Blended Families

Am I a total jerk?

DS and DD have been asking to BBQ dinner, eat outside and swim. It's so hot so I said "sure". I really don't want to heat the house up anyways. Seems like a great idea, DH is onboard and K is here tonight. Should have been an easy evening.

When K gets here the kids tell her our plans for dinner. She gets really quiet and says she can't swim. Huh? K swims all the time and is a great swimmer. Shoot, half the time we can't get her out of the pool for dinner or bedtime. I asked what she meant and she says to me, "My mom sad I can't swim here". Are you freaking KIDDING?! Now she's telling K she can't swim when she's over here? We told her of course she's allowed to swim here, but she refuses to swim.

I don't think it's fair to change plans. I feel like the kids voted, 2 vote "yes" and one votes "no". Growing up that's how disputes were settled at my house. And I really don't think DS and DD should be forced to follow whatever whacked out rule BM has come up with this week. So we're out by the pool grilling dinner, DS and DD are swimming and K is pouting. Are we total jerks for not changing the plans? Or is it ok to let K feel left out, considering we already told her she can swim?
image

Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



Re: Am I a total jerk?

  • No, you are not a jerk. But I'd be sitting by the pool with her, dangling my feet and having a little bonding time about girl stuff instead.

    She can dangle her feet in the pool can't she?

    Can you have a pool side card or board game with her while the other's swim?

    Her mother is a dumbass.  Please tell me DH is going to have a word with her? Not like that's any good....

    "he offered her the world. she said she had her own" - poet Monique Duval
  • Loading the player...
  • That's really tough. Man, K's BM is a real piece of work. That's terrible of her. I would have done the same thing - continued with the plans since you had already involved the other kids. I would keep encouraging K to join in or have one of you try to talk to her again.
  • Are you sure that it's in fact true? Sounds like a kid's way of manipulating and getting attention.
  • I can already tell you, my DH would picked her up and thrown her in and said 'There. It's not your fault you're in the pool now, is it?' I honestly would not let this one slide. I would call BM's bull crap out on this and straight up tell K that unless her mom has a valid reason for such and has discussed it with her dad, then y'all have not initiated such a rule or punishment. I honestly would not let this one go. If you know K wants to swim, loves swim, I would all but make her get in. Only if you are sure it is her choice would I let it go. Is she punished at BM's if she does something fun at your house? This is seriously sick. I would totally put the spotlight on her crap this time. And I wouldn't care one freaking bit. ETA - I realize I said, "y'all." In TN, that IS a word. lol. Thank y'all for not pointing it out to me. I say it all the time, and I'm sure I type it more than I realize. But when I read back over it, I always feel a bit dumber. XP
  • imageambrvan:
    I can already tell you, my DH would picked her up and thrown her in and said 'There. It's not your fault you're in the pool now, is it?' I honestly would not let this one slide. I would call BM's bull crap out on this and straight up tell K that unless her mom has a valid reason for such and has discussed it with her dad, then y'all have not initiated such a rule or punishment. I honestly would not let this one go. If you know K wants to swim, loves swim, I would all but make her get in. Only if you are sure it is her choice would I let it go. Is she punished at BM's if she does something fun at your house? This is seriously sick. I would totally put the spotlight on her crap this time. And I wouldn't care one freaking bit.

    Fluck BM. In this case, I think it's totally fine to throw BM under the bus. WTF. Can I please smack that woman??

    I would say "K, BM is wrong, and she doesn't get to decide the rules at our house. Jo and Daddy do, and we say you're allowed to swim." And then throw the kid in the pool.

    She is so stupid. I'm p!ssed for you guys and K right now. 

    image
  • You're not a jerk for being upset, but your SD is probably sick inside.  No matter what she does, she is making a parent upset.  She can't win.  Its obvious her mom is out of line- but you have to feel for your SD.  I like a PPs idea of dangling feet and having some girl time.
  • image+just+j+:

    No, you are not a jerk. But I'd be sitting by the pool with her, dangling my feet and having a little bonding time about girl stuff instead.

    She can dangle her feet in the pool can't she?

    Can you have a pool side card or board game with her while the other's swim?

    Her mother is a dumbass.  Please tell me DH is going to have a word with her? Not like that's any good....

     

    I was sitting there with PJ and had my feet and PJ's feet in the pool.  But K refused to come near the water saying that her mom will get mad if she gets wet.  After DH was done BBQ-ing he sat with K and told her that she's always allowed to swim here, as long as there's an adult watching.  We all sat together to eat and after dinner the kids played a card game.  But it was clear that K was upset. 

     

    imagehopanka:
    Are you sure that it's in fact true? Sounds like a kid's way of manipulating and getting attention.

    Unfortunately this is exactly the type of stuff BM tells K.  Whenever K is excited about something we do here, her mom stifles it.  When we had our Disneyland passes BM told K that Disneyland was "their" thing (completely ignoring the fact that DH has been the one maintaining K's Disneyland pass and going with her almost weekly) and that K going with us made her sad.  After I had been painting K's nails for a couple years, BM suddenly decided that I wasn't allowed to paint K's nails anymore.  She even told K she wasn't allowed to go to the beach with us because BM doesn't like that I wear a bikini and she didn't trust we would put sunblock on K.  DH asked BM about all these things and she confirmed saying it, but has these ridiculous justifications.

