Thoughts on these "old-fashioned" girly names?

sunkiss000 · March 2009

I like old fashioned names. Of these I like Amelia the best.. its on my list too.

DarcyLongfellow · March 2009

I love Lydia, Amelia, and Stella. Particularly Stella and Amelia. They seem like sweet, old fashioned names, but ones which are going to stand the test of time. You can picture a little girl with those names, but you can also picture a CEO. (maybe Lydia a little less so than the other three)

Dahlia and Scarlett seem a bit like they're trying too hard. Scarlett is just Gone with the Wind to me.

Sophie I have issues with, but I think they're my own personal issues. I think it's a beautiful, adorable name. But it does somehow seem juvenile to me. It also seems like it should be a nickname for Sophia, even though I know it's not.

I like Amelie, but it does not seem in the same category as all the other names you suggested. I don't really think it would be mispronounced, though. Don't you think enough people would have seen that movie that came out a few years ago?