Mayonnaise vs Miracle Whip

coronitaextra · June 2013

There are two types of people in this world, those who like mayonnaise, and those who like miracle whip. And then a handful of weirdos who don't like either and apparently enjoy dry sandwiches.

So, which team are you on? Only because it's Saturday night, and I'm bored as fluck.

[Deleted User] · June 2013

The user and all related content has been deleted.

CousinVicki · June 2013

ew. i am very iffy about mayo, i w ill only use it , very sparingly, on a turkey-ONLY sandwich. if there is cheese on it too? NO WAY. and omg, wendys putting mayo on hambugers? BARF!

also, miracle whip= disgustamundo.

sleepy33 · June 2013

Mayo.

beesquar3d · June 2013

Mayo

Jalee85 · June 2013

Oh this is a tough one! I used miracle Whip exclusively as a child.. But would probably buy Mayo now! I try and use Mustard for sandwiches because its not as fattening! My hubby is one of those weird dry sandwich sorts of people! Although he will do butter!

HFrizzle · June 2013

Before pregnancy loved Miracle whip, but now its gross and too sweet, so regular mayo it is.

coronitaextra · June 2013

mmgkms:
And to think I missed you when you were MIA ::mobile wink:: I'm in the apparent weirdo category. Mustard is it for me.

Lol! I only say that because I am a weirdo, not about the mayo vs MW debate (well maybe to you, you weirdo mustard eater! Lol, jk), but in so many other ways when it comes to food. My dinner was cheese pizza with ranch dressing on it. Nope, not a newly developed prego thing. I've done it since I was 10 at least.

shelley1002 · June 2013

Miracle Whip. It's what I grew up on and it's less fattening than mayo. DH likes mayo so that is what we keep in the house.

izna009 · June 2013

Yo Mayoooooo

atcwag · June 2013

Honestly, on a "regular" sandwich (ham, turkey, etc.), I'm a mustard girl.

I will not eat Miracle Whip on anything - bleck! To those who say; "It tastes just like mayo!", no, no it does not. Not even close. BARFAROO!

The only thing I really eat mayo on is a sub....italian subs are one of my favorite meals and I'm a mayo kind of girl in that regard.

Side note, I worked at a local hotdog shop (been open in our town for 60 years!) for about 6 years in highschool/summers of college. Obviously, I tried LOTS of combinations of condiments. My favorite dog, hands down? Mayo, cheese (like, melted nacho [but not spicy] cheese), onion, kraut & dill pickle slices. Don't knock it til you try it!

I also have a very weird sandwich eating family. My grandpa was notorious for eating peanut butter & pickle relish sandwiches and my dad at chipped ham & butter sandwiches almost everyday when I was growing up.

coronitaextra · June 2013

Oh and for the record, I will only eat Best Foods/Hellman's mayo. No MW loving here!

Amjoy25 · June 2013

Deft mayo!

My husband is one of those weirdos who prefers mustard. Blech! Mustard on a delicious turkey sandwich the day after Thanksgiving? It's just wrong!

atcwag · June 2013

mmgkms:
batmandi:

mmgkms:
And to think I missed you when you were MIA ::mobile wink:: I'm in the apparent weirdo category. Mustard is it for me.

Lol! I only say that because I am a weirdo, not about the mayo vs MW debate (well maybe to you, you weirdo mustard eater! Lol, jk), but in so many other ways when it comes to food. My dinner was cheese pizza with ranch dressing on it. Nope, not a newly developed prego thing. I've done it since I was 10 at least.

I love ranch on pizza! You have to try Catalina dressing in pizza though. Do NOT say a word til you try it! Also not a pregnant thing lol And mustard is fabulous FTR lol

I also like ranch dressing on pizza! My mom eats Catalina on her pizza. I've tried it - not for me!

Stellabelle12 · June 2013

Team mayo...but not because of taste. "Miracle Whip" reminds me too much of "Cool Whip", which does NOT belong on any sandwich of mine.

coronitaextra · June 2013

Stellabelle12:
Team mayo...but not because of taste. "Miracle Whip" reminds me too much of "Cool Whip", which does NOT belong on any sandwich of mine.

