Caroline vs. Genevieve?

kmkaull2

We're team green.  Boy name is 100% set as Jude Patrick.

Girls, we're wavering between:

Caroline Ann (mn is a family name)

Genevieve Catherine (mn is my name, may use Eve as a nn)

Thoughts?  We're open to other ideas, too.  Obviously we like classic names.  My DH is not sold on Caroline and I wonder if Genevieve is a mouthful.  (DS's name is Quinn.)

 Thanks for your input and suggestions.  

mrs_tacos

I love Genevieve, but not necessarily with Quinn. Eva and Quinn is cute, though. Caroline is just kinda ok to me.

Other suggestions that I like with Quinn:

Elise

Alice

Charlotte

Emma

Willa

Beatrice

Adele

Audrey

Nora

Rosalie

Elsa

Audra

Natalie

Ava

Lillian 

 

Moneypenny424

Genevieve Katherine for sure! Love it. I like Caroline, but don't love it with Ann.

amberpro

I love Caroline. So pretty. And we do family mn, too. Stick with Ann.

Genevieve is also pretty. If you go that route, I prefer Catherine as a mn. I don't care for the double "eve" and prefer the use of family names.

Mom2katiec

Caroline. Classic and pretty!

macchiatto

LOVE Genevieve Catherine! I think either Eve or Vivi would be a cute nn.

CeCe8579

Caroline Ann!

firsttimeauntie

Genevieve

WashingtonQueen

I like Genevieve a lot better!! It is so pretty and not overused.

DaisyZH

I like them both but prefer Caroline.

Mochadoodle

Caroline Ann is lovely! Genevieve is too, but it's definitely a mouthful. And I love your boy name!

Suggestions...

Eve Catherine

Lucy Catherine

Violet Ann

JesseKhloe&Me

I knew a Genevieve who went by Gena. The only reason I would worry about Caroline is because I'm not a fan on the nn Carol. Although if you stick to your guns with no NN then I would choice Caroline.

periwinklebloom

Genevieve Catherine is a beautiful name.

Mrs.G123

Love Genevieve.

Mrs.M&M

Caroline Ann makes me think of Carolann.  I like Caroline, just not with Ann.  Genevieve Catherine is pretty. Since you mention using Eve as a nn, what about Evelyn?  I have a friend who just named her baby Evelyn but calls her Evy. I think Evelyn is nice and a little more updated and ageless.  

skio

Caroline Ann.

==N==

Caroline is nice but Genevieve is by far one of my all time favorites.

mjune3881

I adore Genevieve ... It's my girls name if we have another.

ObLaDi

I loooove Genevieve, with the nn Eve or Evie. It's my second favorite girl name.

Caroline is pretty but super popular and a lot more bland to me. 

kmkaull2

Mrs.M&M:

Caroline Ann makes me think of Carolann.  I like Caroline, just not with Ann.  Genevieve Catherine is pretty. Since you mention using Eve as a nn, what about Evelyn?  I have a friend who just named her baby Evelyn but calls her Evy. I think Evelyn is nice and a little more updated and ageless.  

Yeah, I agree about the Carolann.  It bugs me too.  Just trying to honor my aunt/godmother with the "Ann".  I LOVE Evelyn, too.  Not sure I love it with our last name.

Thanks for all of the feedback.  I think Genevieve Catherine is going to be the winner.  :-)

banannapeach85

Definitely Caroline.

cmw&tdm

Not a huge fan of Genevieve but its ok, love Caroline.

laurakaz13

They are both beautiful! You can't lose.  My DD is Grace Eleanor, so I clearly also love classic names. 

eclipselova4eva

Caroline is so cute and she will grow into the name as an adult.

hollyk224

I love the name Caroline, but I don't like Ann with it.

momtobe1028

Ahh so hard to choose ! Both were on the top of our list ! I'm going to go with Caroline .

BulgariHeart

They're both beautiful but I think I like Caroline a tad more. Only, it doesn't flow too well with MN Ann IMO. 

magsugar13

Genevieve

iErica

I really like both!!  But Genevieve has the edge for me.

rpalen29

love both. can't go wrong with either. 

some other classic names:

jocelyn

jaqueline

veronica

charlotte

claire

 

JKLA215

Mrs.MM:

Caroline Ann makes me think of Carolann. nbsp;I like Caroline, just not with Ann. nbsp;Genevieve Catherine is pretty. Since you mention using Eve as a nn, what about Evelyn? nbsp;I have a friend who just named her baby Evelyn but calls her Evy. I think Evelyn is nice and a little more updated and ageless. nbsp;

Agree with this!!

ktzen3

They are both pretty but I prefer Genevieve (Eve). That is on my short list, too.

 Caroline & Quinn both have a "C" sound at the beginning which might get hard when you are calling one or the other. 

WinsyWade

JesseKhloeMe:

I knew a Genevieve who went by Gena. The only reason I would worry about Caroline is because I'm not a fan on the nn Carol. Although if you stick to your guns with no NN then I would choice Caroline.

O.O

Carol as a nn for Caroline? Um, no. Caroline doesn't have a nn. Carol is NOT a nn for Caroline. Grrr

MrsP7309

I'm clearly partial to Genevieve (points at ticker).  Genevieve Catherine is beautiful!