     

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • imagejobalchak:
    image+just+j+:

    No, you are not a jerk. But I'd be sitting by the pool with her, dangling my feet and having a little bonding time about girl stuff instead.

    She can dangle her feet in the pool can't she?

    Can you have a pool side card or board game with her while the other's swim?

    Her mother is a dumbass.  Please tell me DH is going to have a word with her? Not like that's any good....

     

    I was sitting there with PJ and had my feet and PJ's feet in the pool.  But K refused to come near the water saying that her mom will get mad if she gets wet.  After DH was done BBQ-ing he sat with K and told her that she's always allowed to swim here, as long as there's an adult watching.  We all sat together to eat and after dinner the kids played a card game.  But it was clear that K was upset. 

     

    imagehopanka:
    Are you sure that it's in fact true? Sounds like a kid's way of manipulating and getting attention.

    Unfortunately this is exactly the type of stuff BM tells K.  Whenever K is excited about something we do here, her mom stifles it.  When we had our Disneyland passes BM told K that Disneyland was "their" thing (completely ignoring the fact that DH has been the one maintaining K's Disneyland pass and going with her almost weekly) and that K going with us made her sad.  After I had been painting K's nails for a couple years, BM suddenly decided that I wasn't allowed to paint K's nails anymore.  She even told K she wasn't allowed to go to the beach with us because BM doesn't like that I wear a bikini and she didn't trust we would put sunblock on K.  DH asked BM about all these things and she confirmed saying it, but has these ridiculous justifications.

     

    Continue to call her out on it and don't let it slide. Document it as parental alienation and hope that over time it might matter. If he does not call her out on it there is no hope of it changing even if it does not help. 

    Jen - Mom to two December 12 babies Nathaniel 12/12/06 and Addison 12/12/08
  • OMG, this is just ridiculous. I didn't realize she was that bad. I knew she was BSC, but this is just nuts.

    XH likes to say that I'm hurting DD by my decisions, and I am not typically one to throw that in another parent's face because I get it so often, however, she really is hurting her daughter with this kind of crap.

    If I were your DH, I'd be all over her.

    I also think it's time you both start talking to your DD about what manipulation is and what BM is doing and why. She's going to need some serious coping skills to deal with this crap. 

    "he offered her the world. she said she had her own" - poet Monique Duval
  • Hand on the bible, her butt would've gotten thrown in.

    Can you guys explain you have your rules at your house and her BM is not in charge (some other wording) of what goes on at your house?

    This BM seriously has mental health issues.

  • How old is K?  Around age 10 BM told SD and SS that SD was "going to start any day she could just tell".  This made SD edgy and made SS tell everyone that SD was pissy because she was about to get the girl thing for the first time.  This went on for 3 years.  Any chance BM there is pulling something similar and has told her "do not swim there, you could start and how embarassed would you be?" 

    If not that, it's just another random, scary BM BS!  UNREAL to me.  I can tell you that putting the "choice" on K is not a good idea; she is caught in a double bind.  I love the idea of DH throwing her in if they have that kind of relationship.  KUP on DH/BM and how things go with K.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • No you are not a jerk. BM will not dictate rules in our house. My DH would definitely have thrown SD in.
    No one else will ever know the strength of my love for you. After all, you are the only one who knows what my heart sounds like from the inside.
    image






  • Thanks everyone.  Had K not seemed so upset about all of it, DH probably would have thrown her in.  But since she was really worried about upsetting BM, he didn't want to cross a line and make things worse for K.  We have told her repeatedly in the past that BM doesn't make the rules here, we do.  And in the past when these "rules" have been put in place by BM, K eventually comes around after a few weeks and stops obeying them.

    I think the real problem is that BM has emotionally manipulated K so much over the years that K is genuinely worried about upsetting her.  Everytime one of these "rules" has been put in place, DH questions BM in front of K and tells K that she is allowed to do XYZ when she's with us.  He does it at a pick up so that K comes home with him and she doesn't have to deal with BM afterwards.  Really though, BM has told K so many times over the years that she needs K (among other awful things to tell a child) that I think K now feels responsible for BM's happiness.  I mean, we're talking about really emotionally manipulative things.  We do document everything, but unfortunately we've discovered that our Judge doesn't seem to find these things to be a big deal.

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • No, you are not a jerk at all.

     

    Your dh needs to sit down with K and let her know that at her moms house, there are mom rules and at his house there are his rules.   Some may be the same and some may  be different but which ever parent she is with, is the one who makes the rules.  period.

    He also needs to tell BM the same thing. 

