Would you side eye me?

[Deleted User]

The user and all related content has been deleted.

kaswanson

Yeah... I love both the names, but am not a fan of this combo in one family.  Sorry.

mkhardy

I think they are both darling names and honestly wouldn't think anything of it. I say do it!

ho11yday

I wouldn't notice the matchiness.  There are far worse sibsets than Scarlet and Ruby.

MrsHennyBee

ho11yday:

I wouldn't notice the matchiness.  There are far worse sibsets than Scarlet and Ruby.

This, I think both names are adorable (especially Ruby)! 

913mom

I have a Ruby (4)and a Scarlett(2) and some people notice the "theme" and others don't.   I honestly just love both names too and they will grow up to be individuals so I say do it!  Super cute!

Mrs.G123

Cute names. I would definitely notice.

swgdvm

I love both names and i feel bad saying it but i think its too matchy. Its ok for two girls but might be a problem if you have a third!

artroyer

I would notice too. But maybe it's the teacher in me. We had students with the last name Taylor... The girls were Ann and Elizabeth. Noticed that.

SpruceGrouse

Not at all, I love both those names and it is matchy but not in a bad way.

Belle3184

artroyer:

I would notice too. But maybe it's the teacher in me. We had students with the last name Taylor... The girls were Ann and Elizabeth. Noticed that.

Oh my

BootsyLou

I would think it was a little strange but wouldn't make a big deal about it.  

queenbone

Are you only going to have two children? If so, then it would probably be okay. It is a bit cheesy, but lots of people have themed sibsets.

If you are planning on having more children I would not do it because it kind of locks you into using another 'red' name (Rusty?) or having one child standing out as not matching your theme.

Ilumine

Given the fact that your daughters will only be living under your roof (ie needing you to call for their names in tandem or sign cards for them, or...well I really cannot come up with any other times where people really list an entire family's set of names together....) for 18 out of the 78 year of their lives, I am not quite sure why it matters.

 

dairygirl19

If you like it, roll with it. It's a bit themey maybe but they're both solid legit names people know.

What do I know though? I have a Ruby and my baby name of the week is Hazel..so I'm right there with you in a way.

brooksidebride

It's definitely theme-y, and I'd probably make a SLIGHT side-eye. But it's not THAT bad. They are both really nice names, and if you really like Ruby, I wouldn't let it stop you.

Zimger

I don't think it is a big deal.

moonfaerie

I love both names, but yes, I would side-eye you. Not in a mean way but still.

doublefiesta

I would notice but not side-eye. I love both names and think they're adorable together.

EastCoastBride

I woudln't even notice.

lizzybean

Both names are beautiful. I say go for it. 

luminousbluestar

Yeah sorry. Independently they are both great names but together it's theme overload. 

JaysonandKristin

swgdvm:

I love both names and i feel bad saying it but i think its too matchy. Its ok for two girls but might be a problem if you have a third!

Garnet?

Whitterpow

Both names individually are fine, but together I would feel like it was a red theme also. I would probably roll my eyes a little, but I've seen worse.

Whitterpow

JaysonandKristin:

swgdvm:

I love both names and i feel bad saying it but i think its too matchy. Its ok for two girls but might be a problem if you have a third!

Garnet?

Rose?

Meery82

I would notice, but they are both great names, so I wouldn't side eye you. 

JemmaWRX

That's a tough one because both names are great.  If it were me, I probably wouldn't do it. 

Jesslauren310

i think it's cute! and im not totally sure id notice it unless you pointed it out. 

ellebee2

Yup. I would. Sounds like you have an affinity for the colour red.

ellebee2

Whitterpow:

JaysonandKristin:

swgdvm:

I love both names and i feel bad saying it but i think its too matchy. Its ok for two girls but might be a problem if you have a third!

Garnet?

Rose?

Crimson? 

[Deleted User]

The user and all related content has been deleted.

MTmama3

I actually know someone who has a Scarlett and a Ruby. I always thought it was odd but it's not too horrible because both are cute names

brookelynpaisley

Yep, a little too close for me. 

gnomemom

I would notice and maybe chuckle about it, but they are adorable names, so I wouldn't hold it against you.

NL105

I would notice that they are "themed", but I honestly wouldn't care or side eye you for it. They are both cute names regardless.

seaheather24

Wouldnt even think of it, I think they are cute!

BabyMorrissey

As long as baby 3 isn't matching as well, I think you are good to go..