I saw spotting only when sticking toilet paper way up there for the past three days. Each day I put down on Fertility Friend that it was "spotting", FF kept me on my old cycle. When I saw flow on my pad this morning, I put down "Light" in FF and it deemed me on CD1.
If you're not on FF...join! It's a big help.
BFP#2 ~ 8/2/11, EDD 4/11/12, D&C 9/12/11 at 9w5d
BFP#3 ~ 4/15/12, EDD 12/21/12 ~ DD born 12/22/12
Thanks! I am on FF I just was not sure what to put the flow down as...spotting, light, leave it blank, etc. Thanks for the tip on how to enter it in - I'll do it as spotting and let FF move me to a new cycle when I put in 'light.'
BFP#1 8/24/11, EDD 5/5/12, D&C 10/24/11 due to missed m/c
BFP #2 2/1/12, EDD 10/11/12. Baby arrived 10/9/12
BFP #3 5/6/14, EDD 1/14/15
After 7 years of no ovulation...
BFP#1 10/24/11 ~ EDD 6/29/12 ~ Natural m/c 11/2/11
BFP#2 2/3/12 ~ Alice born 9/26/12
eww...that made me lol!
Another vote for first day of red=CD1. I'll get some very slight brownish spotting for a day or 2 before AF, I don't count that.
TTC since Aug 2011. BFP #1 on 10/28/2011 EDD of 07/02/2012 Natural MC on 11/22/2012 BFP #2 on 10/28/2012 EDD of 7/13/13 Judah Ari born on 7/11/13.
I love my rainbow baby!
I had red spotting a few days ago, and then I had brown flow (really a nice dark red/brown) and counted that as CD1.
I figure, if you need a pad or tampon- it is a flow.
BFP #1- 11/7/10 ~EDD 7/20/11 ~M/C (bo) 12/6/10 @ 8wks ~Missing my Little Firework
BFP #2- 9/11/11 ~EDD 5/25/12 ~M/C (mmc10w)11/4/11 @ 11wks ~Missing my May Flower
BFP #3- 02/21/12 ~EDD 11/1/12 Audrey Lee Born 11/4/2012
BFP #4 ~EDD 6/20/14 stick baby stick!