Babies: 6 - 9 Months

Reason #232324 to not take your kid out of their dang car seat

https://www.mcall.com/news/local/parkland/mc-north-whitehall-crash-baby-killed-20110823,0,91791.story

This was posted on 9-12. It's a follow-up story, but you still get the background. Kid was hungry and screaming, dad took kid out to hold her on his lap and feed her a snack, drunk driver hit car and baby died.

I feel sad for the family. They've paid the ultimate price for a poor decision. I know we don't know for sure the baby would have survived in the car seat but I'm thinking her chances would have been better.  

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Reason #232324 to not take your kid out of their dang car seat

  • It's why we will always either wait or pull over.  It's terrible and I feel awful for them but it's so often that one small decsion like this leads to something terrible.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Loading the player...
  • That is so sad. I can't imagine having that guilt on top of losing a child. 
    IMG_8165 lb4lyfe2
    Online Photo Editor


    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers Ztarrgheighzurr Lylliegh Smith is due in January!
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  •  Those people will have to live the rest of their lifes with "what if".  So sad.  If I was the mother of that child, whether she was restrained or not...I would be paying a visit to the drunk driver.


    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • So terrible. I know I've had the urge to just take DS out of his seat. Hopefully other people will read this and think twice about taking their kids out of their car seats.
    imageimage
    BFP # 1- DS ~ TTC #2 since Jan. 2012 - BFP # 2 - "Baby Elsie" - Blighted Ovum - D&C August 22, 2012 at 7w3d, BFP # 3 - CP - December 30, 2012, BFP # 4 - CP - March 19, 2013 ~ First RE Appt. 4/24/13 Med cycle #1: 50mg Clomid and Trigger shot = BFN. Med. Cycle #2: 6 cysts found. No meds/rest cycle. Trying on our own = BFP # 5! Beta #1 = 77, Beta #2 = 129 Beta #3 = 94 - CP - July 2, 2013. BFP # 6! Beta#1 = 21, Beta#2 =58 Beta#3 = 134. U/S shows heartbeat of 142 at 7w2d!
  • imageteenagefbi:
    I know this is going to sound cold but, imagine if they had just pulled over?

    See this is the sh!t that runs through my head when I even think of taking her out of her seat or doing something that could be a bad idea. Is how could I live with myself if that happened knowing I could have just pulled over.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • That girl who posted on 3-6 a few weeks ago saying that she took her kid out of the car needs to read this.

    How sad for that family.

    Lilypie Angel and Memorial tickersLilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers
    Photobucket
  • This is so sad. Last night when we were driving home DS was FREAKING OUT!  It took a good 15 mins to find a safe place to pull over and it killed me but I deal with that over putting him in danger.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • This is just so sad.  I can't imagine how the parents must feel.

    We almost got rear ended a few weeks ago (when the ladies car finally stopped her front bumper was at my drivers side door so it would have been bad) and I had to go home instead of finishing running errands because I couldn't stop thinking "what if" and was so upset.  I hate listening to E cry but her safety is much more important than her being upset for a little while until we can pull over. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  •  That is a terrible thing that happened. I am sure those parents will always live with what if. But it does not matter how many tragedies there are some people will always take their children out of their car seat, some people will turn car seats around before 1 year and some people will let their children ride in the front seat before they are big/old enough.

    I am glad that they found sympathy with the parents and they will not be charged with anything. But I am very interested to see where the case against the drunk driver goes. I wonder if he will be found guilty of homicide. He is guilty of a DUI and the accident but is he really guilty of her death? If the parents had not endangered their child he may not have been able to kill her.

  • What is even more sad is that they drive a minivan. If the boys get fussy, we pull over and I get in the back row (they sit in the 2nd row). That way, I can feed them or play with them or soothe them without them leaving their seats.

    All around, this is a horrible, sad story. 

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickersImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • imagejcole32444:

     That is a terrible thing that happened. I am sure those parents will always live with what if. But it does not matter how many tragedies there are some people will always take their children out of their car seat, some people will turn car seats around before 1 year and some people will let their children ride in the front seat before they are big/old enough.

    I am glad that they found sympathy with the parents and they will not be charged with anything. But I am very interested to see where the case against the drunk driver goes. I wonder if he will be found guilty of homicide. He is guilty of a DUI and the accident but is he really guilty of her death? If the parents had not endangered their child he may not have been able to kill her.

    That's a can of worms I don't even want to think about. What a mess. If his lawyer is any good, he'll argue that point. :( I feel horrible for that family.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • This is reinforcement why some things you just. can't. do.

    My #1 fear is something happening to my LO that my own poor decision making or negligence made worse.

  • imagebuffaluffagus:
    imagejcole32444:

     That is a terrible thing that happened. I am sure those parents will always live with what if. But it does not matter how many tragedies there are some people will always take their children out of their car seat, some people will turn car seats around before 1 year and some people will let their children ride in the front seat before they are big/old enough.

    I am glad that they found sympathy with the parents and they will not be charged with anything. But I am very interested to see where the case against the drunk driver goes. I wonder if he will be found guilty of homicide. He is guilty of a DUI and the accident but is he really guilty of her death? If the parents had not endangered their child he may not have been able to kill her.

    I'm going to assume yes, since if a drunk driver hits someone not wearing their seatbelt they often get slapped with homicide.

    I am sure he will be just because he was drunk. But if a sober person did the same thing the outcome would be different.

    I knew a person who drove home under the influence and hit a kid who can out into the road on a skateboard. Witnesses said that there was nothing the driver could have done. The kid jumped out in front of the car. Even a sober person would have hit the kid but the guy was still charged with homicide because he was drunk.

  • I almost got a ticket because I won't take K out of her seat while moving. I was driving in a city I don't know, she was screaming, I saw a parking lot right on a corner (side entrance) and pulled in so I could feed her. 1/2 hour later, I pulled out of the parking lot and the car on the main street let me in... then put on the blue lights. Apparently, it was a one-way but because the lot entrance was about 8 feet from the corner (and I never saw a sign), I didn't realize. I explained what happened and he let me go.

     

    I'd rather have a dozen tickets than risk her getting hurt by taking her out.

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"