Target registry? Not a good idea??

yurmom · October 2011

I have heard from several people not to register at Target mainly because of their horrible return policy (which I'm not exactly sure what that is). I really want to register there because I love Target! I live in Indianapolis so we have a BRU and BuyBuy Baby is opening, but I kind of have a grudge against BRU because I've had such a horrible time finding registry items for friends there. Also, I have a lot of family and friends from smaller cities that have Targets. What should I do? Meijer?? Any thoughts?

mhollidayesq · October 2011

I registered at Target for my son and had no problems. I thought their return policy was good. If the item was on your registry you didn't need a receipt.

lindslalala · October 2011

I registered at Target for my wedding and had zero problems. I'm registered there now and don't expect anything different!

SheenaNash1 · October 2011

I've registered there before and it was all fine. I've returned stuff there before as well and never had a problem. The people that are saying that probably just had crappy return sales people at the desk.

SassyRedhead · October 2011

Personally I wouldn't register at Target, yes they have cute stuff IF IT'S IN STOCK. The two major gripes with Target is their return policy and the fact that stuff is never ever in stock.

Buy Buy Baby and Amazon would be my top picks.

ColBas02 · October 2011

I registered the for my son Ryker and I had to return doubles from the babyshower, no biggie though and we didnt have any problems.

My only thing I would recommend is to h ave your friends/family make sure once they buy something off of the registry to make sure the cashier does their job so you dont get a ton of double. I got 3 baby slings ha ha.

If I were in the states Id register there!

niknak7 · October 2011

I hate Target's return policy but it is the only store besides Walmart that carries baby stuff within 45 minutes of my house. So it's not really an option to register anywhere else. For DD last year, I got some doubles and the only way I was able to return items is if they included a gift receipt with the gift. Otherwise I was out of luck to return things. Also another con is that their selection is constantly rotating what is in store vs. online vs. discontinuing. I had to re-register like 5 times and by that time it wasn't fun anymore. But they have stores near just about everyone and so I would register there again even with all the cons.

slukd79 · October 2011

Registered there for both my wedding and baby (in addition to other stores.) I had no problems returning things, and I *definitely* returned things. If I didn't have a receipt, I got store credit and honestly, who cares? There is always something I need at Target!

DR1819 · October 2011

I live in Indy as well and was thinking of registering at BBB too. I think that it's opening at the end of Novemeber. I scouted the baby section at Target and the selection is slim and I'm not a fan of their website. I heard if you shop at BBB you can use the coupons from Bed Bath and Beyond.

MotherMonster · October 2011

My top pick for registering is MyRegistry.com

I picked it because you can go all over the internet and register for things and it keeps track the same as a registry at a store. I wanted a lot from all over so that's why I picked it. It's super user friendly so I love it!

LizzyBlueEyes · October 2011

I registered at Target for our wedding and did half of our baby one there and am doing the other half at BRU. I have never had a problem returning stuff there, even without a receipt or after a long time frame.

punkymama · October 2011

I registered at Target for my wedding and for the baby. I haven't had issues returning anything.

I am noticing that some things aren't available but I also registered at Buy Buy Baby. I think it's just personal preference due to your experience at your local Target.

reneenearl · October 2011

MY SIL registered at target, she ended up having a boy and not a girl. She was tokld girl at the ultrasound so everything she registered for was pink or very girly. Not many people bought stuff off the registry, however target let me bring everything up there (even the carseat and bedding and stroller which was all was assembled) while my SIL was in the hospital and let me exchange EVERYTHING as long as i was doing an exchange and not asking for cash back. I thought that was a very reasonable request.

Everything I exchanged was not even purchased from her registry. They gave me no problem, they didn't hesitate and were very understanding. It was all purchased in early January, and when I returned it it was the last couple days in March. Every Item was opened! I have been saying good things about target ever since.

lulling · October 2011

I registered at Target for my wedding and the baby and have had no problems. I think that a lot of people that complain, about any store registry, is that they don't give cash back. But I don't, personally, know of any store that gives cash back for a registry gift. The person bought you a gift, you can exchange it and get a gift. If that guest wanted to give you cash they would have. (Sorry, that kind of gets my goat as I know people who registered for expensive wedding gifts and then attempted to take them back for cash. I am not saying you would do this.)

I think there is a time frame that you have to return the gifts within, maybe 60 days, but as long as you have your shower a month before your baby, you should have time to return anything that you don't want. I guess I figure if you registered for it you want it, right? I would check the policy on breast pumps as some stores will take them back and some will not.

I think there was some problem with the website when they were redo-ing it. But mine has been fine.

Alliebooberz · October 2011

I had a really bad experience with them with my registry. Without the gift receipt, I could not return anything. And I tried to return it within days of it being purchased, and they wouldn't allow me to... not even for store credit, which was all I wanted.

shanad · October 2011

Alliebooberz:
I had a really bad experience with them with my registry. Without the gift receipt, I could not return anything. And I tried to return it within days of it being purchased, and they wouldn't allow me to... not even for store credit, which was all I wanted.

I had a terrible time at Target too. I had my wedding registry with them. It may vary by store, since many of you have had no problem. Like Allie, Without a gift receipt, I could not return anything over $25 value, even though it was on my registry. I got stuck with a $50 laundry sorter/basket, that wouldn't fit in my laundry room, bc I couldn't return it and my aunt didn't have a gift receipt. Anything under $25, they will give you store credit if you supply your license and don't do it with more than $200 worth of items in one year. Oh and the exchange....yeah you can exchange, good luck if someone purchases something between now and Christmas you got a 90% chance you won't be able to find the same product in March (like clothes, bedding, etc).

This time around, I'm going with BRU and Amazon, just to get completion/discount coupons, since I already had a shower for DS #1.

526SadieSadie · October 2011

lindslalala:
I registered at Target for my wedding and had zero problems. I'm registered there now and don't expect anything different!

Same here! We're also registered at BRU, but if an item is less expensive at Target, I switch it over (our pack n play was nearly $50 less at Target!)

bingham101 · October 2011

To my knowledge Meijer does not have a registry. That made me sad. I love Meijer. I registered at target. I wanted a store we could go into and register. Their return policy is kinda harsh compared to walmart that will take anything and everything back. Either it has to be purchased off your registry, or you have to have a reciept to return it. Theres something about 90 days too, but I think they are a little more lax on that, and its 90 days from your due date not the purchase date. But I am not 100% on that. So far I am loving target, but I am going to register for a few things at BRU mainly because I got a coupon for 10 Gift Card if I register and they sent a 15% off. So I think I might get the mattress from there.

yurmom · October 2011

Interesting! Thanks for all the helpful advice, that's odd how Target return policies very by store, you'd think it'd all be the same.

2008PelicanBride · October 2011

We registered at Target for our wedding, even though we were advised against it for the same reasons that you mentioned. We did have some problems. Like, we got multiple of the same item (that was on our registry), but didn't have a gift receipt and the item was over $20.00, so they wouldn't let us exchange it. However, I love Target, so we will still be registering for the baby there too!

Want a personalized experience?

Target registry? Not a good idea??

Re: Target registry? Not a good idea??

Choose Another Board

Search Boards