we've hired the back-up that attended the birth. In the end, DH was most comfortable with the person he'd worked with before, and I was pretty neutral. I am excited! We haven't met with her yet, but she's got us scheduled and we'll meet up in a few weeks to sign a contract and talk about things. I think she's actually more experienced than the one I had hired last time, but her rate is about the same ($500), so that's great.
Re: If you were wondering about my doula dilemma...