  • This is so sad.  I honestly don't know how you guys do it.  I've kept up with your story and you seem like very devoted and involved mom and step mom.  I think most BMs would love to have their ex end up with a woman like yourself who actually loves and cares so much for their kid.  I honestly want to tell you to kidnap K and move to another country or hire a sniper before BM completely ruins her life.  I know this is illegal and not an option but seriously, that woman is sick.  I don't even have any helpful advice.  This will be a cross you bear until the kid turns 18.  Probably longer since BM has done such a good job with her emotional manipulation.  K is going to need a lot of therapy.  
  • imagedbliesmer:

    That is beyond ridiculous.  How horrible of this woman to dictate something as innocent as swimming as your house and resulting in K having a bad night.  Normal people would think of the consequences on K and not do it but your BM tops the cake.

    I would keep having DH talk with BM and "fight" over it.  But I don't know that I would do it in front of K.  Maybe ask her via email so you have documentation.  Explain that it's not fair to K to force her to sit and watch everyone have fun because of her silly rule.  I don't know about throwing her in next time, but keep reiterating that she can't dictate your rules.  Could you also bring in how when your bio kids go to DC that you don't get to say what they do?  You know that the adults will keep them safe and you trust in that.  Obviously she doesn't know the truth about DC but it might help her understand the situation.

    Sadly it's a tough situation and I don't see you guys getting a break anytime soon and it breaks my heart for K. 

    Anytime DH tries to discuss any of this through email or text BM responds, "We'll talk at pick up/drop off.  She knows damn well what she's doing and doesn't want it in writing.  As for DH discussing it in front of K, he feels that by doing it in front of K and then giving permission to K in front of BM, K knows that her mom knows Daddy said it's alright.  As much as it sucks, we're trying to open K's eyes a bit to what is being done to her.  We can't flat out say, "Your mom is a manipulative b!tch who's going to keep you needing therapy forever", but we hope that by us pointing out how unreasonable BM is being about things K will start to understand that she doesn't have to do BM's bidding.

    This whole thing just sucks. 

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • image2chatter:

    How old is K?  Around age 10 BM told SD and SS that SD was "going to start any day she could just tell".  This made SD edgy and made SS tell everyone that SD was pissy because she was about to get the girl thing for the first time.  This went on for 3 years.  Any chance BM there is pulling something similar and has told her "do not swim there, you could start and how embarassed would you be?" 

    K is only 7, so none of that could be an issue.  I can't believe a mom would freak her kid out that much about getting her first menstrual period!  Craziness.  It's really just BM trying to make it so that K "can't" do anything fun when she's with us and make it so she doesn't want to be with us, plain and simple. 

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • Wow that woman is a complete piece of garbage. Who does that to their kids?! Jo, every time you post something about BM and the effect her manipulation has on K I get so angry for you and heartbroken for K. Even if you make it perfectly clear that BM has no authority in your house, she will punish or shame or guilt K as soon as she gets home. Its a no-win. I can't believe that the judge doesn't see these things as blatant PA and take action. I wish I had some advice for you.
    BabyFetus Ticker


    image
  • Does K see a therapist now? If so, can they help her to understand this whole thing? BM makes rules for our house too - like SD and SS must respond to texts even if we are eating dinner because they are not be safe in our home (people who are not white live in my neighborhood GASP). DH just takes their phones if they try to text her under the table. The issue here is - we lost the PAS battle. DH did not let her make rules, but she is custodial and has seemingly infinite amounts of time to spin her crazy. I would therefore strongly rec a therapist if you lack one, as we did things that made sense, are in books like Divorce Poison, and we lost.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • image2chatter:
    Does K see a therapist now? If so, can they help her to understand this whole thing? BM makes rules for our house too - like SD and SS must respond to texts even if we are eating dinner because they are not be safe in our home (people who are not white live in my neighborhood GASP). DH just takes their phones if they try to text her under the table. The issue here is - we lost the PAS battle. DH did not let her make rules, but she is custodial and has seemingly infinite amounts of time to spin her crazy. I would therefore strongly rec a therapist if you lack one, as we did things that made sense, are in books like Divorce Poison, and we lost.

    Ugh, don't get me started on the therapy battle we've had.  DH and I have been trying for years to get K in therapy.  BM agreed once, but yanked K out of it.  BM's side of the story:  transportation became too difficult and K was getting scheduled during BM's work hours.  Why didn't she just ask me to drive K?  BM never answered that question.  Therapist's side of the story:  when she made it clear to BM that K was well adjusted and happy with the blended family DH and I had created, BM went ballistic and demanded that the therapist "admit" K was being neglected in our home.  When therapist refused to do so, BM stopped bringing K.  Ever since then, we have tried repeatedly to get K into therapy and BM won't agree. My gut feeling is that BM knows what she's doing is wrong and damaging to K and doesn't want to get caught.

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • WTH.  That is terrible.  I can't believe that BM would do that to her.  Seems like BD would be the one makeing the rules when SD is with you.  That is bizarre.  Was she in trouble or grounded?
  • Every house is different with different rules.  In my house, the step-kids' mom is not able to dictate anything.  Our house, our rules. Done. She can go suck rotten eggs if she doesn't like what goes on in our house.   
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"