I don't mind it either and I think it looks very pretty! It's just not the common Edith, and around here these days I don't think that Y would be received well if it was a suggestion for a new baby.
I don't like Edyth if it is pronounced the same as Edith. But I think Edythe if pronounced like Ee-Dithe (long i in the middle) is kind of a nice name in an old school English kind of way.
Re: As seen on Facebook. Not what you think!
Funny!
I wonder if it's pronounced like the normal Edith. Or if it's more like:
Ee-Die-Th/Ee-Dithe. "Die" in the middle, not short "i".
It's actually listed on BTN as a variant of Edith. Not sure about that!
EDYTHE
Variant of EDITH
Rainbow Surprise Baby due 05/26/2017
This was my great grandmother's name. It was pronounced just like Edith.
eta: DH has a relative from that generation named Eloise, pronounced "ee-loyss" though... soooo.. pronunciation may very.