selfish middle name poll

solsburyhill

Ok, please tell me which of these you like best.

 

Greta Frances (Frances after my Grandpa whom I'd really love to honor but DH and I think Greta Frances sounds kind of weird)

Greta Marie (kind of a generic middle name, but it's my Gram's middle name as well as many other family members)

Greta Mae (we love the sound of it, think it's totally adorable, but it's my grandma on my dad's side maiden name and I try to disassociate myself from his family so ...)

 

DH suggested going with Greta Mae Frances Lastname.  That way we get the cute Greta Mae and can honor Grandpa.  I just don't know about 2 middle names though. 

PrincessPeach13

I love your DH's idea.  It flows well and sounds cute.  I don't think there' anything wrong with two middle names.  Especially with the names you gave, because they aren't really long names either.

 

eta: and I think Augie and Greta sound adorable together.

mnewlee

I love the way Greta Mae sounds but I'd probably go with Frances or Mae Frances since it's so meaningful.

I don't think Greta Frances sounds bad and unless she's in trouble you probably won't be calling her by her full name very often.

T&HLove

Hmm.. All of them sound good!

I actually think Frances sounds cute, and of course there's meaning, which I love.. So I vote Frances. 

 

ldcoffel

All good choices!
I love the sound of Greta Mae.

Hmm. I pick Greta Mae Francis.

solsburyhill

I've practiced yelling Greta Frances stop throwing sand!  And I find Frances is a good "you're in trouble" middle name.  It just doesn't flow off the tongue all pretty like Greta Mae.

Augie gets called August Peter at least once a day, lol.   

T&HLove

I should also add, that I like Frances because of the significance but Marie and Mae were both top middle name choices for my Greta, so it's hard to help you pick

Ms5586

Gretchen Mae - I like double middle names.  My nephew has a double middle name, the first mn being my sister's pick, and the 2nd being my bil's family name.  He always knows when he's in serious trouble lol.

solsburyhill

T&HLove:

I should also add, that I like Frances because of the significance but Marie and Mae were both top middle name choices for my Greta, so it's hard to help you pick

I thought your Greta had Marie as the middle name : )

Do you ever type out Great instead of Greta?  I do alllll the time! 

ldcoffel

Greta the Great

T&HLove

solsburyhill:

T&HLove:

I should also add, that I like Frances because of the significance but Marie and Mae were both top middle name choices for my Greta, so it's hard to help you pick

I thought your Greta had Marie as the middle name : )

Do you ever type out Great instead of Greta?  I do alllll the time! 

yes! All the time  

GingerNess

ldcoffel:

All good choices!
I love the sound of Greta Mae.

Hmm. I pick Greta Mae Francis.

This. I think the Gr in Greta is somewhat harsh sounding so the pretty flow of Mae offsets it. However if Francis is the meaningful name, I think your DH had a good suggestion.

Oh and my BFF has two middle names [as well as her two brothers] and they've never had any issues but she does use the middle name that comes first on paperwork and such..so if Francis is more important maybe is should go first to get used more.

But Mae sounds better first...ugh I don't know. I guess I can't help!

GingerNess

Frances ... my phone autocorrected that??

MsCrispy

I'd go with Greta Frances. I don't think it sounds weird, I actually like it. Plus it has meaning. I also like the name Mae, but probably wouldn't do it because of the connection.

I'm not a huge fan of the double middle name. I've heard it can be annoying for official forms. Many forms only ask for a middle initial or only have a slot for one name, so you basically have to pick one.

I also love the name Greta. It was at the top of my list for DD, but DH was iffy on it. Picking names is hard.

SusieBW

PrincessPeach13:

I love your DH's idea.  It flows well and sounds cute.  I don't think there' anything wrong with two middle names.  Especially with the names you gave, because they aren't really long names either.

 eta: and I think Augie and Greta sound adorable together.

I agree with all of this, but especially the bold.   I adore the name Greta.  I think your husband's idea of using both Mae and Frances is excellent.

manda26

I vote 2 mn's

memali26

I am going to be of no help, because I love them all. I lobbied really REALLY hard to name DD2 Greta Marie, but DH didn't love it as a sibset with DD1's name. My girls' MNs are Mae and Marie, so good choices there, too :P

I think I would go with Greta Frances for family meaning. I don't think the flow is bad at all, and agree it's a great "you're in trouble, missy!" middle name.

Tulips114

I think Greta Frances sounds cute. I pick that one because its cute and has meaning for you.

srj88

EmpireMomof3:

Well....I hate double middle names. Sorry to be a Debbie downer. They seem so over the top hey look at me AWish. I like Greta Mae best.

 I agree. I don't get the point of a double middle name. Greta Mae is wonderful!

toriwc

MsCrispy:

I'd go with Greta Frances. I don't think it sounds weird, I actually like it. Plus it has meaning. I also like the name Mae, but probably wouldn't do it because of the connection.

I'm not a huge fan of the double middle name. I've heard it can be annoying for official forms. Many forms only ask for a middle initial or only have a slot for one name, so you basically have to pick one.

 

I agree with all this.

bets2011

I also like Greta Frances, and don't think it sounds weird.

jen4ny

I think Greta Frances sounds just fine. I like Mae a little better but I would probably go with Frances because it has meaning to you. DH and I are big on meaning for middle names.