But what if it was a chocolate chip cookie sandwich?

Jalee85 · June 2013

Mustard is the bomb! Unless its a BLT!

Amjoy25 · June 2013

T3hKay:
dh13:
Flucking gross.
Geez nothing is satisfying you tonight lol.

Dh hates anything delicious, such as cheese. Xo dh!

JenMatt2010 · June 2013

Miracle whip unless it's on a burger and then mayo FTW!!

elllaf · June 2013

batmandi:
Oh and for the record, I will only eat Best Foods/Hellman's mayo. No MW loving here!

This for me too!

I grew up with Hellman's in NJ.
Now that I live out west they only have Best Foods.
Thank god they are the same company!
Dh likes both...but ew MW is GRAY. That is not normal..

JenMatt2010 · June 2013

comeongetdown:
dh13:
Amjoy25:
T3hKay:
dh13:
Flucking gross.
Geez nothing is satisfying you tonight lol. <3 
Dh hates anything delicious, such as cheese. Xo dh! 

And membranes. I hate hearing about membranes and the process of stripping them.
especially if it's not your OB?

Haha sorry for starting all that...I didn't know it would get so out of control. It did start with a legit question.

Also I have to say I feel kind of infamous that a post of mine spurred a repost by CV...

bkeane619 · June 2013

Mayooooonaaaiiize

jorkz821 · June 2013

Ummmm I'll eat either. I can't really tell the difference.

Southerndancinmama · June 2013

Does it make me a weirdo if I like both?

lbethke99 · June 2013

I'm a mayo girl- the only time I like miracle whip is if it's on summer turkey sandwich with grapes and all that jazz on it.

coronitaextra · June 2013

Southerndancinmama:
Does it make me a weirdo if I like both?

Only if you like both on the same sandwich....

Stellabelle12 · June 2013

batmandi:
Stellabelle12:
Team mayo...but not because of taste. "Miracle Whip" reminds me too much of "Cool Whip", which does NOT belong on any sandwich of mine.

But what if it was a chocolate chip cookie sandwich?

Touche. Mmm....now I want one of those, dammit. With strawberries.

ETA fixing stupid autocorrect.

--halo-- · June 2013

Definitely mayo, and I am also on the Best Foods train. Other mayo is ok, but best foods is, well, the best... lol

Mmhodges07 · June 2013

Hahaha, I knew dh would hate this post.

Mayo all the way!

Flutterby00 · June 2013

Both, but only since the past couple years - since JJ's came to town. MW on a JJ sandwich isn't the same. So they both have a place in my world!

blondolphn · June 2013

Bring on the bbq sauce!!! I love sweet baby ray's and the different flavors. If it's on sale, I stock up.

mrambo3 · June 2013

I bat for both teams. LOL Miracle Whip on a sandwich like turkey, lettuce, tomato type of thing. Mayo for sandwiches like gondolas from Avanti's. If both are offered, I'd choose Miracle Whip.

Wino0920 · June 2013

I guess I am really odd cause I can eat either. There wasn't even a category for me. Sad face.

blondolphn · June 2013

mrambo3:
I bat for both teams. LOL Miracle Whip on a sandwich like turkey, lettuce, tomato type of thing. Mayo for sandwiches like gondolas from Avanti's. If both are offered, I'd choose Miracle Whip.

Mrambo, I see that your from chicago. At what point have you had Avantis? I live where the original one started. Nom Nom Nom.

Inn2 · June 2013

Neither unless you are giving me JJ and then for some reason it's delicious! Also whoppers aren't bad as long as they don't overdo the stuff. I'm a mustard, plain, or butter sandwich type. When I make tuna salad I do use a tiny bit of either just to keep it all together. Mine relates back to one picnic sandwich with spoiled mayo...and only in the last 10 years have I learned to tolerate the stuff.